• Can I Salvage a Non-Finalized Home Made DVD?

    From M.L.@21:1/5 to All on Mon Sep 14 22:37:52 2015
    We found a home made VHS tape with a precious memory of someone who
    recently passed away and would like to capture a portion of the VHS to
    a digital file.

    My brother found his old JVC DR-MV150BJ VHS/DVD recorder but he can't
    find the remote for it. Unfortunately the MV150B is pretty useless
    without a remote and I doubt there will be a way to finalize a DVD
    without it.

    DVD playback isn't necessary. Is there a way my Windows 10 laptop
    could read the DVD and extract the mpeg from one of the VOBs without finalization? Thanks.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Paul@21:1/5 to M.L. on Tue Sep 15 03:40:40 2015
    M.L. wrote:
    We found a home made VHS tape with a precious memory of someone who
    recently passed away and would like to capture a portion of the VHS to
    a digital file.

    My brother found his old JVC DR-MV150BJ VHS/DVD recorder but he can't
    find the remote for it. Unfortunately the MV150B is pretty useless
    without a remote and I doubt there will be a way to finalize a DVD
    without it.

    DVD playback isn't necessary. Is there a way my Windows 10 laptop
    could read the DVD and extract the mpeg from one of the VOBs without finalization? Thanks.


    http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/close-finalize-cd-dvd#1TC=windows-7

    http://www.cd-info.com/howto/finalize/

    This article suggests isobuster near the end of the article.
    That's worth a try, just to get a folder named video_ts and
    call it a day.

    http://diyvideoeditor.com/step-by-step-guide-dealing-with-unfinalized-dvd-discs/

    According to the info so far "Close Session" simply stops
    the ability to write to the current session (of a multi-session
    disc). Whereas, the claim is that "Finalize" writes the DVD menu structure,
    to a recorded disc, to make it more convenient to play chapters in it
    on a standalone device. Which almost sounds like an "Authoring" function.

    Closing the session sounds like more than enough. While maybe extracting
    the data (if isobuster doesn't complain) may be enough to avoid messing
    up the disc. I presume some kinds of devices (like computers) can
    deal with a disc without closing it. But the implication is, that
    other devices might not be so willing to deal with an unclosed piece
    of media.

    I think I've tried to look for technical articles on this in the
    past, and come up dry. Nobody seems to want to define it (like
    someone with the skill set to write burner software).

    Paul

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From M.L.@21:1/5 to All on Tue Sep 15 16:10:47 2015
    We found a home made VHS tape with a precious memory of someone who
    recently passed away and would like to capture a portion of the VHS to
    a digital file.

    My brother found his old JVC DR-MV150BJ VHS/DVD recorder but he can't
    find the remote for it. Unfortunately the MV150B is pretty useless
    without a remote and I doubt there will be a way to finalize a DVD
    without it.

    DVD playback isn't necessary. Is there a way my Windows 10 laptop
    could read the DVD and extract the mpeg from one of the VOBs without
    finalization? Thanks.


    http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/close-finalize-cd-dvd#1TC=windows-7

    http://www.cd-info.com/howto/finalize/

    This article suggests isobuster near the end of the article.
    That's worth a try, just to get a folder named video_ts and
    call it a day.

    http://diyvideoeditor.com/step-by-step-guide-dealing-with-unfinalized-dvd-discs/

    According to the info so far "Close Session" simply stops
    the ability to write to the current session (of a multi-session
    disc). Whereas, the claim is that "Finalize" writes the DVD menu structure, >to a recorded disc, to make it more convenient to play chapters in it
    on a standalone device. Which almost sounds like an "Authoring" function.

    Closing the session sounds like more than enough. While maybe extracting
    the data (if isobuster doesn't complain) may be enough to avoid messing
    up the disc. I presume some kinds of devices (like computers) can
    deal with a disc without closing it. But the implication is, that
    other devices might not be so willing to deal with an unclosed piece
    of media.

    Thanks so much for your reply. I'm only interested in capturing the
    video, not at all interested in DVD playback. I'll try ISObuster for
    the task.

    I think I've tried to look for technical articles on this in the
    past, and come up dry. Nobody seems to want to define it (like
    someone with the skill set to write burner software).

    Paul

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From HerHusband@21:1/5 to All on Wed Sep 16 04:31:43 2015
    We found a home made VHS tape with a precious memory of someone who
    recently passed away and would like to capture a portion of the VHS to
    a digital file.

    My brother found his old JVC DR-MV150BJ VHS/DVD recorder but he can't
    find the remote for it. Unfortunately the MV150B is pretty useless
    without a remote and I doubt there will be a way to finalize a DVD
    without it.

    DVD playback isn't necessary. Is there a way my Windows 10 laptop
    could read the DVD and extract the mpeg from one of the VOBs without finalization? Thanks.

    If you can create the DVD, there are many programs that can rip the video
    from the disc, such as "MakeMKV". The page below shows some of the more
    popular options:

    www.lifehacker.com/380702/five-best-dvd-ripping-tools

    Alternatively, many video cards have audio/video inputs that would allow
    you to skip the intermediate DVD step and capture the video directly from
    your VHS player. Or you could buy a dedicated capture card and software.

    However, for a one time task like this, it would probably be cheaper and
    easier to just pay a service to convert the VHS tape to a digital file for
    you. There are many companies online who do this, but I think even places
    like Walmart do it these days (as far as I know, they send it out to
    another processor).

    Good luck!

    Anthony Watson
    www.mountainsoftware.com
    www.watsondiy.com

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From M.L.@21:1/5 to All on Wed Sep 16 04:29:28 2015
    We found a home made VHS tape with a precious memory of someone who
    recently passed away and would like to capture a portion of the VHS to
    a digital file.

    My brother found his old JVC DR-MV150BJ VHS/DVD recorder but he can't
    find the remote for it. Unfortunately the MV150B is pretty useless
    without a remote and I doubt there will be a way to finalize a DVD
    without it.

    DVD playback isn't necessary. Is there a way my Windows 10 laptop
    could read the DVD and extract the mpeg from one of the VOBs without
    finalization? Thanks.

    If you can create the DVD, there are many programs that can rip the video >from the disc, such as "MakeMKV". The page below shows some of the more >popular options:

    www.lifehacker.com/380702/five-best-dvd-ripping-tools

    Alternatively, many video cards have audio/video inputs that would allow
    you to skip the intermediate DVD step and capture the video directly from >your VHS player. Or you could buy a dedicated capture card and software.

    However, for a one time task like this, it would probably be cheaper and >easier to just pay a service to convert the VHS tape to a digital file for >you. There are many companies online who do this, but I think even places >like Walmart do it these days (as far as I know, they send it out to
    another processor).

    There wasn't enough time to wait for 3rd party services. Unfortunately
    the DVD tray didn't work so we abandoned that idea for a USB capture
    device, which worked well after some post processing. Thanks to all
    who responded.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From HerHusband@21:1/5 to All on Wed Sep 16 14:01:01 2015
    We found a home made VHS tape with a precious memory of someone who
    recently passed away and would like to capture a portion of the VHS
    to a digital file.

    There wasn't enough time to wait for 3rd party services. Unfortunately
    the DVD tray didn't work so we abandoned that idea for a USB capture
    device, which worked well after some post processing.

    Excellent, I'm happy to hear you were able to save your old videos. I
    figured capturing the video would probably be the easiest method to use,
    but it does require the capture device. Glad you had something that worked.

    Remember to make backup copies of your memorable video!

    Take care,

    Anthony Watson
    www.mountainsoftware.com
    www.watsondiy.com

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)