XPost: alt.fan.rush-limbaugh, alt.politics.democrats, stl.general
XPost: talk.politics.guns

On 06 Mar 2022, Yak <yak@inbox1.com> posted some news:t03b1n$277o4$81@news.freedyn.de:

edell@post.com wrote

Send her ass to Chicago to work with Lori Lightweight.

Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey’s bid to oust St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kim Gardner will continue.

Judge John Torbitzky on Tuesday denied most of Gardner’s motion to dismiss what’s known as a quo warranto.

“The number of alleged incidents and cases impacted, particularly when considering all of the allegations in each of these counts together, and
in combination with the allegations that the examples are part of a
pattern and practice of conduct, gives rise to a reasonable inference that [Gardner] has intentionally failed to act contrary to a known duty,”
Torbitzky wrote. “The facts alleged in the petition also permit the
reasonable inference that [Gardner] was aware of occurrences in her office
and yet took no action.”

Gardner’s spokeswoman did not immediately return a request for comment on Torbitzky’s orders.

Bailey spokeswoman Madeline Sieren said he was “extremely pleased with the judge’s order.”

Bailey says Gardner is responsible for a chaotic and toxic work
environment that’s led to the office fully collapsing. But Gardner wanted Torbitzky to throw the case out because she says he didn’t prove that she willfully neglected her duties.

Some of the accusations in Bailey’s petition include mismanaging her
office so seriously that cases were either delayed or dismissed. She’s
also accused of not communicating with crime victims.

“There is also a reasonable inference that [Gardner’s] subordinates were
acting at her direction or in accordance with her policies,” Torbitzky
wrote. “Whether any alleged failure of one of those subordinates could
subject [Gardner] to ouster need not be answered at this time because the breadth of the allegations give rise to reasonable inference that
[Gardner] has refused to perform her duties as circuit attorney.”

Torbitzky did dismiss, however, contentions that Gardner failed or refused
to timely move for the disposal of property, refused to comply with the
state’s open records laws and mismanaged her office’s finances.

Torbitzky wrote that those allegations “do not suggest willful neglect of office or any other basis for removal.”

Torbitzky also made a number of decisions on what would be allowable under
a lengthy subpoena from Bailey’s office. With exceptions, Torbitzky
largely denied Gardner’s efforts to limit turning over numerous documents
to Bailey.

He also ruled that efforts to quash former Assistant Circuit Attorney
Natalia Ogurkiewicz’s subpoena was denied, but added that Ogurkiewicz is “directed to ensure that her production of documents does not include privileged information or information that would be considered a closed record.”

He said subpoenas to Marvin Teer, a former employee, and Christopher
Hinkley, a current employee, would apply “only to personal devices and
only to documents and communications with members of the CAO.”

“The judge agreed with us and denied Gardner’s motion on all of the most important claims in our suit. Furthermore, the judge also ordered the
Circuit Attorney’s Office to produce almost all of the documents we
demanded,” Sieren of Bailey’s office said. “We are pushing forward with
our efforts to remove Ms. Gardner from office to protect the people of St. Louis.”

New judge will hear case
Torbitzky, a state appellate judge who was assigned to hear the case, will
no longer be presiding over it as he approved her motion to change judges.
The state Supreme Court will name a replacement to take over the case.

St. Louis University law professor Anders Walker said that each side is
allowed one request to change judges. Gardner didn’t provide a reason for asking for the change.

Walker said it’s possible that Gardner is looking past this phase of the
quo warranto proceedings and is instead preparing for the Missouri Supreme Court to eventually hear the case.

“She's really ramping up the narrative that she tried to reform the
system,” said Walker, pointing to remarks Gardner made over the weekend.
“And now she wants to go head to head with the attorney general, the
Supreme Court and maybe even the governor. This is just what she wants.
She wants a showdown.”

<https://news.stlpublicradio.org/government-politics-issues/2023-05- 02/baileys-case-to-remove-gardner-will-continue-after-departing-judge- denies-dismissal>

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)