KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :
The Croatians have
played Brazil just as even as they played the French in the
first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call.
Which bad penalty call ?
--
Ixion
The Croatians have
played Brazil just as even as they played the French in the
first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call.
On Friday, December 9, 2022 at 7:49:36 PM UTC+1, ixion martin
- GdBx wrote:
KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :
The Croatians have
played Brazil just as even as they played the French in the
first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call.
Which bad penalty call ?
It was the correct call, according to the rules at the time.
But be perfectly honest with yourself: would you have taken
the exact same call in good grace if it had gone against
France?
Werner Pichler avait soumis l'idée :
On Friday, December 9, 2022 at 7:49:36 PM UTC+1, ixion martin - GdBx
wrote:
KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :
The Croatians have played Brazil just as even as they played theWhich bad penalty call ?
French in the first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call. >>>
It was the correct call, according to the rules at the time.
But be perfectly honest with yourself: would you have taken the exact
same call in good grace if it had gone against France?
To be honest with myself, I would have taken the exact same call in good grace if it had gone against any team except France ;).
More seriously, if you consider it is a bad call, you don't give any
penalty for handball.
On 2022-12-09 14:51, ixion martin - GdBx wrote:
Werner Pichler avait soumis l'idée :
On Friday, December 9, 2022 at 7:49:36 PM UTC+1, ixion martin - GdBx
wrote:
KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :
The Croatians have played Brazil just as even as they played theWhich bad penalty call ?
French in the first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call. >>>
It was the correct call, according to the rules at the time.
But be perfectly honest with yourself: would you have taken the exact
same call in good grace if it had gone against France?
To be honest with myself, I would have taken the exact same call in good grace if it had gone against any team except France ;).
More seriously, if you consider it is a bad call, you don't give any penalty for handball.
Come on ! You don't actually think this inadvertent handball is
equivalent to a blatant act of goalkeeping like Suarez in 2010*, do you ?
I accept that this is a penalty the way the game is now refereed, but it certainly would not have been in the past (the law said "deliberately handles the ball").
* I also don't think the opprobrium heaped on Suarez was at all
justified. He did what professionals do - took an action that gave his
team a chance to win. [Quite apart from the fact that play should have
been stopped before that for various fouls, offsides etc. as many have argued, notably Bruce on this group)_. This is no more "cheating" or reprehensible than any other deliberate foul (like shirt pulling,
holding, body checking...)
On 2022-12-09 14:51, ixion martin - GdBx wrote:
Werner Pichler avait soumis l'idée :
On Friday, December 9, 2022 at 7:49:36 PM UTC+1, ixion
martin - GdBx wrote:
KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :
The Croatians have played Brazil just as even as they
played the French in the first half four years ago--up
until the bad penalty call.
Which bad penalty call ?
It was the correct call, according to the rules at the
time.
But be perfectly honest with yourself: would you have
taken the exact same call in good grace if it had gone
against France?
To be honest with myself, I would have taken the exact same
call in good grace if it had gone against any team except
France ;).
More seriously, if you consider it is a bad call, you don't
give any penalty for handball.
Come on ! You don't actually think this inadvertent handball
is equivalent to a blatant act of goalkeeping like Suarez in
2010*, do you ?
I accept that this is a penalty the way the game is now
refereed, but it certainly would not have been in the past
(the law said "deliberately handles the ball").
KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :The obviously unintentional handball that gave the French the 2-1
The Croatians have
played Brazil just as even as they played the French in the
first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call.
Which bad penalty call ?
On Fri, 09 Dec 2022 19:49:33 +0100, ixion martin - GdBx <ixion@martin.invalid> wrote:
KaiserD2 a formulé la demande :The obviously unintentional handball that gave the French
The Croatians have
played Brazil just as even as they played the French in the
first half four years ago--up until the bad penalty call.
Which bad penalty call ?
the 2-1 lead four years ago.
| Sysop: | Keyop |
|---|---|
| Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
| Users: | 300 |
| Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
| Uptime: | 46:16:14 |
| Calls: | 6,710 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 12,243 |
| Messages: | 5,354,349 |
| Posted today: | 1 |