A couple of months ago, somebody (I don't remember who) called on
non-Muslim American women to wear a headscarf in public to show
solidarity with Muslim women who believe their religion requires them to
wear a scarf or veil in public. Yesterday a couple of Muslim women with non-standard views about hijab wrote an article objecting to this
movement. That article was published in the Washington Post, here:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2015/12/21/as-muslim-women-we-actually-ask-you-not-to-wear-the-hijab-in-the-name-of-interfaith-solidarity/
A Muslim woman who wears hijab (Saba Syed, who is usually called Umm
Reem) responded to this article here:
http://muslimmatters.org/2015/12/27/this-muslim-woman-asks-you-not-to-undermine-hijab/#comment-148254
I responded to the second article for two reasons. First, everything
that I have learned about Islam here and elsewhere in the past 25 years
tells me that Umm Reem's response is solidly grounded in majority
Islamic beliefs and thinking. It's also unusually well written.
Second and more important to me, as a non-Muslim American woman I've
been watching with horror at growing anti-Islamic bigotry in America.
Too many Americans confuse Islam with the extremist beliefs of
terrorists. They are conflating ordinary Muslims and extremist terrorism supporters into a single undifferentiated group.
In other words, many Americans now are ignorant, scared, and are acting
as Americans often have in the past when ignorant and scared -- turning
on scapegoats. :/ This behavior is a threat not just to Muslims, but to America itself.
This was what I posted in response to the second article, with a couple
of fixes for skipped words and typos (I hit "post" too fast) :):
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
I'm not Muslim; I'm Orthodox Christian. I'm tolerably familiar with
Islam and Muslims after 20+ years moderating a forum about Islam,
though. This is a *very* well written, mainstream response to a
non-orthodox (small "o") Islamic view on the obligation of Muslim women
to wear a head covering. I'd urge my fellow Christians and other
American women to pay attention, especially if you have considered
wearing a headscarf in solidarity with American Muslim women.
In my opinion, the value of a non-Muslim American wearing a headscarf
goes beyond signaling solidarity with Muslim women who believe they are obligated to do so. It signals our agreement as Americans with the First Amendment to the US Constitution, which guarantees religious liberty and provides the foundation for separating the roles of religion and
government. It signals that we do not confuse Islam with terrorism, or approve of blaming all members of a religion because a few members of
that religion are murderous bigots. For Christians, it signals our own awareness that we too have murderous bigots among us and don't want to
be judged with them simply because we are Christian.
The degree of hatred that political figures and many ordinary Americans
have expressed recently against normal, garden-variety Muslims is
terrible, and terrifying to those who recognize it for what it is. It's
the ugly counterexample that shows up any time normal Americans feel threatened by outsiders. In the past, this fear has led to segregation
and hatred of indigenous Americans ("American Indians"), the descendants
of African slaves, and immigrants ranging from the Irish during the
potato famine, Italians and eastern Europeans (many of them Jews) in the early 20th century, and Japanese Americans during the second World War.
This ignorance- and fear-generated bigotry is a threat not just to
Muslim women, and not just to all Muslims, but to the American
experiment. Through it we have alienated and driven from this country
people who would otherwise have made significant, valuable contributions
to our society and culture. One of those was W. E. B. DuBois, the first African American graduate of Harvard University and one of America's
great authors and philosophers. DuBois ended his life as an exile in
Africa, having left the country of his birth and greatest achievements
in despair because so many Americans could not find it in their minds or hearts to accept him as an equal -- a fellow citizen and human being.
You'd think we would learn from our mistakes. You'd think people would
see the same pattern when dealing with fellow Americans and immigrants
whose ancestors came from China, Japan, south Asia and the Middle East.
Some of us seem to lack that ability. :/
I don't urge all of my fellow non-Muslim American women to wear
headscarves in public. That might not be your role or how you express
your support for people under siege. But I do urge you to realize the importance of speaking up and being counted.
--
Catherine Jefferson <tw86034@ergosphere.net>
Blog/Personal: http://www.ergosphere.net
Qur'anic verses have frequently been used to overstep their intended
bounds, so why not interpret them to obtain some leaway. That the
verses should b interpreted in historic context ('asba:bu~l-nuzu:l - "Reason's for Revelation") and adapted using reason is also
established practice. That is a matter of faith and interpretation I
won't pass judgement on.
A couple of months ago, somebody (I don't remember who) called on-women-we-actually-ask-you-not-to-wear-the-hijab-in-the-name-of-interfaith-= solidarity/
non-Muslim American women to wear a headscarf in public to show
solidarity with Muslim women who believe their religion requires them to
wear a scarf or veil in public. Yesterday a couple of Muslim women with non-standard views about hijab wrote an article objecting to this
movement. That article was published in the Washington Post, here:
=20
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2015/12/21/as-muslim=
=20ermine-hijab/#comment-148254
A Muslim woman who wears hijab (Saba Syed, who is usually called Umm
Reem) responded to this article here:
=20
http://muslimmatters.org/2015/12/27/this-muslim-woman-asks-you-not-to-und=
=20
I responded to the second article for two reasons. First, everything
that I have learned about Islam here and elsewhere in the past 25 years
tells me that Umm Reem's response is solidly grounded in majority
Islamic beliefs and thinking. It's also unusually well written.
=20
Second and more important to me, as a non-Muslim American woman I've
been watching with horror at growing anti-Islamic bigotry in America.
Too many Americans confuse Islam with the extremist beliefs of
terrorists. They are conflating ordinary Muslims and extremist terrorism supporters into a single undifferentiated group.
=20
In other words, many Americans now are ignorant, scared, and are acting
as Americans often have in the past when ignorant and scared -- turning
on scapegoats. :/ This behavior is a threat not just to Muslims, but to America itself.
=20
This was what I posted in response to the second article, with a couple
of fixes for skipped words and typos (I hit "post" too fast) :):
=20
=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D-=3D
=20
I'm not Muslim; I'm Orthodox Christian. I'm tolerably familiar with
Islam and Muslims after 20+ years moderating a forum about Islam,
though. This is a *very* well written, mainstream response to a
non-orthodox (small "o") Islamic view on the obligation of Muslim women
to wear a head covering. I'd urge my fellow Christians and other
American women to pay attention, especially if you have considered
wearing a headscarf in solidarity with American Muslim women.
=20
In my opinion, the value of a non-Muslim American wearing a headscarf
goes beyond signaling solidarity with Muslim women who believe they are obligated to do so. It signals our agreement as Americans with the First
Amendment to the US Constitution, which guarantees religious liberty and provides the foundation for separating the roles of religion and
government. It signals that we do not confuse Islam with terrorism, or approve of blaming all members of a religion because a few members of
that religion are murderous bigots. For Christians, it signals our own awareness that we too have murderous bigots among us and don't want to
be judged with them simply because we are Christian.
=20
The degree of hatred that political figures and many ordinary Americans
have expressed recently against normal, garden-variety Muslims is
terrible, and terrifying to those who recognize it for what it is. It's
the ugly counterexample that shows up any time normal Americans feel threatened by outsiders. In the past, this fear has led to segregation
and hatred of indigenous Americans ("American Indians"), the descendants
of African slaves, and immigrants ranging from the Irish during the
potato famine, Italians and eastern Europeans (many of them Jews) in the early 20th century, and Japanese Americans during the second World War.
=20
This ignorance- and fear-generated bigotry is a threat not just to
Muslim women, and not just to all Muslims, but to the American
experiment. Through it we have alienated and driven from this country
people who would otherwise have made significant, valuable contributions
to our society and culture. One of those was W. E. B. DuBois, the first African American graduate of Harvard University and one of America's
great authors and philosophers. DuBois ended his life as an exile in
Africa, having left the country of his birth and greatest achievements
in despair because so many Americans could not find it in their minds or hearts to accept him as an equal -- a fellow citizen and human being.
=20
You'd think we would learn from our mistakes. You'd think people would
see the same pattern when dealing with fellow Americans and immigrants
whose ancestors came from China, Japan, south Asia and the Middle East.
Some of us seem to lack that ability. :/
=20
I don't urge all of my fellow non-Muslim American women to wear
headscarves in public. That might not be your role or how you express
your support for people under siege. But I do urge you to realize the importance of speaking up and being counted.
=20
=20
--=20
Catherine Jefferson <tw86034@ergosphere.net>
Blog/Personal: http://www.ergosphere.net
On 12/28/2015 2:04 AM, Yusuf B Gursey wrote:
Qur'anic verses have frequently been used to overstep their intended bounds, so why not interpret them to obtain some leaway. That the=20
verses should b interpreted in historic context ('asba:bu~l-nuzu:l - "Reason's for Revelation") and adapted using reason is also
established practice. That is a matter of faith and interpretation I
won't pass judgement on.
<snip, but read>
=20
This all makes sense to me. But I'm not Muslim, so it isn't my job to
figure out what the Qur'an or Islam teaches others to do. (It wouldn't
be my job if I *were* Muslim.) However, there's no doubt that many
Muslim women believe that wearing hijab is mandatory -- the majority, as
best I can tell.
=20
Unfortunately, wearing a headscarf in public in 21st century America
(and Europe, and many other countries) makes a Muslim woman stand out in
ways that a beard does not make a Muslim man stand out. Beards are
fairly common in America. I don't know whether anybody has done a formal study, but anecdotal evidence seems to suggest that traditional Muslim
women who wear traditional headscarves attract the lion's share of
attacks from bigots. This certainly has been the case among those I know.
=20
My post wasn't really about Islam or Muslims. It was about a problem
with how the mostly non-Muslim citizens of my country, the United States
A couple of months ago, somebody (I don't remember who) called on
non-Muslim American women to wear a headscarf in public to show
solidarity with Muslim women who believe their religion requires them to
wear a scarf or veil in public. Yesterday a couple of Muslim women with non-standard views about hijab wrote an article objecting to this
movement. That article was published in the Washington Post, here:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2015/12/21/as-muslim-women-we-actually-ask-you-not-to-wear-the-hijab-in-the-name-of-interfaith-solidarity/
A Muslim woman who wears hijab (Saba Syed, who is usually called Umm
Reem) responded to this article here:
http://muslimmatters.org/2015/12/27/this-muslim-woman-asks-you-not-to-undermine-hijab/#comment-148254
I responded to the second article for two reasons. First, everything
that I have learned about Islam here and elsewhere in the past 25 years
tells me that Umm Reem's response is solidly grounded in majority
Islamic beliefs and thinking. It's also unusually well written.
Second and more important to me, as a non-Muslim American woman I've
been watching with horror at growing anti-Islamic bigotry in America.
Too many Americans confuse Islam with the extremist beliefs of
terrorists. They are conflating ordinary Muslims and extremist terrorism supporters into a single undifferentiated group.
In other words, many Americans now are ignorant, scared, and are acting
as Americans often have in the past when ignorant and scared -- turning
on scapegoats. :/ This behavior is a threat not just to Muslims, but to America itself.
This was what I posted in response to the second article, with a couple
of fixes for skipped words and typos (I hit "post" too fast) :):
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
I'm not Muslim; I'm Orthodox Christian. I'm tolerably familiar with
Islam and Muslims after 20+ years moderating a forum about Islam,
though. This is a *very* well written, mainstream response to a
non-orthodox (small "o") Islamic view on the obligation of Muslim women
to wear a head covering. I'd urge my fellow Christians and other
American women to pay attention, especially if you have considered
wearing a headscarf in solidarity with American Muslim women.
In my opinion, the value of a non-Muslim American wearing a headscarf
goes beyond signaling solidarity with Muslim women who believe they are obligated to do so. It signals our agreement as Americans with the First Amendment to the US Constitution, which guarantees religious liberty and provides the foundation for separating the roles of religion and
government. It signals that we do not confuse Islam with terrorism, or approve of blaming all members of a religion because a few members of
that religion are murderous bigots. For Christians, it signals our own awareness that we too have murderous bigots among us and don't want to
be judged with them simply because we are Christian.
The degree of hatred that political figures and many ordinary Americans
have expressed recently against normal, garden-variety Muslims is
terrible, and terrifying to those who recognize it for what it is. It's
the ugly counterexample that shows up any time normal Americans feel threatened by outsiders. In the past, this fear has led to segregation
and hatred of indigenous Americans ("American Indians"), the descendants
of African slaves, and immigrants ranging from the Irish during the
potato famine, Italians and eastern Europeans (many of them Jews) in the early 20th century, and Japanese Americans during the second World War.
This ignorance- and fear-generated bigotry is a threat not just to
Muslim women, and not just to all Muslims, but to the American
experiment. Through it we have alienated and driven from this country
people who would otherwise have made significant, valuable contributions
to our society and culture. One of those was W. E. B. DuBois, the first African American graduate of Harvard University and one of America's
great authors and philosophers. DuBois ended his life as an exile in
Africa, having left the country of his birth and greatest achievements
in despair because so many Americans could not find it in their minds or hearts to accept him as an equal -- a fellow citizen and human being.
You'd think we would learn from our mistakes. You'd think people would
see the same pattern when dealing with fellow Americans and immigrants
whose ancestors came from China, Japan, south Asia and the Middle East.
Some of us seem to lack that ability. :/
I don't urge all of my fellow non-Muslim American women to wear
headscarves in public. That might not be your role or how you express
your support for people under siege. But I do urge you to realize the importance of speaking up and being counted.
--
Catherine Jefferson <tw86034@ergosphere.net>
Blog/Personal: http://www.ergosphere.net
Sysop: | Keyop |
---|---|
Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
Users: | 296 |
Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
Uptime: | 75:06:48 |
Calls: | 6,657 |
Calls today: | 3 |
Files: | 12,203 |
Messages: | 5,332,640 |
Posted today: | 1 |