• Re: Industrial Battereis

    From Theo@21:1/5 to John Rumm on Thu Dec 7 13:59:15 2023
    John Rumm <see.my.signature@nowhere.null> wrote:
    I find the bulk packs of either Energiser or Philips batts from CPC work
    out quite well - decent life and reasonable price.

    (I have got a box of their own brand "Proelec" to try - but not used
    those yet so won't comment).

    I've been using Proelec AAAs and they've been fine. Don't really use them regularly enough to compare with any other type (most hungry devices now
    have integrated lithium ion cells, which leaves primary batteries for
    low-drain low-use things like remote controls and such).

    Theo

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Jeff Layman@21:1/5 to The Natural Philosopher on Thu Dec 7 16:26:00 2023
    On 07/12/2023 10:42, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 10:39, Jeff Layman wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 10:17, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 09:35, Paul wrote:
    On 12/7/2023 3:23 AM, Jeff Layman wrote:
    On 06/12/2023 22:37, Tim Streater wrote:
    On 06 Dec 2023 at 21:23:36 GMT, "alan_m" <junk@admac.myzen.co.uk>
    wrote:

    For batteries in my wireless temperature sensors in the fridge and >>>>>>> freezer I use Energiser Ultimate Lithium. Although expensive they >>>>>>> work
    down to -40C whereas alkaline batteries are unreliable in the
    freezer as
    they are only specified to -20C

    I use these in the sensors for my garage doors. They have the
    longest life of
    any I've tried so far.

    They have some interesting chemistry inside...
    <https://www.youtube.com/shorts/yGDkiUAwxRs>


    The datasheet makes no specific mention of
    what would happen in a long term immersion of
    a battery. They don't want the contents exposed
    to water, and that's why the thing has the layers
    that it does. But I don't see anything guaranteeing
    against the cell eventually being penetrated by
    water internally.

    Lithium Primary cell.

    https://data.energizer.com/pdfs/lithiuml91l92_appman.pdf

    2 Li(s) + 2 H2O -> 2 LiOH (aq) + H2(g)   [Exothermic]

    What makes you think that there is any lithium *metal* in the cells at
    all?

    Because there is a small amount - less than 1g according to:
    <https://batteryspecialists.com.au/blogs/news/everything-there-is-to-know-about-the-energizer-lithium-battery>
    (This agrees with the product data sheet, which says the battery
    contains less than 1g. The SDS says it contains about 6% of lithium or
    lithium alloy. As the AA weighs about 15g, this confirms the lithium
    content)

    No. 'less than' does not equal 'equal'.

    The lithium is in the electrolyte, as a salt.

    Partially correct. The SDS at <https://data.energizer.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Lithium-FeS2-AIS-SDS-01-23.pdf>
    states it contains "Lithium iodide - 0.3-3%". But it also states:
    "Lithium or Lithium Alloy - 6.3-6.6% / AA 5.4-5.5% / AAA"
    and
    "In case of fire where lithium batteries are present, flood area with
    water or smother with a Class D fire extinguishant appropriate for
    lithium metal"

    Finally, from <https://data.energizer.com/pdfs/lithiuml91l92_appman.pdf>: Battery Description: Cylindrical lithium iron disulfide batteries use
    lithium for the anode, iron disulfide for the cathode, and a lithium
    salt in an organic solvent blend as the electrolyte. From the diagram
    showing cutaway construction: Anode - lithium metal

    --

    Jeff

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Clive Arthur@21:1/5 to The Natural Philosopher on Thu Dec 7 16:55:10 2023
    On 07/12/2023 10:17, The Natural Philosopher wrote:

    <snip>

    What makes you think that there is any lithium *metal* in the cells at all?

    Lithium primary cells do, or at least did, coin/button cells and the
    like. Lithium metal anode. Also, the specialist high-temperature
    (180'C, expensive!) Lithium cells do, certainly.

    --
    Cheers
    Clive

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Paul@21:1/5 to The Natural Philosopher on Thu Dec 7 15:30:26 2023
    On 12/7/2023 5:42 AM, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 10:39, Jeff Layman wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 10:17, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 09:35, Paul wrote:
    On 12/7/2023 3:23 AM, Jeff Layman wrote:
    On 06/12/2023 22:37, Tim Streater wrote:
    On 06 Dec 2023 at 21:23:36 GMT, "alan_m" <junk@admac.myzen.co.uk> wrote: >>>>>>
    For batteries in my wireless temperature sensors in the fridge and >>>>>>> freezer I use Energiser Ultimate Lithium. Although expensive they work >>>>>>> down to -40C whereas alkaline batteries are unreliable in the freezer as
    they are only specified to -20C

    I use these in the sensors for my garage doors. They have the longest life of
    any I've tried so far.

    They have some interesting chemistry inside...
    <https://www.youtube.com/shorts/yGDkiUAwxRs>


    The datasheet makes no specific mention of
    what would happen in a long term immersion of
    a battery. They don't want the contents exposed
    to water, and that's why the thing has the layers
    that it does. But I don't see anything guaranteeing
    against the cell eventually being penetrated by
    water internally.

    Lithium Primary cell.

    https://data.energizer.com/pdfs/lithiuml91l92_appman.pdf

    2 Li(s) + 2 H2O -> 2 LiOH (aq) + H2(g)   [Exothermic]

    What makes you think that there is any lithium *metal* in the cells at all? >>
    Because there is a small amount - less than 1g according to:
    <https://batteryspecialists.com.au/blogs/news/everything-there-is-to-know-about-the-energizer-lithium-battery>
    (This agrees with the product data sheet, which says the battery contains less than 1g. The SDS says it contains about 6% of lithium or lithium alloy. As the AA weighs about 15g, this confirms the lithium content)

    No. 'less than' does not equal 'equal'.

    The lithium is in the electrolyte, as a salt.


    But you saw the Youtube video, right ?

    You saw the alkali metal response to water.

    We don't know what the exact (layered) setup
    of the foil is, but at a guess, the outside layer
    is an alkali metal. Maybe the substrate of the
    foil, tends to be flammable. (Or, it could be
    the chemical residue on the ribbon, which
    aids in the response.)

    That's a more vigorous response than the one you
    get in schooling, where they take a piece of
    sodium from sodium-under-oil jar, and drop that
    into water. How that one differs, is it is not
    self-igniting as easily. Other materials in that
    series of the periodic table, are more energetic.

    We also had a TV series, shown on Saturday mornings,
    where they walk through the entire periodic table, demonstrating
    the elements. And you get to see the vigorous reactions
    of some of them.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Showalter

    "In 1988 Showalter became the series demonstrator in a 26-program
    PBS education series by Annenberg/CPB, The World of Chemistry,
    opposite with series host, Nobel prize winner Roald Hoffmann.
    While Hoffmann introduced a series of concepts and ideas, Showalter
    provided a series of demonstrations and other visual representations
    to help students and viewers to better understand the information."

    https://archive.org/stream/TheWorldOfChemistry/The%20World%20Of%20Chemistry/07%20-%20The%20Periodic%20Table/World%20of%20Chemistry%20-%20Transcript%2007%20-%20The%20Periodic%20Table_djvu.txt

    We call this family the alkali metals.
    They make up Group 1 in the periodic
    table. The first element is lithium, and
    then there's sodium, and potassium.
    Down here is rubidium, and this one is
    cesium. And do you notice anything that
    they all have in common? You probably
    see that they're all stored in very
    unusual ways.

    I'm gonna take
    a piece of this lithium and put it into the
    water. And watch what happens, how it
    Starts to fizz a little bit. The fizzing now
    is the reaction of lithium with the water
    to produce hydrogen gas. Let's try the
    sodium. I'll get a small piece of that,
    not too big, because we don't want the
    reaction to be too violent. Oh, that
    reacts much faster, doesn't it? See the
    sodium bouncing around there, again
    fizzing, giving off that hydrogen gas.
    Okay. Let's try potassium, the most
    reactive of the three. I'll get a small
    piece of that and put it into the water.
    Wow! That really reacted violently.
    Did you see the immediate reaction of
    the potassium? Again, it's formed that
    hydrogen gas and the hydrogen gas was
    ignited.

    Using a thin ribbon, having a decent surface
    area, accelerates the reaction. If the foil
    continued to be rolled up, the reaction
    could not consume the material with the same
    speed, which is where some of the "safety"
    comes from.

    Paul

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Clive Arthur@21:1/5 to John Walliker on Thu Dec 7 22:37:05 2023
    On 07/12/2023 18:07, John Walliker wrote:
    On Thursday 7 December 2023 at 16:55:30 UTC, Clive Arthur wrote:
    On 07/12/2023 10:17, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
    <snip>
    What makes you think that there is any lithium *metal* in the cells at all? >> Lithium primary cells do, or at least did, coin/button cells and the
    like. Lithium metal anode. Also, the specialist high-temperature
    (180'C, expensive!) Lithium cells do, certainly.

    I wonder how they stop the lithium from melting in the battery at those temperatures? Li has a melting point of 180.5 deg C?
    John

    I don't know (and I doubt they'd tell me). Some of them can go up to
    200'C - maybe the construction is such that being liquid doesn't matter?
    Certainly liquid Sodium is used in some cell types, but they don't
    work when the Sodium is frozen.

    https://electrochemsolutions.com/products/primary-lithium-cells/moderate-rate-lithium-cells/default.aspx

    Battery packs made with this type of cell are often used in pairs, one
    new one and one partially used one. Initially, the partially depleted
    battery is used, and when it's just about empty, a circuit switches the
    fresh one in. That way you don't waste very expensive energy by
    throwing away batteries with some life left in them.

    --
    Cheers
    Clive

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Mark@21:1/5 to Pamela on Wed Dec 20 23:26:45 2023
    Pamela wrote:

    On 21:30 6 Dec 2023, Graham. said:
    "Jeff Gaines" <jgnewsid@outlook.com> Wrote in message:

    I tend to buy industrial batteries (AA & AAA) because they are a fair
    bit cheaper than consumer batteries.I am beginning to think they
    don't last as long, any views?-- Jeff Gaines Dorset UKThere are 3
    types of people in this world. Those who can count, and those who
    can't.

    If we are talking about Energizer alkerline cells, even the
    manufacturer makes no claim "Industrial" is anything other than a
    marketing/labelling strategy.

    I had the general impression that professional cells are designed for a longer working life but won't provide as much current when called for. However PowerCurious.com claims pro cells provide more current.

    https://powercurious.com/duracell-procell-vs-coppertop-batteries/

    Maybe comparing manufacturer's data sheets would help.

    Like the OP, I don't find pro cells are noticeably better.
    I don't find pro cells are noticeably better.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From alan_m@21:1/5 to Mark on Thu Dec 21 09:42:54 2023
    On 20/12/2023 23:26, Mark wrote:
    Pamela wrote:

    On 21:30 6 Dec 2023, Graham. said:
    "Jeff Gaines" <jgnewsid@outlook.com> Wrote in message:

    I tend to buy industrial batteries (AA & AAA) because they are a fair
    bit cheaper than consumer batteries.I am beginning to think they
    don't last as long, any views?-- Jeff Gaines Dorset UKThere are 3
    types of people in this world. Those who can count, and those who
    can't.

    If we are talking about Energizer alkerline cells, even the
    manufacturer makes no claim "Industrial" is anything other than a
    marketing/labelling strategy.

    I had the general impression that professional cells are designed for a
    longer working life but won't provide as much current when called for.
    However PowerCurious.com claims pro cells provide more current.

    https://powercurious.com/duracell-procell-vs-coppertop-batteries/

    Maybe comparing manufacturer's data sheets would help.

    With Duracell industrial, and consumer branded, there are a range of
    batteries aimed at either extremely low power (such as for a year or two
    in clocks) or higher power outputs.

    That link seems to be a vey hand-wavy comparison often going off at a
    tangent and comparing alkaline with lithium rather than comparing
    industrial with consumer branding of the same type. No figures are given
    to back up the comparisons. The claim that consumer batteries are
    cheaper than industrial is not my experience but this may be that
    industrial are sold by warehouse type retailers rather than supermarkets.

    My problem I've had with Duracell (alkaline) procell/industrial is that
    they now leak badly when getting towards the end of their life. This
    didn't happen with their batteries 10+years ago so possibly a change in production in the intervening years. That fact the branding of the
    batteries changed from Procell to Industrial and now back to Procell may suggest Industrial started to get a bad reputation.

    As is common with most big brands they seem to regularly change ownership.

    --
    mailto : news {at} admac {dot} myzen {dot} co {dot} uk

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)