The article “Absorption of Spin of a Plane Circularly Polarized Wave” is published
http://authors.elsevier.com/sd/article/S0030402620303612 ,
http://khrapkori.wmsite.ru/ftpgetfile.php?id=187&module=files
http://viXra.org/abs/2003.0286
Conclusion
The new use of the spin tensor, this time to calculate the spin absorption of a plane wave in matter, confirms the conclusion [9,14-23] that the concept of spin by Sadowsky & Poynting [10,11], according to which the spin density is proportional to the
energy density, takes precedence over the nowadays spin concept [1-8], which links spin to the energy density gradient.
However, the article was rejected by some journals.
Physical Review Letters. LH16556
We find that your claim:
“the need to replace the modern spin concept [1-6], which links spin to the energy density gradient, with the concept of Sadowsky & Poynting [8,9], according to which the spin density is proportional to the energy density itself”
is unsubstantiated. Therefore, this paper does not amount to a viable submission to PRL and cannot be made so by revision. We maintain our decision and we are not considering this paper further for publication in PRL. Please note that due to the
constraints on our resources, we may not be able to respond to further queries that are not directly connected to editorial aspects of a paper under active consideration.
Yours sincerely, Stojan Rebic Associate Editor
Journal of Modern Optics. ID TMOP-2019-0639
Many thanks for sending us your manuscript. I have discussed this paper at some length with my associate editors. We agree that there are some very interesting points of discussion contained in the paper. However the style is a bit polemical and this
leads to a tendency toward exaggeration. Also, it would be good to avoid single-sentence paragraphs.
Professor Thomas Brown Editor in Chief.
Applied Optics (375113)
I am sorry to inform you that your recent submission to Applied Optics will not be considered for publication.
Sincerely, Applied Optics Manuscripts Office
AIP Advances. #ADV19-AR-02245-TR
Unfortunately, this manuscript on a fundamental topic does not fall under the range of topics that are covered by AIP Advances, which focuses on the applied physical sciences.
Ben Slater Deputy Editor
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)