Le jeudi 3 août 2023 à 12:41, David Bremner <david@tethera.net> a
écrit :

First, thanks for your efforts so far. It does make me think you
are
probably right, that we can (try to) drop the corresponding
patches.

I do have one question (which might be annoying to answer): do
the
resulting elpa-* packages install with your patched emacs? I
vaguely
remember some issues with post install byte-compilation.

I assume that by "resulting", you mean, those built with my
patched emacs, as opposed to the ones present in the archives,
that is built by archive emacs.

Whether or not those elpa-* packages were build by my patched
emacs or the archive one does not matter : the content of the
resulting package are the same. After all, we only ship source
elisp files and sometimes documentation.

To be certain of that, I modified my previous experiment to
calculate the shasum of the resulting deb files after each build,
and I compared the results between my patched emacs and the
archive one.

I attach the new version of the script, and the results.

You will see that the only packages that produce different results
(geiser marginalia orderless vertico citar consult-el embark) are
the ones that are unreproducible anyway.

So now we can agree that your question is equivalent to "Do the
elpa-* packages from the archive install with my patched emacs ?",
which is easier to answer :).

In order to answer that, I made another experiment. I created two
chroots, one with the archive version of emacs installed
(emacs-nox, more specifically), and one with my patched version
(of emacs-nox again).

I then tried to install each binary package we maintain, in each
of the chroots, and checked whether there was any one of those
binary package that would install in the archive version, and not
in my patched version.

There is only one (elpa-ligature), for reasons entirely unrelated
with byte- or native-compilation (unresolvable dependencies : it
depends on emacs-gtk, that I cannot install in the chroot
containing my patched version of emacs-nox without unreasonably
complicating the implementation of the experiment).

I attach the list of binary packages we maintain, the experiment
script, and the results.

Best,

Aymeric


--=-=-Content-Type: text/plain
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=emacs_build_results

autothemer-el 2 2 0
assess-el 2 2 0
bbdb 0 0 0
adaptive-wrap 0 0 0
ace-popup-menu 0 0 0
ace-window 0 0 0
atomic-chrome-el 0 0 0
beacon 0 0 0
ace-link 0 0 0
avy-menu 0 0 0
apache-mode-el 0 0 0
aggressive-indent-mode 0 0 0
avy 0 0 0
auto-dictionary-mode 0 0 0
a-el 0 0 0
apiwrap-el 0 0 0
beginend-el 2 2 0
bm-el 2 2 0
clojure-mode 2 2 0
circe 2 2 0
bongo 0 0 0
browse-kill-ring-el 0 0 0
bpftrace-mode 0 0 0
boxquote-el 0 0 0
No such package : dash-functional-el
bui-el 0 0 0
char-menu-el 0 0 0
c-sig 0 0 0
company-mode 2 2 0
color-theme-modern 0 0 0
citar 0 0 1
cycle-quotes 2 2 0
crdt-el 0 0 0
consult-el 0 0 1
closql-el 0 0 0
compat-el 0 0 0
dap-mode 0 0 0
debpaste-el 0 0 0
deft 0 0 0
debian-el 0 0 0
devscripts-el 0 0 0
darcsum 0 0 0
csv-mode 0 0 0
dh-make-elpa 0 0 0
dash-el 0 0 0
dh-elpa 0 0 0
diffview-el 0 0 0
diminish-el 0 0 0
dimmer-el 0 0 0
dired-quick-sort 0 0 0
diff-hl-el 0 0 0
No such package : elisp-slime-nav
discover-my-major 0 0 0
dockerfile-mode 0 0 0
dpkg-dev-el 0 0 0
dired-du 0 0 0
ediprolog-el 0 0 0
dired-rsync 0 0 0
el-mock-el 0 0 0
elfeed 2 2 0
dumb-jump-el 2 2 0
editorconfig-emacs 0 0 0
el-x 0 0 0
elisp-bug-hunter 2 2 0
ebib 0 0 0
eglot 0 0 0
elm-mode 0 0 0
elpa-darkroom 0 0 0
elpa-ligature 0 0 0
elpa-rust-mode 0 0 0
elpa-subed 0 0 0
elpa-transient 0 0 0
elpher 0 0 0
emacs-buttercup 2 2 0
emacs-anzu 0 0 0
elscreen 0 0 0
emacs-async 0 0 0
emacs-cmake-mode 0 0 0
elpa-undo-tree 0 0 0
emacs-bash-completion 0 0 0
emacs-corfu 0 0 0
emacs-dashboard 0 0 0
emacs-bind-map 0 0 0
emacs-db 0 0 0
emacs-ctable 0 0 0
elisp-refs 0 0 0
emacs-discomfort 0 0 0
emacs-debase 0 0 0
emacs-goodies-el 0 0 0
emacs-helm-ag 2 2 0
emacs-desktop-notification-center 0 0 0
emacs-fossil 0 0 0
emacs-epc 0 0 0
emacs-doom-themes 0 0 0
emacs-git-modes 0 0 0
emacs-highlight-indentation 0 0 0
emacs-git-messenger 0 0 0
emacs-htmlize 0 0 0
emacs-kv 2 2 0
emacs-deferred 0 0 0
emacs-lsp-haskell 0 0 0
emacs-ivy 0 0 0
elpa-snakemake 0 0 0
emacs-libvterm 0 0 0
emacs-noflet 0 0 0
emacs-openwith 0 0 0
emacs-jabber 0 0 0
emacs-orgalist 0 0 0
emacs-jedi 0 0 0
emacs-memoize 0 0 0
emacs-pass-mode 0 0 0
emacs-neotree 0 0 0
emacs-pg-el 0 0 0
emacs-pdf-tools 0 0 0
emacs-lsp-ui 0 0 0
emacs-pod-mode 0 0 0
emacs-posframe 0 0 0
emacs-powerline 0 0 0
emacs-smeargle 0 0 0
emacs-session 0 0 0
emacs-web-server 2 2 0
emacs-svg-lib 0 0 0
emacs-wgrep 2 2 0
emacs-tablist 0 0 0
emacs-uuid 0 0 0
emacs-request 0 0 0
emacs-python-environment 0 0 0
emacsql 2 2 0
emacs-world-time-mode 0 0 0
emacs-which-key 0 0 0
emacs-websocket 0 0 0
embark 0 0 1
engine-mode 0 0 0
eproject-el 0 0 0
esh-help-el 0 0 0
eshell-bookmark 0 0 0
ement-el 0 0 0
eshell-git-prompt 0 0 0
emacsql-sqlite3 2 2 0
eshell-prompt-extras 0 0 0
ert-expectations-el 0 0 0
epl 0 0 0
ert-async-el 0 0 0
esup-el 2 2 0
eshell-up 0 0 0
eshell-z 0 0 0
exec-path-from-shell-el 0 0 0
f-el 2 2 0
expand-region-el 0 0 0
exwm 0 0 0
esxml 0 0 0
eyebrowse-el 0 0 0
exwm-mff 0 0 0
fill-column-indicator 0 0 0
flycheck 1 1 0
flx 0 0 0
faceup 0 0 0
flycheck-package 0 0 0
ess 2 2 0
folding-mode-el 0 0 0
evil-el 0 0 0
find-file-in-project 0 0 0
ggtags 0 0 0
geiser 0 0 1
ghub-el 0 0 0
git-annex-el 0 0 0
fountain-mode 0 0 0
ghub-plus-el 0 0 0
go-mode.el 2 2 0
fsm-el 0 0 0
git-timemachine 0 0 0
git-auto-commit-mode 0 0 0
golden-ratio-el 0 0 0
goto-chg-el 0 0 0
graphviz-dot-mode 0 0 0
gitlab-ci-mode-el 0 0 0
haskell-mode 2 2 0
gnuplot-mode 2 2 0
helm-org 0 0 0
helm-projectile 0 0 0
graphql-el 0 0 0
helm 0 0 0
helpful-el 2 2 0
highlight-numbers-el 0 0 0
hl-todo-el 0 0 0
hungry-delete-el 0 0 0
ido-ubiquitous 2 2 0
ibuffer-projectile 0 0 0
ibuffer-vc 0 0 0
ht-el 0 0 0
hydra-el 0 0 0
imenu-list 0 0 0
initsplit-el 0 0 0
js2-mode 2 2 0
jinja2-mode 0 0 0
irony-mode 2 2 0
iedit 0 0 0
ido-vertical-mode 0 0 0
ilisp 0 0 0
key-chord-el 0 0 0
let-alist 0 0 0
linum-relative 0 0 0
ledger-mode 0 0 0
lua-mode 2 2 0
lsp-java 0 0 0
lsp-mode 2 2 0
load-relative-el 0 0 0
kotlin-mode 0 0 0
lsp-treemacs 0 0 0
loop-el 0 0 0
magit-popup 0 0 0
m-buffer-el 0 0 0
makey 0 0 0
magit-todos 0 0 0
marginalia 0 0 1
magit 0 0 0
meson-mode 0 0 0
message-templ 0 0 0
minimap-el 0 0 0
modus-themes 0 0 0
magit-forge-el 0 0 0
magit-annex 0 0 0
mocker-el 0 0 0
monokai-emacs 0 0 0
markdown-mode 0 0 0
mastodon-el 0 0 0
mpv.el 0 0 0
move-text-el 0 0 0
mutt-alias-el 0 0 0
nginx-mode 0 0 0
muttrc-mode-el 0 0 0
nose-el 0 0 0
no-littering-el 0 0 0
nov-el 0 0 0
maildir-utils 0 0 0
ol-notmuch 0 0 0
olivetti-mode 0 0 0
orderless 0 0 1
org-appear 0 0 0
org-bullets 0 0 0
org-contrib 0 0 0
org-drill 0 0 0
org-present 0 0 0
org-tree-slide 0 0 0
org-roam 2 2 0
org-make-toc 0 0 0
ox-texinfo-plus 0 0 0
page-break-lines-el 0 0 0
paredit-el 0 0 0
paredit-everywhere 0 0 0
org-mode 0 0 0
parent-mode-el 0 0 0
package-lint-el 0 0 0
persp-projectile 0 0 0
pcre2el 0 0 0
parsebib 0 0 0
persist-el 0 0 0
php-elisp 2 2 0
perspective-el 0 0 0
pfuture-el 0 0 0
pip-requirements-el 0 0 0
pointback 0 0 0
popup-el 0 0 0
projectile 2 2 0
pos-tip 0 0 0
project-el 0 0 0
plz-el 0 0 0
py-autopep8-el 0 0 0
pkg-info-el 0 0 0
No such package : rg-el
pyvenv-el 2 2 0
pyim-basedict-el 0 0 0
py-isort-el 0 0 0
rainbow-delimiters 2 2 0
qml-mode 0 0 0
queue-el 0 0 0
puppet-mode 0 0 0
rainbow-identifiers-el 0 0 0
rainbow-mode 0 0 0
recursive-narrow 0 0 0
redtick 0 0 0
pyim-el 0 0 0
rich-minority 0 0 0
scala-mode-el 2 2 0
relint-el 0 0 0
restart-emacs 0 0 0
smart-mode-line 0 0 0
smex 0 0 0
solarized-emacs 0 0 0
sml-mode 0 0 0
s-el 0 0 0
srv-el 0 0 0
spinner-el 0 0 0
sesman 0 0 0
seq-el 0 0 0
shut-up 0 0 0
super-save-el 0 0 0
system-packages-el 2 2 0
sxiv-el 0 0 0
suggest-el 0 0 0
tabbar-el 0 0 0
transmission-el 0 0 0
taxy-el 0 0 0
taxy-magit-section-el 0 0 0
vala-mode-el 0 0 0
verilog-mode 3 3 0
systemd-el 0 0 0
treepy-el 0 0 0
undercover-el 0 0 0
vertico 0 0 1
vimish-fold 0 0 0
rtags 0 0 0
use-package 0 0 0
volume-el 0 0 0
visual-regexp-el 0 0 0
wc-mode 0 0 0
treemacs 0 0 0
with-simulated-input-el 2 2 0
with-editor 0 0 0
visual-fill-column 0 0 0
writegood-mode 0 0 0
virtualenvwrapper-el 0 0 0
web-mode 0 0 0
weechat-el 0 0 0
xcite 0 0 0
writeroom-mode 0 0 0
xcscope-el 0 0 0
yaml-el 2 2 0
xref-el 0 0 0
xelb 0 0 0
ws-butler 0 0 0
yasnippet 2 2 0
yaml-mode 0 0 0
xr-el 0 0 0
xml-rpc-el 0 0 0
zenburn-emacs 0 0 0
ztree 0 0 0
zzz-to-char 0 0 0
yasnippet-snippets 0 0 0
racket-mode 0 0 0

--=-=-Content-Type: text/x-sh
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=test_emacs_build.sh

#!/bin/sh

# Attempts to build the package provided as argument
# First only with the archive
# Second with the .deb files in the directory pointed by variable DEB_EXTRA_PACKAGES

# And compare the results ; on the standard output is written :
# - the name of the source package
# - the return value of the first attempt
# - the return value of the second attempt

if test $# -lt 1; then
echo "Missing argument : source package"
exit 1
fi

# The directory holding the modified versions of emacs, set to a correct value DEB_EXTRA_PACKAGES=/home/rico/temp/emacs
TEMP_DIRECTORY=$(mktemp -d)

cd $TEMP_DIRECTORY

apt source -t sid --only-source --download-only $1 1>/dev/null 2>/dev/null

dscfile=$(find . -name "*.dsc")

if test "$dscfile" = ""; then
echo "No such package : $1"
cd
rm -rf $TEMP_DIRECTORY
exit 1
fi

# First attempt
sbuild -d unstable --chroot=unstable-amd64-sbuild --no-run-lintian --no-run-piuparts $dscfile 1>/dev/null 2>/dev/null
first_attempt="$?"
shasum ./*.deb > first_attempt_shasum
rm -f ./*.deb

# Second attempt
sbuild -d unstable --chroot=unstable-amd64-sbuild --no-run-lintian --no-run-piuparts --extra-package=$DEB_EXTRA_PACKAGES $dscfile 1>/dev/null 2>/dev/null
second_attempt="$?"
shasum ./*.deb > second_attempt_shasum
rm -f ./*.deb

diff -q first_attempt_shasum second_attempt_shasum 1>/dev/null 2>/dev/null identical="$?"

echo "$1 $first_attempt $second_attempt $identical"

cd

rm -rf $TEMP_DIRECTORY


--=-=-Content-Type: text/plain
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=emacs_install_results

dh-elpa-helper 0 0
bbdb 0 0
elpa-adaptive-wrap 0 0
c-sig 0 0
elpa-a 0 0
elpa-aggressive-indent 0 0
darcsum 0 0
elpa-ace-window 0 0
elpa-ace-link 0 0
elpa-ace-popup-menu 0 0
elpa-anzu 0 0
elpa-apache-mode 0 0
elpa-apiwrap 0 0
elpa-async 0 0
elpa-auto-dictionary 0 0
elpa-avy 0 0
elpa-assess 0 0
elpa-autothemer 0 0
elpa-beacon 0 0
elpa-atomic-chrome 0 0
elpa-beginend 0 0
elpa-avy-menu 0 0
elpa-bash-completion 0 0
elpa-bind-key 0 0
dh-elpa 0 0
elpa-bm 0 0
elpa-bind-chord 0 0
elpa-boxquote 0 0
elpa-bpftrace-mode 0 0
elpa-browse-kill-ring 0 0
elpa-bongo 0 0
elpa-buttercup 0 0
elpa-bug-hunter 0 0
elpa-bui 0 0
elpa-ac-rtags 0 0
elpa-bind-map 0 0
debian-el 0 0
elpa-circe 0 0
elpa-clojure-mode 0 0
elpa-cmake-mode 0 0
elpa-char-menu 0 0
dpkg-dev-el 0 0
elpa-clojure-mode-extra-font-locking 0 0
elpa-closql 0 0
elpa-company 0 0
elpa-color-theme-modern 0 0
elpa-concurrent 0 0
elpa-compat 0 0
elpa-crdt 0 0
elpa-c-sig 0 0
elpa-csv-mode 0 0
elpa-ctable 0 0
elpa-cycle-quotes 0 0
elpa-corfu 0 0
elpa-darcsum 0 0
elpa-darkroom 0 0
elpa-dash 0 0
elpa-debase 0 0
elpa-db 0 0
elpa-deferred 0 0
elpa-counsel 0 0
elpa-deft 0 0
elpa-debpaste 0 0
elpa-diff-hl 0 0
elpa-diffview 0 0
elpa-diminish 0 0
elpa-dimmer 0 0
elpa-dired-du 0 0
elpa-consult 0 0
elpa-dockerfile-mode 0 0
elpa-discomfort 0 0
elpa-company-rtags 0 0
elpa-doom-themes 0 0
elpa-discover-my-major 0 0
elpa-dired-quick-sort 0 0
elpa-dired-rsync 0 0
elpa-elfeed-web 100 100
elpa-editorconfig 0 0
elpa-ednc 0 0
elpa-ebib 0 0
elpa-elisp-refs 0 0
elpa-el-mock 0 0
elpa-elpher 0 0
elpa-debian-el 0 0
elpa-eglot 0 0
elpa-elfeed 0 0
elpa-el-x 0 0
elpa-dumb-jump 0 0
elpa-elm-mode 0 0
elpa-emacsql 0 0
elpa-elscreen 0 0
elpa-ediprolog 0 0
dh-make-elpa 0 0
elpa-emacsql-mysql 0 0
elpa-emacs-dashboard 0 0
elpa-emacsql-sqlite 0 0
elpa-emacsql-psql 0 0
elpa-citar 100 100
elpa-engine-mode 0 0
elpa-emacsql-sqlite3 0 0
elpa-epl 0 0
elpa-ert-async 0 0
devscripts-el 0 0
elpa-dpkg-dev-el 0 0
elpa-eshell-bookmark 0 0
elpa-ert-expectations 0 0
elpa-eshell-prompt-extras 0 0
elpa-eshell-up 0 0
elpa-eshell-z 0 0
elpa-epc 0 0
elpa-esup 0 0
elpa-esxml 0 0
elpa-esh-help 0 0
elpa-exec-path-from-shell 0 0
elpa-expand-region 0 0
elpa-faceup 0 0
elpa-fill-column-indicator 0 0
elpa-eshell-git-prompt 0 0
elpa-eyebrowse 0 0
elpa-evil 0 0
elpa-embark 0 0
elpa-ement 0 0
elpa-f 0 0
elpa-flx 0 0
elpa-flx-ido 0 0
elpa-eproject 0 0
elpa-fsm 0 0
elpa-folding 0 0
elpa-geiser 0 0
elpa-find-file-in-project 0 0
elpa-fountain-mode 0 0
elpa-exwm 0 0
elpa-git-auto-commit-mode 0 0
elpa-flycheck 0 0
elpa-exwm-mff 0 0
elpa-ghub 0 0
elpa-gitlab-ci-mode 0 0
elpa-ggtags 0 0
elpa-git-messenger 0 0
elpa-gitattributes-mode 0 0
elpa-ghub+ 0 0
elpa-golden-ratio 0 0
elpa-flycheck-package 0 0
elpa-git-commit 0 0
elpa-devscripts 0 0
elpa-git-timemachine 0 0
elpa-gitconfig-mode 0 0
elpa-goto-chg 0 0
elpa-graphql 0 0
elpa-gitignore-mode 0 0
elpa-git-annex 0 0
elpa-git-modes 0 0
elpa-helm-core 0 0
elpa-flycheck-rtags 0 0
elpa-graphviz-dot-mode 0 0
elpa-go-mode 0 0
elpa-highlight-indentation 0 0
elpa-highlight-numbers 0 0
elpa-haskell-mode 100 100
elpa-helm 0 0
elpa-ht 0 0
elpa-hungry-delete 0 0
elpa-htmlize 0 0
elpa-hl-todo 0 0
elpa-helpful 0 0
elpa-ibuffer-vc 0 0
elpa-ido-vertical-mode 0 0
elpa-iedit 0 0
elpa-hydra 0 0
elpa-imenu-list 0 0
elpa-ibuffer-projectile 0 0
elpa-initsplit 0 0
elpa-helm-ag 0 0
elpa-ess 0 0
elpa-helm-org 0 0
elpa-ido-completing-read+ 0 0
elpa-ivy 0 0
elpa-jinja2-mode 0 0
elpa-helm-projectile 0 0
elpa-key-chord 0 0
elpa-irony 0 0
elpa-kotlin-mode 0 0
elpa-kv 0 0
elpa-ivy-hydra 0 0
elpa-jabber 0 0
elpa-ledger 0 0
elpa-let-alist 0 0
elpa-linum-relative 0 0
elpa-load-relative 0 0
elpa-loop 0 0
elpa-helm-rtags 0 0
elpa-lua-mode 0 0
elpa-ivy-rtags 0 0
elpa-js2-mode 0 0
elpa-lv 0 0
elpa-dap-mode 0 0
elpa-gnuplot-mode 0 0
elpa-helm-virtualenvwrapper 0 0
elpa-magit-section 0 0
elpa-magit-popup 0 0
elpa-makey 0 0
elpa-ligature 0 100
elpa-markdown-mode 0 0
elpa-memoize 0 0
elpa-m-buffer 0 0
elpa-marginalia 0 0
elpa-jedi-core 0 0
elpa-mastodon 0 0
elpa-meson-mode 0 0
elpa-message-templ 0 0
elpa-minimap 0 0
elpa-lsp-mode 0 0
elpa-mocker 0 0
elpa-monokai-theme 0 0
elpa-move-text 0 0
elpa-modus-themes 0 0
elpa-muttrc-mode 0 0
elpa-neotree 0 0
elpa-jedi 0 0
elpa-nginx-mode 0 0
elpa-magit 0 0
elpa-lsp-haskell 100 100
elpa-noflet 0 0
elpa-olivetti 0 0
elpa-no-littering 0 0
elpa-nov 0 0
elpa-mutt-alias 0 0
elpa-openwith 0 0
elpa-orderless 0 0
elpa-orgalist 0 0
elpa-org-appear 0 0
elpa-org-bullets 0 0
elpa-nose 0 0
elpa-org-present 0 0
elpa-org-drill 0 0
elpa-org-tree-slide 100 100
elpa-org-make-toc 0 0
elpa-ox-texinfo+ 0 0
elpa-page-break-lines 0 0
elpa-paredit 0 0
elpa-package-lint 0 0
elpa-magit-annex 0 0
elpa-package-lint-flymake 0 0
elpa-lsp-ui 0 0
elpa-org-roam 0 0
elpa-parent-mode 0 0
elpa-paredit-everywhere 0 0
elpa-parsebib 0 0
elpa-org 100 100
elpa-persist 0 0
elpa-pcre2el 0 0
elpa-ol-notmuch 100 100
elpa-perspective 0 0
elpa-org-contrib 100 100
elpa-pfuture 0 0
elpa-pg 0 0
elpa-magit-todos 0 0
elpa-php-mode 0 0
elpa-pdf-tools-server 0 0
elpa-pkg-info 0 0
elpa-plz 0 0
elpa-persp-projectile 0 0
elpa-pointback 100 100
elpa-pod-mode 0 0
elpa-popup 0 0
elpa-pip-requirements 0 0
elpa-posframe 0 0
elpa-pos-tip 0 0
elpa-pdf-tools 0 0
elpa-powerline 0 0
elpa-projectile 0 0
elpa-project 0 0
elpa-puppet-mode 0 0
elpa-qml-mode 0 0
elpa-queue 0 0
elpa-rainbow-delimiters 0 0
elpa-rainbow-identifiers 0 0
elpa-pyim 0 0
elpa-rainbow-mode 0 0
elpa-recursive-narrow 0 0
elpa-pyim-basedict 0 0
elpa-lsp-treemacs 0 0
elpa-racket-mode 0 0
elpa-py-autopep8 0 0
elpa-redtick 0 0
elpa-restart-emacs 0 0
elpa-py-isort 0 0
elpa-rich-minority 0 0
elpa-relint 0 0
elpa-request 0 0
elpa-rust-mode 0 0
elpa-s 0 0
elpa-scala-mode 0 0
elpa-seq 0 0
elpa-sesman 0 0
elpa-session 0 0
elpa-shut-up 0 0
elpa-python-environment 0 0
elpa-simple-httpd 0 0
elpa-smart-mode-line 0 0
elpa-smeargle 0 0
elpa-smex 0 0
elpa-pyvenv 0 0
elpa-snakemake-mode 0 0
elpa-sml-mode 0 0
elpa-spinner 0 0
elpa-snakemake 100 100
elpa-srv 0 0
elpa-rtags 0 0
elpa-smart-mode-line-powerline-theme 0 0
elpa-super-save 0 0
elpa-svg-lib 0 0
elpa-mpv 100 100
elpa-systemd 0 0
elpa-system-packages 0 0
elpa-tabbar 0 0
elpa-tablist 0 0
elpa-swiper 0 0
elpa-pass 0 0
elpa-solarized-theme 0 0
elpa-taxy 0 0
elpa-transient 0 0
elpa-transient-doc 0 0
elpa-suggest 0 0
elpa-transmission 0 0
elpa-treepy 0 0
elpa-taxy-magit-section 0 0
elpa-undo-tree 0 0
elpa-undercover 0 0
elpa-use-package 0 0
elpa-uuid 0 0
elpa-vala-mode 0 0
elpa-vc-fossil 0 0
elpa-visual-fill-column 0 0
elpa-use-package-ensure-system-package 0 0
elpa-visual-regexp 0 0
elpa-vertico 0 0
elpa-use-package-chords 0 0
elpa-volume 0 0
elpa-wc-mode 0 0
elpa-vterm 0 0
elpa-vimish-fold 0 0
elpa-web-mode 0 0
elpa-websocket 0 0
elpa-magit-forge 0 0
elpa-wgrep 0 0
elpa-sxiv 0 0
elpa-wgrep-ack 0 0
elpa-wgrep-ag 0 0
elpa-wgrep-helm 0 0
elpa-which-key 0 0
elpa-with-simulated-input 0 0
elpa-world-time-mode 0 0
elpa-writegood-mode 0 0
elpa-weechat 0 0
elpa-with-editor 0 0
elpa-ws-butler 0 0
elpa-writeroom-mode 0 0
elpa-virtualenvwrapper 0 0
elpa-xcite 0 0
elpa-xcscope 0 0
elpa-xml-rpc 0 0
elpa-xr 0 0
elpa-xref 0 0
elpa-yaml-mode 0 0
elpa-zenburn-theme 0 0
elpa-treemacs 0 0
elpa-ztree 0 0
elpa-xelb 0 0
elpa-zzz-to-char 0 0
elpa-yasnippet 0 0
elpa-yasnippet-snippets 0 0
emacs-libvterm 0 0
elscreen 0 0
expand-region-el 0 0
geiser 0 0
ilisp 0 0
ilisp-doc 0 0
flycheck-doc 0 0
irony-server 0 0
golang-mode 0 0
haskell-mode 100 100
maildir-utils 0 0
elpa-treemacs-projectile 0 0
elpa-lsp-java 0 0
scala-mode-el 0 0
js2-mode 0 0
verilog-mode 0 0
sml-mode 0 0
vala-mode-el 0 0
mu4e 0 0
xcite 0 0
xcscope-el 0 0
org-roam-doc 0 0
elpa-treemacs-evil 0 0
elpa-yaml 0 0
rtags 0 0
elpa-subed 0 0
yasnippet 0 0
org-mode 100 100
gnuplot-mode 0 0
elpa-treemacs-magit 0 0
emacs-goodies-el 0 0

--=-=-Content-Type: text/plain
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=paquets_debian_emacsen_binaires

bbdb
c-sig
darcsum
debian-el
devscripts-el
dh-elpa
dh-elpa-helper
dh-make-elpa
dpkg-dev-el
elpa-a
elpa-ace-link
elpa-ace-popup-menu
elpa-ace-window
elpa-ac-rtags
elpa-adaptive-wrap
elpa-aggressive-indent
elpa-anzu
elpa-apache-mode
elpa-apiwrap
elpa-assess
elpa-async
elpa-atomic-chrome
elpa-auto-dictionary
elpa-autothemer
elpa-avy
elpa-avy-menu
elpa-bash-completion
elpa-beacon
elpa-beginend
elpa-bind-chord
elpa-bind-key
elpa-bind-map
elpa-bm
elpa-bongo
elpa-boxquote
elpa-bpftrace-mode
elpa-browse-kill-ring
elpa-bug-hunter
elpa-bui
elpa-buttercup
elpa-char-menu
elpa-circe
elpa-citar
elpa-clojure-mode
elpa-clojure-mode-extra-font-locking
elpa-closql
elpa-cmake-mode
elpa-color-theme-modern
elpa-company
elpa-company-rtags
elpa-compat
elpa-concurrent
elpa-consult
elpa-corfu
elpa-counsel
elpa-crdt
elpa-c-sig
elpa-csv-mode
elpa-ctable
elpa-cycle-quotes
elpa-dap-mode
elpa-darcsum
elpa-darkroom
elpa-dash
elpa-db
elpa-debase
elpa-debian-el
elpa-debpaste
elpa-deferred
elpa-deft
elpa-devscripts
elpa-diff-hl
elpa-diffview
elpa-diminish
elpa-dimmer
elpa-dired-du
elpa-dired-quick-sort
elpa-dired-rsync
elpa-discomfort
elpa-discover-my-major
elpa-dockerfile-mode
elpa-doom-themes
elpa-dpkg-dev-el
elpa-dumb-jump
elpa-ebib
elpa-ediprolog
elpa-editorconfig
elpa-ednc
elpa-eglot
elpa-elfeed
elpa-elfeed-web
elpa-elisp-refs
elpa-elm-mode
elpa-el-mock
elpa-elpher
elpa-elscreen
elpa-el-x
elpa-emacs-dashboard
elpa-emacsql
elpa-emacsql-mysql
elpa-emacsql-psql
elpa-emacsql-sqlite
elpa-emacsql-sqlite3
elpa-embark
elpa-ement
elpa-engine-mode
elpa-epc
elpa-epl
elpa-eproject
elpa-ert-async
elpa-ert-expectations
elpa-eshell-bookmark
elpa-eshell-git-prompt
elpa-eshell-prompt-extras
elpa-eshell-up
elpa-eshell-z
elpa-esh-help
elpa-ess
elpa-esup
elpa-esxml
elpa-evil
elpa-exec-path-from-shell
elpa-expand-region
elpa-exwm
elpa-exwm-mff
elpa-eyebrowse
elpa-f
elpa-faceup
elpa-fill-column-indicator
elpa-find-file-in-project
elpa-flx
elpa-flx-ido
elpa-flycheck
elpa-flycheck-package
elpa-flycheck-rtags
elpa-folding
elpa-fountain-mode
elpa-fsm
elpa-geiser
elpa-ggtags
elpa-ghub
elpa-ghub+
elpa-git-annex
elpa-gitattributes-mode
elpa-git-auto-commit-mode
elpa-git-commit
elpa-gitconfig-mode
elpa-gitignore-mode
elpa-gitlab-ci-mode
elpa-git-messenger
elpa-git-modes
elpa-git-timemachine
elpa-gnuplot-mode
elpa-golden-ratio
elpa-go-mode
elpa-goto-chg
elpa-graphql
elpa-graphviz-dot-mode
elpa-haskell-mode
elpa-helm
elpa-helm-ag
elpa-helm-core
elpa-helm-org
elpa-helm-projectile
elpa-helm-rtags
elpa-helm-virtualenvwrapper
elpa-helpful
elpa-highlight-indentation
elpa-highlight-numbers
elpa-hl-todo
elpa-ht
elpa-htmlize
elpa-hungry-delete
elpa-hydra
elpa-ibuffer-projectile
elpa-ibuffer-vc
elpa-ido-completing-read+
elpa-ido-vertical-mode
elpa-iedit
elpa-imenu-list
elpa-initsplit
elpa-irony
elpa-ivy
elpa-ivy-hydra
elpa-ivy-rtags
elpa-jabber
elpa-jedi
elpa-jedi-core
elpa-jinja2-mode
elpa-js2-mode
elpa-key-chord
elpa-kotlin-mode
elpa-kv
elpa-ledger
elpa-let-alist
elpa-ligature
elpa-linum-relative
elpa-load-relative
elpa-loop
elpa-lsp-haskell
elpa-lsp-java
elpa-lsp-mode
elpa-lsp-treemacs
elpa-lsp-ui
elpa-lua-mode
elpa-lv
elpa-magit
elpa-magit-annex
elpa-magit-forge
elpa-magit-popup
elpa-magit-section
elpa-magit-todos
elpa-makey
elpa-marginalia
elpa-markdown-mode
elpa-mastodon
elpa-m-buffer
elpa-memoize
elpa-meson-mode
elpa-message-templ
elpa-minimap
elpa-mocker
elpa-modus-themes
elpa-monokai-theme
elpa-move-text
elpa-mpv
elpa-mutt-alias
elpa-muttrc-mode
elpa-neotree
elpa-nginx-mode
elpa-noflet
elpa-no-littering
elpa-nose
elpa-nov
elpa-olivetti
elpa-ol-notmuch
elpa-openwith
elpa-orderless
elpa-org
elpa-orgalist
elpa-org-appear
elpa-org-bullets
elpa-org-contrib
elpa-org-drill
elpa-org-make-toc
elpa-org-present
elpa-org-roam
elpa-org-tree-slide
elpa-ox-texinfo+
elpa-package-lint
elpa-package-lint-flymake
elpa-page-break-lines
elpa-paredit
elpa-paredit-everywhere
elpa-parent-mode
elpa-parsebib
elpa-pass
elpa-pcre2el
elpa-pdf-tools
elpa-pdf-tools-server
elpa-persist
elpa-perspective
elpa-persp-projectile
elpa-pfuture
elpa-pg
elpa-php-mode
elpa-pip-requirements
elpa-pkg-info
elpa-plz
elpa-pod-mode
elpa-pointback
elpa-popup
elpa-posframe
elpa-pos-tip
elpa-powerline
elpa-project
elpa-projectile
elpa-puppet-mode
elpa-py-autopep8
elpa-pyim
elpa-pyim-basedict
elpa-py-isort
elpa-python-environment
elpa-pyvenv
elpa-qml-mode
elpa-queue
elpa-racket-mode
elpa-rainbow-delimiters
elpa-rainbow-identifiers
elpa-rainbow-mode
elpa-recursive-narrow
elpa-redtick
elpa-relint
elpa-request
elpa-restart-emacs
elpa-rich-minority
elpa-rtags
elpa-rust-mode
elpa-s
elpa-scala-mode
elpa-seq
elpa-sesman
elpa-session
elpa-shut-up
elpa-simple-httpd
elpa-smart-mode-line
elpa-smart-mode-line-powerline-theme
elpa-smeargle
elpa-smex
elpa-sml-mode
elpa-snakemake
elpa-snakemake-mode
elpa-solarized-theme
elpa-spinner
elpa-srv
elpa-subed
elpa-suggest
elpa-super-save
elpa-svg-lib
elpa-swiper
elpa-sxiv
elpa-systemd
elpa-system-packages
elpa-tabbar
elpa-tablist
elpa-taxy
elpa-taxy-magit-section
elpa-transient
elpa-transient-doc
elpa-transmission
elpa-treemacs
elpa-treemacs-evil
elpa-treemacs-magit
elpa-treemacs-projectile
elpa-treepy
elpa-undercover
elpa-undo-tree
elpa-use-package
elpa-use-package-chords
elpa-use-package-ensure-system-package
elpa-uuid
elpa-vala-mode
elpa-vc-fossil
elpa-vertico
elpa-vimish-fold
elpa-virtualenvwrapper
elpa-visual-fill-column
elpa-visual-regexp
elpa-volume
elpa-vterm
elpa-wc-mode
elpa-web-mode
elpa-websocket
elpa-weechat
elpa-wgrep
elpa-wgrep-ack
elpa-wgrep-ag
elpa-wgrep-helm
elpa-which-key
elpa-with-editor
elpa-with-simulated-input
elpa-world-time-mode
elpa-writegood-mode
elpa-writeroom-mode
elpa-ws-butler
elpa-xcite
elpa-xcscope
elpa-xelb
elpa-xml-rpc
elpa-xr
elpa-xref
elpa-yaml
elpa-yaml-mode
elpa-yasnippet
elpa-yasnippet-snippets
elpa-zenburn-theme
elpa-ztree
elpa-zzz-to-char
elscreen
emacs-goodies-el
emacs-libvterm
expand-region-el
flycheck-doc
geiser
gnuplot-mode
golang-mode
haskell-mode
ilisp
ilisp-doc
irony-server
js2-mode
maildir-utils
mu4e
org-mode
org-roam-doc
rtags
scala-mode-el
sml-mode
vala-mode-el
verilog-mode
xcite
xcscope-el
yasnippet

--=-=-Content-Type: text/x-sh
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=test_emacs_install.sh

#!/bin/sh

# Attempts to install the package provided as argument in two different chroots.
# The first one has got the archive version of emacs installed
# The second one has got the patched version of emacs installed

# The setting up of those chroots is out of the scope of this script.

# On the standard output is written :
# - the name of the binary package
# - the return value of the first attempt
# - the return value of the second attempt

if test $# -lt 1; then
echo "Missing argument : binary package"
exit 1
fi

# Fix with your own chroot names

schroot -d /tmp -u root -c unstable-amd64test-archive-emacs -- apt install -y $1
first_attempt="$?"

schroot -d /tmp -u root -c unstable-amd64test-patched-emacs -- apt install -y $1
second_attempt="$?"

echo "$1 $first_attempt $second_attempt"

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

Hello,

On Thu 03 Aug 2023 at 07:40am +02, Aymeric Agon-Rambosson wrote:

tl;dr : The changes introduced by Andrea Corallo following said discussion have made patches 12 and 13 (the rebased version of Lars Ingebrigsten commits)
useless, so we should drop them.

In fact, I thought that this was the unanimous conclusion of the discussion, hence my mail to Sean from yesterday where I enquired as to why patches 12 and
13 were still present.

For context, the earlier version of patches 12 and 13 were introduced to solve
a series of FTBFS bugs we had with various elpa-* packages (see #1021842, for instance). Those bugs happened roughly like so :

1. Whenever a primitive (a function available from elisp, but implemented in C) is advised, it is necessary to compile a trampoline to allow to jump dynamically to the native-compiled definition of the advice, which could be anywhere on the user's system.
2. Said trampoline needs to be output to a file.
3. The job of function comp--trampoline-abs-filename is to find a directory in
which to store this file, and return it.
4. This search was made from a list of candidates (think /usr/lib/emacs/29.1/native-lisp or ~/.emacs.d/eln-cache).
5. If no such candidate was available, either because they were unwritable (the former) or because they did not exist (the latter, in our build environments), the function errored out, which caused our bug.

Thank you for the investigation.

My conception of the environment variable is a bit broader than just
this particular bug: I think that it is a good idea to be able to switch
off native compilation in the way this environment variable permits.
So I am inclined to keep the patches.

--
Sean Whitton

--=-=-Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQJNBAEBCgA3FiEEm5FwB64DDjbk/CSLaVt65L8GYkAFAmTM2LgZHHNwd2hpdHRv bkBzcHdoaXR0b24ubmFtZQAKCRBpW3rkvwZiQIg4D/9MtFYGhipcof1rN00chcE2 HrE/ngxHvQyhblq5ae4q6euYt9OF8d9vquYTHz5JZ6EzTzyGEpDiMmsfyU873IE/ 6dnfUSaw3sLSHlzI9Tp10mZb4osLsDhoE5rfeGxEgE8OV2OKmJUt5i3jbaMLD3yK OfdJI8hxWKiUw+ROwarhsuwnPM6kMjb1Hg4EIywknU8NA/0Gk7gLjHTrrwyFQtSs jZnfIJx0zi1K+kxgWagoMdvHHfmfBq67nZEd2xIHaW4R203T8GvW1bbjkeS3K3Fo AkPsRS80+mBlRcROKHWBdTwdx6OPqr4tdtB7ge2Q7d2UXaKtXpzwsmfE4d7BT7/j RmKYQRlEBuCmyWMLfV53xUt2s5OLGXCFBk44IrKsu0esqNBuEzb8EfWwvia+5Gc8 g3bJKBVVFBWFuEA7zah68V7NOxDMyxxCz8yIs7OOn266HIlClhGUoYNiyfQq2hI7 Aa/a4dpEo+wkMn9eTQFlOBbCE1S5ipM1PkvwMwZ5uZmxANE9AQxeFTXjeW+XejGQ JcvNgPlwUevX4uYHRmNXDWdS81nBg2m6Nnx44o4Vl6mwu0+NMO78OrtSeJ2/GOGM ScvlAdQnN4ZmpvMSVyLjqj9cZmpDScxPLeLXQuZV7r3Mvqm3iYkHDyA5x77sL/6d A+QfhWnEmY4uGik5XLZyOA==vwh9
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Us

Aymeric Agon-Rambosson <aymeric.agon@yandex.com> writes:

For this reason, I have in my fork (https://salsa.debian.org/ricorambo/deb-emacs) a branch (rico-without-lars-patch) that simply drops patches 12 and 13.

The experiment is the following : for every package maintained by
the debian-emacsen team, a build is attempted with the version of
emacs in current sid, and another is attempted with the version of
emacs from my fork.

If the patches were really useful, there would be at least some
elpa-* package that would build correctly on the first attempt,
and FTBFS on the second.

First, thanks for your efforts so far. It does make me think you are
probably right, that we can (try to) drop the corresponding patches.

I do have one question (which might be annoying to answer): do the
resulting elpa-* packages install with your patched emacs? I vaguely
remember some issues with post install byte-compilation.

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

Le vendredi 4 août 2023 à 11:53, Sean Whitton
<spwhitton@spwhitton.name> a écrit :

My conception of the environment variable is a bit broader than
just
this particular bug: I think that it is a good idea to be able
to switch
off native compilation in the way this environment variable
permits.

Except... The patches do no such thing.

The patches do *not*, I repeat, do *not* switch off native
compilation.

The *only* thing these patches do is :
- If inhibit-automatic-native-compilation (very misleading
variable name indeed) is t, then trampolines are output in a
temporary file.
- If inhibit-automatic-native-compilation is nil, then trampolines
are output in the first available candidate directory, OR in a
temporary directory if no suitable candidate was found.

This is *all* they do, despite the name of the variable that seems
to promise so much more. You see what I mean when I say they are
useless. With or without the patch, in our build environment, we
end up doing the exact same thing : outputting our trampolines to
a file somewhere in /tmp.

You can check this by looking at all the places where the content
of this variable is actually used. You will find that it is only
used in the function comp--trampoline-abs-filename, to do what I
described you it does previously.

Now, if you want to "switch off native compilation", which I agree
is a convenient thing to be able to do, you have two variables
that *really* do something :
- native-comp-jit-compilation, that controls whether loaded .elc
files are asynchronously compiled. Note that this does *not*
include trampolines : even if this variable is nil, trampolines
are still compiled.
- native-comp-enable-subr-trampolines, that controls whether or
not the trampolines are compiled, and where they are
output. Sean, this is the variable I discussed the semantic of
with Andrea. Now, we do *not* want to disable trampoline
compilation, lest we accept to render all advices on primitive
functions null and void (which will cause quite a lot of FTBFS
bugs, many packages advise primitives as part of their
testbed). The docstring of this variable explains this in more
detail.

Controlling these two variables with environment variables
requires only a patch like the following :


--=-=-Content-Type: text/x-diff
Content-Disposition: inline; filename=envvar.patch

diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index d6e1c23fa28..3f89df0f119 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -595,6 +595,9 @@ It is the default value of the variable `top-level'."
(setq user-emacs-directory
(startup--xdg-or-homedot startup--xdg-config-home-emacs nil))

+ (setq native-comp-jit-compilation (getenv "DEBIAN_ENABLE_NATIVE_COMP_JIT"))
+ (setq native-comp-enable-subr-trampolines (getenv "DEBIAN_ENABLE_NATIVE_COMP_TRAMPOLINES"))
+
(when (featurep 'native-compile)
(unless (native-comp-available-p)
;; Disable deferred async compilation and trampoline synthesis

--=-=-Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed


Which is much simpler than the ones we have now, and actually does
what we want to do.

We would then simply have :

$ENV{'DEBIAN_ENABLE_NATIVE_COMP_JIT'} = 'nil';

in the relevant emacsen-common scripts instead of the current :

$ENV{'EMACS_INHIBIT_AUTOMATIC_NATIVE_COMPILATION'} = 't';

Sean, this is what I meant when I said we should let upstream
focus on the semantic of elisp variables, and ju

Little correction on what I wrote earlier. Sorry about that, I
should have been more careful.

Le vendredi 4 août 2023 à 18:49, Aymeric Agon-Rambosson <aymeric.agon@yandex.com> a écrit :

The *only* thing these patches do is :
- If inhibit-automatic-native-compilation (very misleading
variable name
indeed) is t, then trampolines are output in a temporary
file.
- If inhibit-automatic-native-compilation is nil, then
trampolines are output
in the first available candidate directory, OR in a
temporary directory if
no suitable candidate was found.

This is *all* they do, despite the name of the variable that
seems to promise so
much more. You see what I mean when I say they are useless. With
or without the
patch, in our build environment, we end up doing the exact same
thing :
outputting our trampolines to a file somewhere in /tmp.

You can check this by looking at all the places where the
content of this
variable is actually used. You will find that it is only used in
the function
comp--trampoline-abs-filename, to do what I described you it
does previously.

That is not entirely true. The C variable Vinhibit_automatic_native_compilation, corresponding to elisp
variable inhibit-automatic-native-compilation, is effectively used
to disable native compilation of loaded elc files.

The patch remains useless nonetheless : this (partial) disabling
of native compilation is redundant with the one already provided
by variable native-comp-jit-compilation.

In fact, if you look at this part of the patch :


--=-=-Content-Type: text/x-diff
Content-Disposition: inline; filename=redundant.patch

diff --git a/src/comp.c b/src/comp.c
index 59c9e9619a3..06ddb956bb5 100644
--- a/src/comp.c
+++ b/src/comp.c
@@ -5179,6 +5179,7 @@ maybe_defer_native_compilation (Lisp_Object function_name,
return;

if (!native_comp_jit_compilation
+ || !NILP (Vinhibit_native_compilation)
|| noninteractive
|| !NILP (Vpurify_flag)
|| !COMPILEDP (definition)

--=-=-Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed


You will notice that the first two boolean conditions are
redundant : native_comp_jit_compilation already does what Vinhibit_native_compilation wants to do, albeit with an inverted
meaning.

So, let me correct myself ; the patch does not do one, but two
useless things :
- it provides a mechanism to output trampolines to a temporary
location, despite the fact that there already is one that does
the same thing.
- it duplicates variable native-comp-jit-compilation to
inhibit-automatic-native-compilation, simply flipping its
meaning.

The rest of what I wrote about us just needing the little patch I
provided to control the relevant v

Hello,

On Fri 04 Aug 2023 at 09:08pm +02, Aymeric Agon-Rambosson wrote:

That is not entirely true. The C variable Vinhibit_automatic_native_compilation, corresponding to elisp variable inhibit-automatic-native-compilation, is effectively used to disable native compilation of loaded elc files.

The patch remains useless nonetheless : this (partial) disabling of native compilation is redundant with the one already provided by variable native-comp-jit-compilation.

In fact, if you look at this part of the patch :

diff --git a/src/comp.c b/src/comp.c
index 59c9e9619a3..06ddb956bb5 100644
--- a/src/comp.c
+++ b/src/comp.c
@@ -5179,6 +5179,7 @@ maybe_defer_native_compilation (Lisp_Object function_name,
return;

if (!native_comp_jit_compilation
+ || !NILP (Vinhibit_native_compilation)
|| noninteractive
|| !NILP (Vpurify_flag)
|| !COMPILEDP (definition)

You will notice that the first two boolean conditions are redundant : native_comp_jit_compilation already does what Vinhibit_native_compilation wants to do, albeit with an inverted meaning.

But the patch allows it to be done using an env var. There is no env
var corresponding to the new Vnative_comp_jit_compilation. And the env
var is needed so that we can be sure it's turned off early enough.

So, while it would be tidier to rework the patch to avoid introducing a
second variable, its functionality is still useful.

--
Sean Whitton

--=-=-Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQJNBAEBCgA3FiEEm5FwB64DDjbk/CSLaVt65L8GYkAFAmTPzHcZHHNwd2hpdHRv bkBzcHdoaXR0b24ubmFtZQAKCRBpW3rkvwZiQIkKD/41WUnjQjVbxvA6ZcWDWlEu pBMxHuGEtZB2dp6yRnDR9FsHLPOUlSmRcvu2oQGg7WIWBbYC62J1lFwiZFa+akmX LBsvb9TJdKbfcQch1lmDzBi8nW21U4KQsB1xUCXA0jFqsxkko3cwVsiUW7pbSrOS rks/11eF57NN7vFfBM17u2HLNwrv9/j4I1morhx0WOs/GIGM5/f9XZEF+fdESVmJ 6mSFZO+WjI6gbUZWV8UjKWFjHIhQU8eslXsW7Q4SMC4LJvi/SiIfuFP6NnBv0GtW c9EVkp4Fs7XsuwYSLYSLfYskIbT3QVIXPd8eMRmWD+HbEeypaBA5025/Sh8dzSLF 1JX86DfNGJm294c3TFy81hiaJMu9WfH3BXa3bfNmW5SdwcJ8b1rcIbMCQzU8K0rh zx0ZoN9FhkgLfKOq3GR08BVzzxQ4AZz4jncqHn8CWoh2rEkFeG2YMebe6waVgo/t /NWoksC9rBVEIBkmUsZSewG0ZHecJrLyQWpAmM/thZEOM8xLb7z4r/hRHKQFa3Aq +Sk2uXf+uxM/jn0UEqQDGGLtKRU+r+A5FKeh6oDAefMWIOW6A9Eo4ZZXaxSJYtTj /uJ/be8+znMehBZnTdAv6lPfbg4t6NpWZJsHevgNYOHPVn2tndHctP3ltp56+nPy mpaE9evJkZpn77XPXpMQNw=®96
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usen

Le dimanche 6 août 2023 à 17:38, Sean Whitton
<spwhitton@spwhitton.name> a écrit :

But the patch allows it to be done using an env var. There is
no env
var corresponding to the new Vnative_comp_jit_compilation. And
the env
var is needed so that we can be sure it's turned off early
enough.

Exactly, so we can just add the envvar with the two-line patch
that I sent :


--=-=-Content-Type: text/x-diff
Content-Disposition: inline; filename=envvar.patch

diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index d6e1c23fa28..3f89df0f119 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -595,6 +595,9 @@ It is the default value of the variable `top-level'."
(setq user-emacs-directory
(startup--xdg-or-homedot startup--xdg-config-home-emacs nil))

+ (setq native-comp-jit-compilation (getenv "DEBIAN_ENABLE_NATIVE_COMP_JIT"))
+ (setq native-comp-enable-subr-trampolines (getenv "DEBIAN_ENABLE_NATIVE_COMP_TRAMPOLINES"))
+
(when (featurep 'native-compile)
(unless (native-comp-available-p)
;; Disable deferred async compilation and trampoline synthesis

--=-=-Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed

So, while it would be tidier to rework the patch to avoid
introducing a
second variable, its functionality is still useful.

The only part of the patches that adds something that is not
already there is the part that adds the envvar.

The useful functionality of these patches can therefore be
entirely achieved with the two-line patch that I sent.

It is not only tidier, it is also equivalent