• Nat Sarang

    From ChristianAMR@21:1/5 to All on Thu Jan 19 09:12:55 2023
    Neither Ocean nor Swarganga include it in their databases ...

    Abhijit Shenoy´s version uses Chhayanat as base . The other versions might only use Nat ...? This could be examined with more detailed listening .

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CrMFG18WaWs

    From his vid :

    " A mishra - melotpan raag born out of Bilawal and Kafi thaats. Shades of 2 Raags - Chayanat and Brindavani Sarang. Derived by adding the Shudh Gandhar in the aaroh of Brindavani Sarang, thus incorporating the Nat ang.

    [N.] s R, G, m, m p, N S ;
    S n p, m R, N. s / S n p, p [m] R G m p, m, R N. s

    Madhyalay Roopak - Rādhe aayi ghatā ghana - composed by Pt Jaisukhlaal "Vinay" Shah

    Drut Tarana (Trivat) Jhaptaal - composed under my pen-name "Abhirang" "

    He uses the phrases SRGPm and SRGmPm which remind me of a ma-centric Bilawal prakar .

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qLNF_6mBNio - Ustad Aslam Khan
    He uses the phrase RRGGm S

    I couldn´t hear any such ma-centric phrases in Vijay Bakshi´s version .

    Furthermore , I couldn´t detect any instance of SR RG Gm in any of the versions at quick listening ( It might be there though , hidden ) .
    Anyway , I have decided to use this typical Nat phrase in my own composition

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From ChristianAMR@21:1/5 to All on Thu Jan 19 09:09:37 2023
    Neither Ocean nor Swarganga include it in their databases ...

    Abhijit Shenoy´s version uses Chhayanat as base . The other versions might only use Nat ...? This could be examined with more detailed listening .

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CrMFG18WaWs

    From his vid :

    " A mishra - melotpan raag born out of Bilawal and Kafi thaats. Shades of 2 Raags - Chayanat and Brindavani Sarang. Derived by adding the Shudh Gandhar in the aaroh of Brindavani Sarang, thus incorporating the Nat ang.

    [N.] s R, G, m, m p, N S ;
    S n p, m R, N. s / S n p, p [m] R G m p, m, R N. s

    Madhyalay Roopak - Rādhe aayi ghatā ghana - composed by Pt Jaisukhlaal "Vinay" Shah

    Drut Tarana (Trivat) Jhaptaal - composed under my pen-name "Abhirang" "

    He uses the phrases SRGPm and SRGmPm which remind me of a ma-centric Bilawal prakar .

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qLNF_6mBNio - Ustad Aslam Khan
    He uses the phrase RRGGm S

    I couldn´t hear any such ma-centric phrases in Vijay Bhakshi´s version .

    Furthermore , I couldn´t detect any instance of SR RG Gm in any of the versions at quick listening ( It might be there though , hidden ) .
    Anyway , I have decided to use this typical Nat phrase in my own composition .

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)