"Before Scandinavia: These could be the first skiers
By Robert Marquand | Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor"
The above article, of March 15, mentions a 2000 year old design and
then mentions skis dating to 4500 years ago, found in Scandanavia.
New to me. Then discusses the present day use of skis in the Altaian mountains of China, and suggests that the design there might date back
10000 or 20000 BP. Refers to cave paintings and speculates that skis
may have been invented there and diffused to Scandanavia.
About all one can do is speculate on the probabilities here.
Could stone age people make boards? Article says invention is common
sense, but not maybe so much so for people who didn't commonly use
boards. Moreover in heavy timber, snowshoes maybe more flexible, and
easier for stone age people to make.
However, while deer move down from the high country in Southern
Colorado in the present day, I read an account (in fiction) that deer
will beat paths among willows in areas of moderate snow. Hunters on
snowshoes easily able to kill the entire herd. Of course, hunters
needed a large range, so an area could repopulate after this. So we
can speculate that snowshoes might have been an early invention. Good
edge for humans over other predators.
The 10,000 to 20,000 year BP date would allow skis to move with the
migration into Scandanavia as the glaciers retreated.
I can't say I was impressed with the author implying telemarking
is for wimps. Bono and Kennedy proved that there is positive selection against hunters that try to prove their macho to a tree. Of course,
maybe sexual selection would offset this.
Also, what do the Altaian cave paintings show, and how are they
dated.
So, something for idle speculation, unless someone here has some
answeres.
Regards
John GW
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v404/n6776/full/404382a0.html
"Before Scandinavia: These could be the first skiers
By Robert Marquand | Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor"
The above article, of March 15, mentions a 2000 year old design and
then mentions skis dating to 4500 years ago, found in Scandanavia.
New to me. Then discusses the present day use of skis in the Altaian mountains of China, and suggests that the design there might date back
10000 or 20000 BP. Refers to cave paintings and speculates that skis
may have been invented there and diffused to Scandanavia.
About all one can do is speculate on the probabilities here.
Could stone age people make boards? Article says invention is common
sense, but not maybe so much so for people who didn't commonly use
boards. Moreover in heavy timber, snowshoes maybe more flexible, and
easier for stone age people to make.
However, while deer move down from the high country in Southern
Colorado in the present day, I read an account (in fiction) that deer
will beat paths among willows in areas of moderate snow. Hunters on
snowshoes easily able to kill the entire herd. Of course, hunters
needed a large range, so an area could repopulate after this. So we
can speculate that snowshoes might have been an early invention. Good
edge for humans over other predators.
The 10,000 to 20,000 year BP date would allow skis to move with the
migration into Scandanavia as the glaciers retreated.
I can't say I was impressed with the author implying telemarking
is for wimps. Bono and Kennedy proved that there is positive selection against hunters that try to prove their macho to a tree. Of course,
maybe sexual selection would offset this.
Also, what do the Altaian cave paintings show, and how are they
dated.
So, something for idle speculation, unless someone here has some
answeres.
Regards
John GW
| Sysop: | Keyop |
|---|---|
| Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
| Users: | 293 |
| Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
| Uptime: | 228:45:24 |
| Calls: | 6,624 |
| Calls today: | 6 |
| Files: | 12,171 |
| Messages: | 5,318,995 |