• Archaeologists are saying that they are wrong about hunter-gatherers Mi

    From James McGinn@21:1/5 to All on Sat Dec 24 12:26:06 2022
    1–30 of many
    James McGinn's profile photo
    James McGinn
    , …
    DD'eDeN aka note/nickname/alas_my_loves
    25
    unread,
    When A Real Scientist Considers Human Evolution
    by James McGinn / Genius > > Turning us all into liars and brain-dead believers, the subconscious evolved as a means by which we maintain our ability to be reprogrammed with a new
    Sep 8
    jimmc...@gmail.com's profile photo
    jimmc...@gmail.com
    ,
    DD'eDeN aka note/nickname/alas_my_loves
    9
    unread,
    Human Evolution and the Emergence of the Subconscious
    James McGinn December 26, 2019 at 8:21 pm | # Turning us all into liars and brain-dead believers, the subconscious evolved as a means by which we maintain our ability to be reprogrammed
    12/28/19
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    , …
    jimmc...@gmail.com
    158
    unread,
    Science does NOT depend on definition of terms
    civilizations of hunter-gatherer bands, or light-years of time? > >> > >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Would those usages be acceptable
    3/30/18
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    , …
    RichTravsky
    383
    unread,
    Problems With Hunter-Gatherer Model
    1/20/13
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    , …
    RichTravsky
    118
    unread,
    The Mystery of Agriculture's earliest origins
    McGinn (alias C. Denk): "Seasonal migration would > > > > > have been absolutely impossible for the earliest > > > > > hominids--A'
    3/25/12
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    , …
    Lee Olsen
    17
    unread,
    Are we descended from sports fans?
    :41 McGinn: "I may be a world class evolutionary theorist but I'm not a mind reader." now you claim you do know what people tend to think. Do you have any ethics at all? >
    9/22/11
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    ,
    Lee Olsen
    7
    unread,
    Early (6 to 8 mya) origins of hominid agricultural practices
    09 pm McGinn: "Don't bring a semantic argument to a scientific forum." > > IA: > Scientists generally all agree that it started with us some 10000 > years
    9/17/11
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    , …
    RichTravsky
    308
    unread,
    Albert Einstein and the Ecological Gatekeeper Hypothesis
    Jim McGinn: "we can be fairly certain that they never ventured more > than > 50 or maybe a 100 yards from the safety > of trees." > Jim McGinn: "Spears
    2/19/12
    Paul Crowley's profile photo
    Paul Crowley
    , …
    Rich Travsky
    97
    unread,
    Man-eaters
    day (McGinn:"And the only safe > > > place against an > > > injured, pissed-off lion or hyena is high in a tree."), > > > > Uh huh. > > Wrong
    4/15/07
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    ,
    Lee Olsen
    2
    unread,
    Wagler's Desperation
    12/3/06
    Marc Verhaegen's profile photo
    Marc Verhaegen
    , …
    Lee Olsen
    136
    unread,
    lions & savannah
    of the hunter/gatherer myth. Early hominid were isolated at their (communal) treed localities. What selective factors would favor the emergence of bipedalism? You have no answer
    12/18/06
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net's profile photo
    claudi...@sbcglobal.net
    , …
    Jim McGinn
    21
    unread,
    Challenge to Spiznet
    "Jim McGinn" wrote in message news:1164405524.8...@m7g2000cwm.googlegroups.com... >> >> >> What do you think Gerrit meant when he stated
    11/24/06
    Stewart's profile photo
    Stewart
    , …
    pete
    29
    unread,
    Could the ability to carry things be the key evolutionary advantage of bipedalism?
    vague, hunter-gatherer notions they's be telling us that we have all the evidence we need. > Others include: > (c) the failure to identify the hominid niche, > although
    12/2/06
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    , …
    Rich Travsky
    52
    unread,
    Not Enough Data
    11/19/06
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    ,
    mclark
    3
    unread,
    Striving for Vagueness
    McGinn: I'm willing to address any specific complaint you have. Eshleman: The specific complaint is that you're denying evidence of recent domestication of plants and animals
    12/24/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    , …
    littor...@gmail.com
    219
    unread,
    Absence of Canines in Apiths
    11/10/20
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    ,
    spiznet
    2
    unread,
    Too Ironic
    Jim McGinn wrote: >> "JAE" wrote in message >> news:1133979247.5...@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com... >> > >> > Jim
    12/8/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    ,
    george
    2
    unread,
    Does Jason have a point?
    12/6/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    ,
    mclark
    2
    unread,
    Assignment for Mikey
    12/5/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    , …
    mclark
    188
    unread,
    Impeccable
    Jim McGinn wrote: > > rmacfarl wrote: > > > > Is there anybody that has an evidence based dispute with my > > hypothesis? > > > > > > >
    11/25/05
    Algis Kuliukas's profile photo
    Algis Kuliukas
    , …
    Marc Verhaegen
    1445
    unread,
    A critique of the BBC aquatic ape programme and the transcript.
    Jim McGinn wrote: > > JAE wrote: > > [snip] > > > How come you never seem to put forth specific examples > > so that everybody can see what it is you'
    1/5/06
    rmacfarl's profile photo
    rmacfarl
    , …
    Su Solomon
    5
    unread,
    Beware Brahean blunders. They are not limited to astronomy.
    using, hunter-gatherer ape notion of the, supposedly, now dead savanna hypothesis. Although we won't get any of them to admit it or even discuss it explicity (maybe the clearest
    10/13/05
    rmacfarl's profile photo
    rmacfarl
    , …
    John B.
    13
    unread,
    The Forest People
    of the hunter/gatherer Ik, is > > less optimistic, and I've tried to avoid it. review: http://www1.dragonet.es/users/markbcki/trnbll.htm " As starvation sets
    9/9/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    unread,
    Spoils of War
    : the hunter/gatherer myth. > They hunt primarily with sight, just as Homo does. < . . . at that point Homo runs > (slowly) up and takes away their kill. So much for running fast
    8/21/05
    Andrew Nowicki's profile photo
    Andrew Nowicki
    , …
    Rich Travsky
    224
    unread,
    Final Solution of the Aquatic Question
    9/26/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    ,
    pete
    2
    unread,
    Final Solution of the Savanna Question
    disproving the hunter/gatherer notions of traditional PA. If traditional PA's notion of homo being a species that regularly travelled continuously, in small groups, across
    8/1/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    , …
    Whitedog
    90
    unread,
    Monsoon/mosaic
    "Jim McGinn" > wrote: > > >That humans are territorial is a fact that must be explained by any > >hypothesis on hominid evolution. If it can't then
    7/27/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    , …
    Paul Crowley
    4
    unread,
    Explanatory Shortfalls of Conventional Vagueness
    "Jim McGinn" wrote in message news:1120452765.7...@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com... > > > JAE wrote: >> Algis Kuliukas wrote: >>
    7/6/05
    Jim McGinn's profile photo
    Jim McGinn
    unread,
    Political Realities That Underly Hominid Brain Evolution
    6/27/05
    Paul Crowley's profile photo
    Paul Crowley
    , …
    Marc Verhaegen
    23
    unread,
    Darwin and Modern PA

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From James McGinn@21:1/5 to All on Sat Dec 24 12:22:43 2022
    Archaeologists are saying that they are wrong about hunter-gatherers Michael Shermer, Graham Hancock

    https://youtube.com/shorts/TkLGYbnhBXU?feature=share

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)