There are times when the tow pilot and instructor both come to the conclusion that the individual either taking lessons or a rated glider pilot is not performing well enough to merit further instruction or another tow.Decades ago, we had a student (middle aged male) that was taking lessons. He was just not "getting it". It was suggested he "take up something else, like sailing".
Most often there is a safety issue involved that the student or the rated glider pilot is incapable of recognizing their own inability to conform or meet the standard expectation of both or either the tow pilot or instructor.
Safety is the most important issue for all concerned I look forward to hearing from other tow pilots and instructors about this scenario. Old Bob The Purist
There are times when the tow pilot and instructor both come to the conclusion that the individual either taking lessons or a rated glider pilot is not performing well enough to merit further instruction or another tow.
Most often there is a safety issue involved that the student or the rated glider pilot is incapable of recognizing their own inability to conform or meet the standard expectation of both or either the tow pilot or instructor.
Safety is the most important issue for all concerned I look forward to hearing from other tow pilots and instructors about this scenario. Old Bob The Purist
On Monday, April 24, 2023 at 8:31:48 PM UTC-4, youngbl...@gmail.com wrote:pattern on a benign day with a target airspeed of say 50. Think about that - it's only a few knots below VNE. In a 2-22 you're standing on the rudder pedals and the fabric is vibrating like a snare drum.
There are times when the tow pilot and instructor both come to the conclusion that the individual either taking lessons or a rated glider pilot is not performing well enough to merit further instruction or another tow.Many years ago the club I first learned at had a problem student. He was a very intelligent, motivated, quirky, older guy. After say 50 flights he was still wildly inconsistent. On one flight in the club's 2-22 he got up to something like 75 mph in the
Most often there is a safety issue involved that the student or the rated glider pilot is incapable of recognizing their own inability to conform or meet the standard expectation of both or either the tow pilot or instructor.
Safety is the most important issue for all concerned I look forward to hearing from other tow pilots and instructors about this scenario. Old Bob The Purist
I was president of the club (I was still a kid) but I sat in on a couple of the debriefs. On this particular flight the problem student explained that parallax error and reflections off the canopy made the airspeed unreadable, followed in turn by thecoriollis effect and localized gravity waves. After a few more go-rounds like this we had "the conversation" that said he would likely never solo but could fly dual with us as long as he wanted. He stormed off in a huff.
That Winter he went to a well-known "rating mill" down South and managed to get his Private Rating. Not that long after that he joined another club back home. He somehow managed to convince the check pilot(s) that he could fly, even though he madeseveral members nervous including towpilots at the local FBO.
Not long after that, he kited up on tow at a couple of hundred feet. The L-19 was pulled up beyond the critical angle. The ensuing dive was unrecoverable, and we had a dead towpilot. Even after that event the glider pilot blamed the towpilot, the towoperation, and everyone and everything other than himself.
Since that time, a number of the local operations have developed an informal network to warn one another of these problem cases. I for one will never be shy about expressing concerns about students and rated pilots.I remember that "squirrel", and, a couple of us went to the funeral for the towpilot. Kinda hard to crash a L-19 by being out of position, but it is possible as shown.
On Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 9:44:40 AM UTC-4, Papa3 wrote:the pattern on a benign day with a target airspeed of say 50. Think about that - it's only a few knots below VNE. In a 2-22 you're standing on the rudder pedals and the fabric is vibrating like a snare drum.
On Monday, April 24, 2023 at 8:31:48 PM UTC-4, youngbl...@gmail.com wrote:
There are times when the tow pilot and instructor both come to the conclusion that the individual either taking lessons or a rated glider pilot is not performing well enough to merit further instruction or another tow.Many years ago the club I first learned at had a problem student. He was a very intelligent, motivated, quirky, older guy. After say 50 flights he was still wildly inconsistent. On one flight in the club's 2-22 he got up to something like 75 mph in
Most often there is a safety issue involved that the student or the rated glider pilot is incapable of recognizing their own inability to conform or meet the standard expectation of both or either the tow pilot or instructor.
Safety is the most important issue for all concerned I look forward to hearing from other tow pilots and instructors about this scenario. Old Bob The Purist
coriollis effect and localized gravity waves. After a few more go-rounds like this we had "the conversation" that said he would likely never solo but could fly dual with us as long as he wanted. He stormed off in a huff.I was president of the club (I was still a kid) but I sat in on a couple of the debriefs. On this particular flight the problem student explained that parallax error and reflections off the canopy made the airspeed unreadable, followed in turn by the
several members nervous including towpilots at the local FBO.That Winter he went to a well-known "rating mill" down South and managed to get his Private Rating. Not that long after that he joined another club back home. He somehow managed to convince the check pilot(s) that he could fly, even though he made
operation, and everyone and everything other than himself.Not long after that, he kited up on tow at a couple of hundred feet. The L-19 was pulled up beyond the critical angle. The ensuing dive was unrecoverable, and we had a dead towpilot. Even after that event the glider pilot blamed the towpilot, the tow
Since that time, a number of the local operations have developed an informal network to warn one another of these problem cases. I for one will never be shy about expressing concerns about students and rated pilots.I remember that "squirrel", and, a couple of us went to the funeral for the towpilot. Kinda hard to crash a L-19 by being out of position, but it is possible as shown.
We did have a student that was legally blind, but could sorta "see". We would take her up so she could enjoy the feeling of flight even though she would never solo. We felt good about helping her enjoy something we could provide.
Bob:
You are quite correct.
I was for many years the Chief Pilot for a large club and I often had to manage safety questions with this observation:
Sooner or later, the weakest glider pilot in the club will meet the weakest tug pilot in the club - with each at opposite ends of the same rope.
It made me re-think some things, especially about who should solo and who should tow.
ROY
Bob:Roy:
You are quite correct.
I was for many years the Chief Pilot for a large club and I often had to manage safety questions with this observation:
Sooner or later, the weakest glider pilot in the club will meet the weakest tug pilot in the club - with each at opposite ends of the same rope.
It made me re-think some things, especially about who should solo and who should tow.
ROY
On Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 10:34:37 AM UTC-4, Charlie M. (UH, Pi & 002 owner/pilot) wrote:the pattern on a benign day with a target airspeed of say 50. Think about that - it's only a few knots below VNE. In a 2-22 you're standing on the rudder pedals and the fabric is vibrating like a snare drum.
On Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 9:44:40 AM UTC-4, Papa3 wrote:
On Monday, April 24, 2023 at 8:31:48 PM UTC-4, youngbl...@gmail.com wrote:
There are times when the tow pilot and instructor both come to the conclusion that the individual either taking lessons or a rated glider pilot is not performing well enough to merit further instruction or another tow.Many years ago the club I first learned at had a problem student. He was a very intelligent, motivated, quirky, older guy. After say 50 flights he was still wildly inconsistent. On one flight in the club's 2-22 he got up to something like 75 mph in
Most often there is a safety issue involved that the student or the rated glider pilot is incapable of recognizing their own inability to conform or meet the standard expectation of both or either the tow pilot or instructor.
Safety is the most important issue for all concerned I look forward to hearing from other tow pilots and instructors about this scenario. Old Bob The Purist
the coriollis effect and localized gravity waves. After a few more go-rounds like this we had "the conversation" that said he would likely never solo but could fly dual with us as long as he wanted. He stormed off in a huff.I was president of the club (I was still a kid) but I sat in on a couple of the debriefs. On this particular flight the problem student explained that parallax error and reflections off the canopy made the airspeed unreadable, followed in turn by
several members nervous including towpilots at the local FBO.That Winter he went to a well-known "rating mill" down South and managed to get his Private Rating. Not that long after that he joined another club back home. He somehow managed to convince the check pilot(s) that he could fly, even though he made
tow operation, and everyone and everything other than himself.Not long after that, he kited up on tow at a couple of hundred feet. The L-19 was pulled up beyond the critical angle. The ensuing dive was unrecoverable, and we had a dead towpilot. Even after that event the glider pilot blamed the towpilot, the
in the sailplane, a solo student that you were skeptical of prior to solo, a low time know it all that has no concept of towing, and then you have the rated pilot that hasn't flown in a while.Since that time, a number of the local operations have developed an informal network to warn one another of these problem cases. I for one will never be shy about expressing concerns about students and rated pilots.I remember that "squirrel", and, a couple of us went to the funeral for the towpilot. Kinda hard to crash a L-19 by being out of position, but it is possible as shown.
We did have a student that was legally blind, but could sorta "see". We would take her up so she could enjoy the feeling of flight even though she would never solo. We felt good about helping her enjoy something we could provide.There have been a few times when towing a student or rated pilot that I thought hard and long about being in that tow pilots seat. Things happen quickly and if not prepared they can and will be deadly. Here is my scenario's of look out, two instructors
My relationship with our instructors is IMHO fantastic, on many flights the instructor will ask me how the tow went and especially on solo flights the instructor will actually look at me upon landing and ask for a thumbs up or down.
Some very low time and new glider pilots have no concept of tow pilot safety, all they are concerned about is getting them in the air at all cost and that includes a lack of understanding for safety.
Look at it anyway that you like, but the tow pilot is still the PIC, and his or hers word is the final word! If you don't like it get your butt in your motorglider and self launch. Old Bob, The Purist
I have such a student. He started flying around age 70, then got delayed as the pandemic shut down operations for a while. I joined the club and started flying with him. Other instructors got frustrated with his "lack of progress". I'll fly with him.We sat and talked, he fully understands he may never progress to "solo status", but he loves being at the field, helping, taking a lesson (flight), comradery is a big draw. I had him capable of takeoff and flying on tow. I have not had him box the wake
Bill
I have such a student. He started flying around age 70, then got delayed as the pandemic shut down operations for a while. I joined the club and started flying with him. Other instructors got frustrated with his "lack of progress". I'll fly with him.We sat and talked, he fully understands he may never progress to "solo status", but he loves being at the field, helping, taking a lesson (flight), comradery is a big draw. I had him capable of takeoff and flying on tow. I have not had him box the wake
BillI had a guy that took almost 200 flights to solo, I was the tow pilot for his solo flight and I must admit that I was more than a bit concerned. Yes, there have been times when I was concerned, yet he has finally demonstrated that he can stay behind the
On Sunday, April 30, 2023 at 4:28:49 PM UTC-4, Bill Tisdale wrote:We sat and talked, he fully understands he may never progress to "solo status", but he loves being at the field, helping, taking a lesson (flight), comradery is a big draw. I had him capable of takeoff and flying on tow. I have not had him box the wake
I have such a student. He started flying around age 70, then got delayed as the pandemic shut down operations for a while. I joined the club and started flying with him. Other instructors got frustrated with his "lack of progress". I'll fly with him.
We just started the spring flying last week. Spring checkouts and Flight Reviews for rated pilots. We lost this weekend to rain.BillAnd now?
R
I have such a student. He started flying around age 70, then got delayed as the pandemic shut down operations for a while. I joined the club and started flying with him. Other instructors got frustrated with his "lack of progress". I'll fly with him.We sat and talked, he fully understands he may never progress to "solo status", but he loves being at the field, helping, taking a lesson (flight), comradery is a big draw. I had him capable of takeoff and flying on tow. I have not had him box the wake
Bill
We just started the spring flying last week. Spring checkouts and Flight Reviews for rated pilots. We lost this weekend to rain.
Bill
Who checks out the spring checker-outers? Inquiring minds and all..Excellent question Dan, maybe it is the winter wonder glider CFIG's. OBTP
Dan
5J
On 4/30/23 18:44, Bill Tisdale wrote:
We just started the spring flying last week. Spring checkouts and Flight Reviews for rated pilots. We lost this weekend to rain.
Bill
Who checks out the spring checker-outers? Inquiring minds and all..Dan, instructors that have been flying all winter.
Dan
5J
On 4/30/23 18:44, Bill Tisdale wrote:
We just started the spring flying last week. Spring checkouts and Flight Reviews for rated pilots. We lost this weekend to rain.
Bill
Who checks out the spring checker-outers? Inquiring minds and all..
Dan
5J
On 4/30/23 18:44, Bill Tisdale wrote:
We just started the spring flying last week. Spring checkouts and Flight Reviews for rated pilots. We lost this weekend to rain.
Bill
On Monday, May 1, 2023 at 12:24:25 PM UTC-4, Dan Marotta wrote:
Who checks out the spring checker-outers? Inquiring minds and all..Dan, instructors that have been flying all winter.
Dan
5J
On 4/30/23 18:44, Bill Tisdale wrote:
We just started the spring flying last week. Spring checkouts and Flight Reviews for rated pilots. We lost this weekend to rain.
Bill
Bill
Sysop: | Keyop |
---|---|
Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
Users: | 307 |
Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
Uptime: | 114:42:45 |
Calls: | 6,854 |
Files: | 12,355 |
Messages: | 5,416,648 |