• Something odd about rule 305.9

    From news@zzo38computer.org.invalid@21:1/5 to All on Sat Oct 17 18:01:15 2020
    Rule 305.9 says that an object that is both a land and another type cannot
    be cast, but it doesn't otherwise say that a land cannot be cast. Is this
    a mistake? It seems unintentional to me, that it should say that any object whose type is land cannot be cast, whether or not it has any other types.

    I found this when discussing on IRC about modal double-face cards, and how
    some specific rules regarding them work.

    --
    This signature intentionally left blank.
    (But if it has these words, then actually it isn't blank, isn't it?)

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Max Harmony@21:1/5 to news@zzo38computer.org.invalid on Sun Nov 29 02:06:13 2020
    This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156) --l6CxLD5hZghg2C9l7yJiYFy6lpQ6kaJC7
    Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------h36ZJ-OPwkDKpJMpP/B5zb3q"

    --------------h36ZJ-OPwkDKpJMpP/B5zb3q
    Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

    On 17-10-20 21.01, news@zzo38computer.org.invalid wrote:
    Rule 305.9 says that an object that is both a land and another type cannot
    be cast, but it doesn't otherwise say that a land cannot be cast. Is this
    a mistake? It seems unintentional to me, that it should say that any object whose type is land cannot be cast, whether or not it has any other types.

    I found this when discussing on IRC about modal double-face cards, and how some specific rules regarding them work.

    You can't cast a land because you can only cast spells, and lands aren't spells. CR 305.9 is to stop people trying to cast Dryad Arbor as a creature. --------------h36ZJ-OPwkDKpJMpP/B5zb3q
    Content-Type: application/pgp-keys; name="OpenPGP_0xCCD026FCA8960638.asc" Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="OpenPGP_0xCCD026FCA8960638.asc" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

    -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

    xsNNBFS8nJ4BIAC5Pi5TGPrpq5LAa4X1MHAFf6FvLG1owNw+9Ga9ssUgBOn7aTrU6q7jWdolJ4xE 7ilUMFpkfur/bL+5PmaYQ58JLcyk0t195/N4Lgc3foTO1Q+WV7FBrrFT1XpOe86PRV404MSOYJrk E/7Y/pOaeRYs2wiX5bKNlD6lLVixvBtEUOFb899GTIo2RU4gZ0c2BIuiuMACZStUhfB8NmlrTMYL pIKcCSMcZL/AMaRQJ4w8V9q727NMppgajrjfKw9ipW/ZZKR6QuDYae8tQFyoT5gQ2mbSYfvkZqQQ Vsm/gutDKG1j4jWJa/JyJg/5edC8PQXDgDLFPR7BHusP+epUre3Vuah+1ndbuiO+lmw0oFjRPJAP X4DTGQM8MV0v46LlN4ZhIv/wiZmncdmQgEdlrxBiE+54AR5hiB9UkfKr3KWqQLxnBWmOtciWPP+D UP1/3uWNMpxb8m4aRyu/1E4VyrFbkmIuP7o+D0DffZlZhGs1svelT0hBsNNTAsrBQQVQU3ajNqkD tT0rkwY+whNFAWuNacdb5OF/WkzBoJFJmpy71qNUBkPzjnDSSeJGhMckdMt/do1ZjMJ38iBqawEF 9IEONTPxpkMa8UJcPc1oM+TGxJauLyKN6nWpaA5CB+mkfeNSrqnBbQXyuGQeeUZj89q8JC4iP9jI EqEZ9qBlO4QNd664y0KbzyVeRipipu61i1L/likx5P+/ImRUGmUVVJtuNVlT/yTFuQ87FZQNbzQk 8ygbu8nMUQShkSYGHQhLOWwCb0f/lj336k15HEOVQJ+zYCc8iRZ75lG0KfdX0YTDaP+T4bDu3mjM 0RObAMnF8W5lNx9jVN/OK2M+fKuHcFw9XenaqghMuY/o3tu7oYGgA7nHw4WbJ02Eaj6ziWN/WWkb gPz95ekclcy1RwF4HGfVetOwcZV0RtXHqrSeC3uiZvEkmJsLNGi9ds+i/mwdp+Cnimd6ruC4Me0T NXTnC7u0lEyrEj/iOLhALN+C9I/Pqfecintkz3zsm3RptB4k8RULrcb8pZ3Lm2o3vDH7Su89zjj+ 83D+btiX6zlG6RkNk2MYNE3UITv8si86tDR4o5yXDEwAoKWV15OOWL5hhjvlQ4XzM4EMDsDvAZ6h N1vI8nDtPqTL9TNSSHwcwkEf07kbbyz+zhJDB8BUaUk8UqHa75DIfdMd2Ce1tbrzmHsZSl2gHbto VPGZLK9HGwL4eajdvRqYBl/uMmU//INUwJD1iTWWOIMo9LLtiDBjSwT5o2CHlxzl13SQuqhpx2hV JDrQURQX7cH+PhNj9hJpuSJpHNplwmxOa1jj++pmbrXdUxQY8tSYKgJNzQia3okaV+/u0bUTmbsc 3hEatQACwT+rABEBAAHNHU1heCBIYXJtb255IDxtYXhoQG1heGgubWUudWs+wsBiBBABAgAMBQJU vXMgBQMAEnUAAAoJEJcQuJvKV618KzIH/3OmlRJcxPImHqE9bD7LcpVEJBOSKNoBdbv+uK2TCiRL WojkHiQh94ydAS4Kj5tfUn+igFKJT00cIDsVtanhkw3/8jfRlkW6fvhbVNycJwQOrLulxxnVKDcb /pMOSNWmeMAkR7bteGtKzFGcvHuT90PIFEqHjvYyuoRu57frgh/ai2tWWmQ/mNosuwX5A7jNZYYh JAVHh2lIKUMs3VuwQiCgDZgLZsa8T0YNj8DDMfZbh0G8VhO0/7kPbdSCVdG/m+2Ng3RAtt2m53Ci BL+9wIht/MiVExzl6575FNlBYkwxzLUkMLaYtRNklo07apecXxw8Mig6A5xGwRcFV4xVaGHCwNwE EAECAAYFAlTAsxYACgkQyu8Izjz9TBCFIQwAk93woKNk+lNIP+MxTjTZ2tshEtptThFECBWuZ9UA ARCB5Nb3rx21cqxsSQ2y/qUBINfAwWR/DsiasLD5OP+pBiJwVg8tKCDSPqlDxQrV6ca16sjw9Sne 86+Nrbx6bbCdkR1J1C80HpHHssvu9pJPUrKNJBCA/4UKi+IVxFSoMFVa3q2Dzs3OGZ6y9PRATxqL gvjEbH1oBlN6VuYFc+gcE9zfGte3kgjP34Wu521hEwWRxhV0fYW+UzBoWy8jr6dtaXrs9ZO/b0k0 FAUpWaYW8mPg0nJAz09P7gItDzbojqJl0o03lappDM1H7yjNOtWg42tNay2uRjbCIaXGj3rE8EHA 1JH3//4Xpl38DKqfogEOR14TWQZsOUJzyUOv2g6gE4XDlaUijkepYzNIRT/5k1fyOmgPqGfMX049 G/UDNyBbBTs/OhSc5TK1WefgS53DSApGiOgPTsENL5Aennf4nPF1maq6tmjF44rQXKCXxGEGNKn+ PhOCOcfxbRBxBgQywsFcBBABAgAGBQJUwGMQAAoJENDNgAf9RQJ2mUYP/Ah3ckLoIBdq4fiL6gKB xirjFys7Jhv7bmINSth2FgNb9Q9jvxRq+n8sP+bcnskRvTDurNqdkycH/BkxNBu5lti2r8Lmu0xH rzIdpDQPC57othnMLG9827VxaJtCWfzjLqD+DAgYjFffr9NhsK7aOSYHVQqhchTk2ms/DXpK4HDu 4zmVfmnblkd7sGigugFGOLbwWudoYoN8vbBzRb4cRZiIp4G+NarpUov1xBNLbGGXP1aJNLtWgT5/ B/Ki27J6WqFvQUyNm4RrT1z2ojRJpiIjVIubW6uEEKw1XQ/AZtNJzrNqfnRxLN55kR7rp7/1MR2I /nK1yDfnO3h0J8nHOGUhYczDF/E1wuChGbpZaM+HbnHxYgUi3LyfQKVaYqhwBRw49vAfXmFoPl+L pE328tp8QygfT+bx3c4qy1taly7RDXg5eUxmJzGc3WSHGrqUBeFn2HVY3JQr1wXXkLYFpLTY+xnu njmGxkrhVtZbV2BqaUF6qRma8lOYTtmAoPRKO+yKXmXTDJqTh3cWU4VU7dtlerb5IjnH/dVwKXR4 5MaJ8JBME4hMcCGqloQ/I5qf+7wLZ92WCP0+rkhXOzdB3AK3nn6o2hlxModNsV3aHwSemIVCqvVC BdZMhA+xDAGvZ9R0DXeGBY8YCiDCEM6+ICa9UFjMcZcT4NiRNIQiaeyiwsFcBBABCAAGBQJUvJ6/ AAoJEDUwD9mlzIuoP2wQAK/djZoujREzMdvDosgQNnmVXYnepwyz/uYXrFxrEfKKGRm2bIaZD2W7 jAeehGJz9caEwMROc5wEb5GCauSvYWZ9PiAeZD0B7ERyM/E9Jgz8X1PBvboZjSv6cYYCwEg8DhNy 1zblhxtSIoC/3aQ+pVsS9KcwlyAXbD7Qk1s43wdzTE9qLj9mBVicfC3eYy54l3KMvAW4/XsJmXOj yjNRAAST2pe8Cpr2Ynsflw51gh8MXUyjGMY5Rcn3qwhjAvMJf+yuCnWC8zS7ywW9+AvAe3mBeQ11 wjUyNk8M+B5TFsNXfLofOJywcvh9ApBzMI7yO6+PxfElFWSecg6T0+KivybTJlISprfgdyMi9HlZ VC063uvBb7XSFujugUtv9tFf5rVCcD2pxYnuoguZ+e8VNLyVPgDmF7Kaxm84yOFWqlGSY52x30y2 7xL9P32uLaqyRh4PCk2ARaeBO8H3m3o9duDOCP+OJKNW7+A5nNBwiojicjBmAiKU9OUjP8afTIQi LHv6qJRFCQplxJgrqJ6fn2VJgcjpyWqSN3JZQrF8CmZ2XaosjzFdjcDosziW8aevbRswawbZpMWQ SwvI17SLzFfWPiLloSR1wep/VZWKlSkyDDIiCsZLqNRAw0HMSKFh4+Oe64r64wGDjM4J142Ran6N kjX2egegiPmX9o7DBHLDwsFcBBABCgAGBQJUwCqzAAoJEBRo+hMNF8r1J80P/0oOYRb+QxXs98o3 IU13vqL15eE5URL6+3MquzUORMJdzIbPsFIZY/Bl6r2jpRaI1q+2hPnbZsjo9nhH/W57ZA3sFX3/ ewQ9khoFvq8rBc8V2nm3ti5BwC39bfbzQqKQ9xH75q35XY9v49NbHKR1CVyvDzcdeTD6Ig7qKAN2 TZn9lIMrED9fgyScXTLwN28TGGH9LV2e/pDLZmsRUh34BHw+NY1cihoimaAJ4BVDEHFGiWwzR2Il LNV2AewLo055uJG7/xaETMcX0PaW5ZpnBhBA6lVgHnD4d/mSK+vAjjaY6cME1HL3hxqRFYyZGFiT ZEMh3rUtbijXdOBtFf5KkFkDllOby1m1s7U+yBjaJgT2LOwsh4x5V9rrRa0566jk7e0MDGq9Tfoi Icw4GHMIGZx0LRZm0RMST5F6QiaiFhxallB9cNLftDJGRnhvijeWYyOMSQdLTPWnUs2arxynSSiS Y5a6IrKNgKSeWvGBonbphoIe0OpzbnVNs2BM/luv9IZbhFu5C8ESQ39oUBrzYPJTgnehufX2h2Yc Sddv0UYzq5l/3xvSdcl3z0E4BqdxW/rjynhgqduGDUXg2AJ953GiNJ+lg0pT58lRdT0aEwAbNTQ0 3rux0YKu3I0Edajwf9sTw7LWUDdpri08Y6j/PWIBVz+5SerkrLkxQS8gvwmDwsOVBBMBCgA/AhkB Ap4BApsDAheABQsNCQwIAxUKCQUWAgMBABYhBCI5JocLUCzsKPfZUMzQJvyolgY4BQJeDnhqBQkL PVT8AAoJEMzQJvyolgY4xJAf/060lnCMfDj2WV1PBx7NQBy0s4x8vbqyUMYRhKWDHnUp1jTJh+tL LWFsgq6oLgN6Zr28P4bbwukxU4d74ucF8lZY5jsq2zUJuri6TDQfMHKhMTnxDwj5WzS3IL7R/+0q RueHAiOURMbKqDTxFLCQhU83EGtHbRXQJb9Mb0f73+PGPcdgJ2gK9sgZWVZSt02sq+Wn91IfPxbJ 33LLNnUCDgZOQsrNib+m04FU/9qrt/OQSdmAiW2SC2ZHnNVzSNMZgTIqWTD0pe6b9VkHN89VGVWy 1+bJG3/7ChoahI/VMmL6xgawH/DF0sCtevh5SSEKEcdjHaHPc9/plihjsCqC/DuZyj4bGp4DQG5h ZzC1YSskK4AbcxtppL9e6+WOud3QxgEnwLhzWciH+kFyOMbR1bhWqrTI/YewNJag/YkAfmuv1H3G B/hhhg5ibOGBNDtiZzYijm/KSO1mhESr2nH2pyEEKEm0Cl6sbt+O7tG1Et1W/Fa4hG3hZe6ZrtQU Qtz3MTumylU5WVYD7moLDe6GXbf/ADJ9iDrFA7G7DxzO3xn0ngbG5TB1ZLY0k6mdNMPZS5XmopbG DRbQeAhtDlfYWGbZ2+csnrl2MoF2Uz2Ga8lvcNHFbc328FoihhYUiUd+HqUN/1/OR1BjFXe2rX3Z a3tjaSArCZFn+/D9cCi+9gcd+jUUIl2gLj6aZqS+wX+7stIU+d6RdAbrN0vcLrDnTSC/V/8XVsEp DJ0KD4Ig1dS1QwboAsZArbMzK4SADiBGBvwDVOsNkj6Jq+4GrxtGix+4D3O7XUud1PqO0XjGiNuv 5OEEc4xI7t2s+5x7st6O6/DH4YnLEoDFgewvijTVRJIpVHPnXUes5MWVYzeOiP9p0HopTcpbulRe KUiPV2tLhHZiySBt5INdP6aWaaWXPIeMcdtwIgjAYhkkELLzPQqUlqnvPyFEDeEO0ToNOHH8yrfK yW392pLtknUsmMInl7MKPp/hDu4AjRE9GHYT98tbgUFA1CpXc8wh0WSeFkZQB5lGucQSZXe/K/Hu WUM0JtxGNap4yFWlFwtpYJJQjS4BkzGv1z9M9H3FWV4ASf9oesg3mIifAjwZ2LLhDPW1cv0vBND+ 3Ilyv/T7afOwX/6J5DxmO2o4qNIFFufDcwfnSwIo7TWppc4OwYVj2vPz39YcZrXMZ+ZGjRxsu4sN NL7fRVf+wr1cLitkAXqDc/p6GI0KKORfsKJ5D8DesZUcjLcvmIazAU97IDkx1dlkxGn1nWWAVbEu ELs4ImF7W4SXdVQLXLjduWOpaGjeYujby8b2n5WdTbUVv1UNdwZs66lLu6yqm0PmfX24dFqXgZz+ 8EHpxNS9S+TDd5Wl66IiiILCwGIEEAECAAwFAlTgVwcFAwASdQAACgkQlxC4m8pXrXyonQf8C39C eh9OS9DNYQIumNTIefrw7Pa1SnqbO840jdUMZjMnJ13hbSi6m3gSgcRYARRmm3/SqFYcs4fJp5zz rhGvtv6NaeRg/H7lf2rfCyzyReFoK94NuyMpQCOlbRiIPqeSCdVEnNSxRc2XuBl2G7oR3lgoKD7x t59DHaCXJeeTjnoTcuWRy6Ihjh+72j8fFvk3L6o3HJrTxQ20r9hDeEOoGKaPt3D1IfOPXANXHgzC S+GY3Y+5IRyq5qC9gUEIJqsMn/UY3NnhJi1QQqduvwFKoVw3e1oiRC8TuyGS86caUCrrbIRFIBFe rQjH/Gje16ynwh3M4VtoG7hlToNJv9h4vsLAYgQQAQIADAUCVuPTMQUDABJ1AAAKCRCXELibylet fAH1B/9+qVcExi/Djwvq3AJqOYZpVtXpfHhKcm/tV082b2hEKxEYnXbBa73FpdWEtvkKWSqUP1H8 GVX53ZR1CKcnoIu2hBYxUq9LA5Sfi0gbawntknhI3lbzTiIxdBuUuZGLnBo9MuedFiblJFAADDuY kvyRkYvrXbrito3hoyJW4g0984QNR/BNaY/T4n0SqsPfpEQKnItECXwpY21tAP/otapK7cHaGnJH M6KiBB1seSCtlkfCjBp8Zt9YueUdKpCnRP1/gbosrFSlAWSlo7YN14yjX6ADVx4g9xdjdPXGhzg4 4ZELZ0Vd1n0mMnuRUIC/0OtT7vWOMKTUJ1E53xvtiUtqzSFNYXggSGFybW9ueSA8dGVoX21heGhA a2V5YmFzZS5pbz7Cw3YEMAEIACAWIQQiOSaHC1As7Cj32VDM0Cb8qJYGOAUCXEw+BwIdAAAKCRDM 0Cb8qJYGOCeyH/4pF6ANSj49+e9KW1ndqrpras0x0MhY2hWNpq0FvHR1/io9LbjgeMbteuBNPKfh nik/aTrjigOnQPVKecfzjyqkq9ChIgROPJ8s8dTbDyzwhXWBgBeFgAe6FMxNeSdiHfCsQ2vg/jf8 RitXzZ4dv1qhAyAc2tJWDtgIVFd30gt0+cCfe+ADWRULSpNywWb8uB3lAoiT/8+52uDX66SCX47q iP+rCiDPIcFgCj8q1Ueb+lt+W6eLj2g2jSBJmatvl2XDGH/OiPX1gHb3VxEhE9wPTrh/aT+ujBfU KspzQmbSIHQHcxzgBlkJ2biVlOrkyZKN4dc9a8MhPOuBl64lwuzImeLjf0nAAsLMf695bX98fClc oSOGJTVhoSasCEUOiup646DH8xoXUiwo9cs7I2aY+kH2Jhg+FqhHhzBqGRDyzxRsG2wjAD7bvv1H 3a7gY1GXUOHOvXykLtQHbQ9805N0QPZa+2zP5wDGUsI5Bk6mCzi0wOWUt4TqI2n0sed9IpXsy+Z8 1V6EtzUJhFWroo3boH6Ze+LbxIq7y9VQ0kz7MUWQ2hSkZ/CmiuGUPy/QEVsu6E+9IOgAZHK+kr2l K1kjqWzRs/knGVVO3r0muAG0QdILnKleU2cBHKKXsH20BagilvE70JvvCD3+RalZ59xUY6UKNP1p HWd+EMWSREaMxQNE1XI+SDMNHhcsBAWMiP1KOdtdbx3FUQnNjbb9NyOiBmtld+qIOVooEGbiL0SG jes5gxgUYlQlaiwUKWIerwWsTCDBRsssXAVA0vdwM/ReprNewudHUesxgZpHEzt4ZkBhqkc78QWt RLMfDc6T0p9x6z/aTmChEZRLlS2oCkpDw+O4R0gPGkTgdkA+KCZ863QGlIX6LpqcDXf5OJGOogza hqCRa2h3sCL/ouoAJIDWkn0nHbzd2kScMJpQMoRm3Nj2gHyQ196ZuCWebt/c461EC7GEKLghiGvl K5dRqDa4msaKqRjAlB1ifRsB/jmoPGAFIoNlA5nXxEQpjtmhLyioK+XIQZNaG2v91S+xdekAmneE 4M3tJ5oBvVaXrwpHukhCVVxrh1JAc22D7pvznkOnn2dGSQIL2uvo6/VpwAJjA3xJC0DGpJIkyF8x zvdosNKFx/KY7HuXO7vqAK7t5EFNE3SZhSJqxjpsmh6zFxMaqqa707WWctnjUzL7rVxiB1ob5bYp HaFiTIkdK2FyRo/vd+Ql4nPnzUDlPC3WhcTq8+duF5cAX2N2cc99JbvbqQlxOCKrH3V1f7jZd0Ly PGZ7kRjdUetYcqdBmLYlcgc51HDFodMHsH4s6KvLgjYDKCqH7EvylzwubfJN+0nV1iOy5FMMjB27 wEJ8p3G0xZLpwsOXBBMBCgBBAhkAAp4BApsDBQsJCAcDBRUKCQgLBRYCAwEAAheAFiEEIjkmhwtQ LOwo99lQzNAm/KiWBjgFAlwJenwFCQlQEg4ACgkQzNAm/KiWBjgcqR/9FOdVX2Zp64cpRfaU0Cgc 4sfMiDrhYwpGLWAJcRvwXJ4bJ5EYpShgx8ObwAfOvBlWBFGIGICoODcZq1Yu/KAxn3mvDTYKZwhA HOYZ9AtzVCDKq+m/VhWu6Tnv1HRSkgMkM3CrAJZRxoXS20pjqjcjFriJPLTmso2r4biXnAhWyBTt v8M1ZpqAieU3dsphphikC1827Uh7HA1bkDcYq/xcUzaQapgIQFgLqWwIuKJXnA96zjM//P0wuIml SiVTLB3rJr5ZYOHaxSpr7GJc4gvHMFmtcR4wUZ8vkrU1BmYQVzMfzkl8utU1jmCca8cOL2WBddvN fY5IfZLFQWRAn+21FhxWQcmOmo4ioiQ+oNmcksfHNL1olnc8+4NEQAC0dbnfKNxV2s0/HjDSAwdG 60WRRrl5iQMIBFXhinHkvi7XALN0iyZ60l7yWWclHuBU4Ch45WnbjlTit9BNdA4XLcrRkP5463V3 kIoGhtDnotXwQJmgGqGYwTmJ7bmeGTlFbo9/XwqRMBeymS8QcgT5i7wUTdMcDO/5l8Jr7Vv0u8uN oCUI3jizu/5j+9mHHSKRe10ityXxiC/5jlCaJOsPJ6NhYWBTWDbhZIzvZYqJv/DYyMFXrRHvv6zl 7rZYbSzJ16J3d7euLc1ulClwVbAbtFitZ0p7XpbNbnbedjgLp1OQaV/BbY1QpFngEG5nPf00TMzm RUXo/QTfvooZaLlQuJeNkRSHsWlskPgkWSaEvMpL0FSCp89AJKP/HNxMPy7Gy9S1SV0+3dk3aSxb Ouv1liRURe62SbDT7kaMvRknEV9UbtnqtjGHtBXtb+aHCov9E1NGVdbql8WUDUGwWtKcUG2BtOdU E8bpxh8AMM6UoNkK9PuvhYSGHIFRyUuP7x+SO/PleWPM19BwhcPvXUILjjiM2TP+I5ulvdgtzQwO eKWWPd5DasReTOJYxgG6NJVwSb+b1jVr70XI0bbZypoHC6AO+N1IfaLN1CXITrAQLpRTPhdFi0MA 33uHEj4u76aV6a3kveDXMfswEAlc9vE5K1vGRVCy005OvnTDp9ToDTVK/7zcFLmwfEOozwKBHxDe RIrpQJq/gyXP11aIXhzYsvw8qOmQFHLLMKhlIwlpF8DUVXU8Cma9fdvYU/Zm9s81rLIWA2oEzcmG OxGjAO7jTZH/yMx4wRSQ90hIeYkN8azm5WHoxLx0vlQB6vCHinBvVsc3ccm+6qbuRuGBWX86MSRS uWyX5AGO4d40yGNHTgS/yvH7oGNndbqPt8r/LBTnIBtUUlUFI9/U/qLNEkYZC4jncM6uaLhyyo7i CHiwOn8YGOKlxCw2eJCh1uzaI2yiwcSmztGG56T9E3XFtwyyxsqoHc0aTWF4IEhhcm1vbnkgPCpA bWF4aC5tZS51az7Cw5IEEwEKADwCGwMCHgECF4AFCw0JDAgDFQoJBRYCAwEAFiEEIjkmhwtQLOwo 99lQzNAm/KiWBjgFAl4OeGoFCQs9VPwACgkQzNAm/KiWBjgsCiAArT/HGBR+33xbiF7P2P9aCkWP n8iCWtd4rIRkDoJYJABR7NZTJpdvp7LUVIspEanXxZ9Om1vI+qsLu7fPRjEwwMfndUBTZYi1JY6K YazcwacOguvHAZVPiEaSkIP1e//YXL69odY6q67pyPIaiPSG6KhHnSD9wO/5lt671TWcPoNIOd6a JzsqVS9/X9jxPVBDsoPjFd1/9DM6QW4wSQjc+MWORelMwDW4MYcRK8D3X5Sh+Fy9eeYLAVPpYBuY z066zA6/Gcx/8awHKsAAO9yUnA4+4xf0OeykXfVy7MAP9MWDMAoW8+lL6YCYHl5l3IYAqxSPW0w5 sXyLtHkEmHv04JbDYUVx7ndQ79TxIjLgL3vjfCjuDvZC01vnUyn0cSy8MlxLKxuENoo/XVlXXja+ 05z02AVJfUVAVBPLYaL1U8t0irN8dPHtX4C5Qi2VGCyhr9nmwmsARyxqvhlXiVukHgsAfonLC0yn 9PFZcK0WMBYBGogiY7QMk4oiYfo/fmQ4T5e4TGs6qXyhlOy0nIc42EqvJn2J7Q2cSYBI98imuldr AvsIItok94xl/2EBnYxp9tvBwZo4789fomefVza31/FtTwbAIOCo6c5Z/GjflP7cvtCaQGgeapPa kUDjxr20mP57Ep/lCEeVqOqT/HdeCDTs8pbYFQOGzewIM7t61yDLp8pcB1eOVAHnC3ZRdgNDy6BW 2mjuctqLhIwZjRQVyaPigraReHyIC78r+BEZMZqhogze9X0vAONrkTt8Q+0JgREBfHi4YRSMpzqu hmTl2ujIu/vyjOHyej9z5FP0l/FzQr8y9DktlVvqDFjomKrYC3deAZj1jtXFzCM5yM/ECx+/TTI+ yWk3zMWLs7LR1uGS5tHtX0JCrRsKVAFOLJ3+t0M5uNSnUbgIv/bqaF0sTBfgYQJWHWjvFDrFr2E5 FVmZnA9SZDM/R10xh4guWXRtPri8MNn9iswttsIa5A8NNcTIAuxkoTDBb5cyBHpaWD8wFVi2B5YV YjFcj8c9IP1NuDtJ6egxs3hgtD19JesbGSBx0XmKwpHKb5e5jv/XwqwV2QujcrcgB04VxvXmwkm4 HQ8wT0Nnqo3nfDqSCfU2c46J5PwYwMoJBoMQAZYcC8/qK8Y1B8q7b4P+BUX0Ky+4jDgL0XIbndQ4 fzWhXjNdCpIsSKCYprQ/w2C4Bda9PCryILNvRc2Z6B8VJYBLJDAiwzi2DrGj4nL033MgLzeE5Krz k5vl+H6G+ilX39DZGpqpo/u4N+7NCo5o29V6hR6VHbfVjaLC+kHWJCysmcu3bNrjona231OM638/ 4sbJQs04SSN8LYLemb5sXOgkHI23NcBrGjuWGw0vaNlsHsxCQ87DTQRUvJyeASAA4f4zgtqhfOef Ccr9kP0o4xZL1wpMMmQq++Pe9g1E06y7Vn4Ba6soLBFibhW6KPBXpKOBuwz72zM/lzEaLlAtd9mP nwCCaztDHrj4LZWRlYpGl5ODm86tr9uOkMTBC2PJx1MjqqeXLq6UnCc96j1E0z7F5NnJWwybDRqy Up8oR2iPDPWoj3U+MZTiejnu+B22+ITwei4DcRikv1/eMAgnJ0R0p9lGSVusozZM0zspwouPvESi +fyEw4j5QIP4miw2HNYjOiI8zmG7mAipRSqp+GUAgits62yjIVPxXNaUWkFIt+XdCxAzopbGULub K2jd0Ho/9WvY5MBzqtqWuX+5x/HH1kDN5eZFpn9Gmo2na2VtWyuVTwkMQ8rMVf7SEBOdsMWbinoL /eiOWifXmBN7Vmb6tdYVMuMQEGaK+Q4hsx0nEApp/BSkD//1h504DmPVrVoK6Vyuo8HBkPCpcjPK kHH3mzMRmyYlPqjRCUqcByreTLkSuLsN19IbHOyDqSjvVyt3iWzm1MD/Em/zOY2Dv0TZ86iv5MTT dk4E9WGM3b6sOlHlRZQr9LYJJHLqqVakdO0uHMqW5cmRcAiYaqJcVC7dLJOkSaBfhRswCBKg1bKk IppuH4y21GScF/e/XNgKplLRjPWCajSCW5G9D4dMyR+/DCinSH16fG0W+yO2hPLKmjKlkY726cFQ 1558t5fqV+V4WqQZqWOGiJ2Iko9T7Ww+xpGsDOlVrJRdfMYVjPJOziwP0ndOc6Xvqksp23kOxiWo unIjz9h+3i4zfdM4eVxyAozRQYzi3UurwlUMwfK03utHrLe7b9XyZxh4+pfbQp+LfFKZd8nnXz82 6j8C1zSYplAWyIPDy3IcYFFC3elz1o0cVeOTL7tRpVOKtac6d9efSDRi+58L2CaS02ajdUXRyOLV bDEpKgexhcCwAUZsEt5DfFMiBnwUlq/OBc6OC/1iz5Tx7kl2WwdIPW9FhM0Pp6zU5ZraF6cwQ1k6 fg5kmrMWsZW5hXHS9KdR76Ttt3WaRVMH6Y4ypQTyeznvcDqNKOrpo7xrJGNaCxQyHZ5PzzRDsADY SDGOvSOE2Kq5Bd1/M/kvfAXD1EzBUuvFNqaXp/ONoRlSy5hz4Mihtx4a1JEezjWyMss8Ke8+Ikjd fD2fRdMERAsPssqvOWZNK2PXYvyY2OWtOkUXwpJFTwH3rGkyDI9BR3nLsV/QwfOdE2fNUxCt3BLB NOT+zDL7EzUWUnguOC7MK21blOsTVRFJLikvIkrK0ex7EQrxMFpMrHbsNeY7tYThFd+gtHQhCYIZ pHaEW5SOM2zj7XU/UYXD6Z5IMHMKGDJUKKuZCrPcpKUIyD+N2c506kpbUUXtvwARAQABwsN8BBgB CgAmApsMFiEEIjkmhwtQLOwo99lQzNAm/KiWBjgFAl4OeEsFCQ0T/F0ACgkQzNAm/KiWBjgX9B/+ NEuFh3Oea8/swspuDdSBehPgEiZl6Aa3/IKIW16IiL4GM/ZnjT4MLcR4rw6P94Km+GJrwif00TAL D619fWcFuZdoIUlLSyk+8UcLfNrPamSYdrLsEnGmoPDxuKUVRjfzvp15Jfhms59/Q4QHetORWwxN no/c4SIA5WjpEWpUPhzX1TKsEd8yz9e7J36oJ100Zr+B42eAbL0jgAoVih852eCqVDOMAEc29JEd wYwyqkaLokVi0sJGl9Xpd9QMte9WOtxTTNP21rvJ9YiJ2yHmfbiaQjXe5o7enNvsdXZZK+l0swfX LciZA4f0V4Jf0i/mJoPjsZBYfnaG5mY1njCmqBebODRlgu7fIlizdIb1POC3DqOer1qYOiBIG5g8 wwFrUtXKmPm4pwKSF4eaRP9s4ti2gjRLDVsLPYgwU/2SaxOJlEGL8ijPrQgwcuY9eEGrByfk3vAn BGPf1ylVL0VJoEqIbrnCu1b+poGL4noW5QQUAc3Ts2+Ra1cC5mJNlmvhXZ0SsO8+g+Gf6OC4KSet nwI5J2Plk4N5G9wy9ODIKIf1U11DmF8038UaKiGmMAzbOuF7VPTcm984/gS5clnimlFe+XKPspza dXNeOjFY9UrGfY+HTHCjEwMwhlDQe1qmIhtWVBDOz4oYdYyDRD7O3Egzm2TeHM4p4b677vLveO51 hSDtEsJwG6/Co15TMNG+BN6M4+NYn3pFjMIMONahHISgXkHSkajaPzDJbnIrmxRM5GwhuPSr9hCY RnKzFgV+Prjaje3MddHtmCdhSaQPV9uuti9E6sLuvvVuneBOZLW4l9W3eWX0J6uDgcBmwP2i4rdq XUrIO/RvNtttWC9lIPQyRwfIn4dzQNrR0F559ialjLuWIF2IOdLAozV3OahOaNL9QM7yCvxBaEuI GTqkLzB1jfzrypKD113Ae7sHk4HLYXL59BprMRnlRoVfCFMd8FhV4IfBH0PuEng9hxUjd8NPPq1M TF4kyH2/kNxWikfQ5rZhCDunPKN+cm/VLVRhmB8GZQbjq8+KfCMqK/LcmJ0xdSFSj/wvvNxBkAHV FK7C2PynYei4M7Fs+ETvWB/x00kydoOv78KFNnqgFstkEz6jQbZwZWqX7EuBc1hwhPGP/3fqEIU0 f0jbf7M6oEC78wTk0L9reW6Hj3/vS87UTK3X2V+9WbN6N250zjXs58ZK0K+xDfbaFhMmVuNwD8NQ xTTBd6hUnFN6WWY4WyNPiWaYyNQAUTjUV1deD0RVkCEDtqE22A6BH2s4qfgfmN/BHwv0trMu0Vai ANhH603dswT9qQc4f1iZQw0hVHpna2u1kBC3rGap5FwffMjvbsNu/3WyE+YgXeOnda36fDDQ7Q== =kmuB
    -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
    --------------h36ZJ-OPwkDKpJMpP/B5zb3q--


    --l6CxLD5hZghg2C9l7yJiYFy6lpQ6kaJC7--

    -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

    wsN5BAABCAAjFiEEIjkmhwtQLOwo99lQzNAm/KiWBjgFAl/DSGUFAwAAAAAACgkQzNAm/KiWBjiU jiAAtJ2eD6Ee69coQibQwh+kNmN72rmob4AtTO72J7MBUrKU07Ag7J02FoCfcRAM+VU42N5bYDSH 7Yb+X+P9HyIhoLKtFcQVcaRDWWu3esjCtmSH5ZncluuPJpw5maXbNBMIlajCgJkdkR5IgC19jIg6 YkZsl7xZ5nFCLgZ+uh3n8RYYlA0x+0T8E6PKVhKIYb27xkHnpTmgg70dDiAGiiDU0nPpIiZG2/ds fqbfcpQP7xHO0OtJY1la3+fm+1h3B7xTsAZ1GTW4LpqYoEdlGlN4WGVRBSkpx+FDDBoR8JZJlVxI BbzoCvRjPB4sY2LDUQ5jxHXTZ55H+gtowc5BDJBCu9IKw9k78/5KTqQ1gdy3clLvAH1AvPvviqJr 2lNCupu9O8FLkBsY1Miyx/UeQHwwRMFQg5qFyZykfy/ejUi7JkxGXlsjhx9sjSRXq8jozA+nYPcw I5j7yg3jndqkHZJB2bZ8Qbjm2Efi+XSFQ+RI+k0y23AYnib1lN5DMoGSlAnPmNGh58LDukFRC7lM 0V9xqDdRODTtYxXs7ylu9NfPGZgG2W2pUhVArfk7vBVcagEa8KLcDaLwOhuZTrGu+Mzkq1SQF56O OogMIBdklSR8OM1gGJo/s80uFBEf1jQOp971kn95TO0cMJyKDwbO2rIUDJA2qF44QgDhxMJc86+X nlo7OX5Ca2oeclPvNgvfLo6pGLBA6qdDXu2PipmGtf1kRFimeXQjvASJF0Z+zIxINw4WuecvodS4 yvCsNvHesD91PFVYbI6AiISjDAwyzZa+zvVn/q9b5G/yzhs54LcciJ1HqljnOOkrYLPOVuDIWJGg 2asway4+qjrJFjJgeH+ybwmMNY8Xa0US4EWW4igCqXX/0qhvWprSoIAhKvNAn7xumB7UN+MG8B9o hpszXHEU+q37yXAOPOxYGXQwCXHeJcnFIgfoSUK05PHDCxbQpfGsJwRgE5wkZwfvEodw3TiYemFm VBryjJJTvZXs/jRQZ4T6g/CGQDJGSddsZOrFLwEFPX+8Y1raeVDJQgamzR18VSKCNhkC2O+a4/Hz DxpT06Wq+2+NCnsSQyVYepo6xASqCnwInsdU6joS8IQdp1XTELKse/VhWKtl0F+ymxOpKLftJggy JG8Uw4ctYpC+OZSvEDW/qN9IU/7+ONzqOeETZLAZLAeonHHfF8BXZQ64/suxxwJOzEQVPs//xUMg s5r9YqBQPXNWRyw0p+/798ml7zMi+WO4hhWhlnnZNF+3jCw4TRN8Uagx2YlrNwwSHx6dkMfuyBdv X6dOERxeazzenirxx5j3aaIJVc3h0PrerZBsmIZhRERF/Fai2AcjfX6JnG96NAJkD628aeRamPLW mA==
    =QP5E
    -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Magnus de Laval@21:1/5 to All on Thu Dec 10 11:56:22 2020
    You could consider 305.9 as basically clarification that any card with "Land" on the type line can't be cast. A card like Ancient Den (Artifact Land) or Dryad Arbor (Land Creature) cannot be cast even though they are an Artifact and a Creature
    respectively, as "lands cannot be cast" overrides "creatures and artifacts can be cast". MDFCs are a little different, as each side of the card could be considered separate cards for casting/playing purposes. E.g. the side Emeria's Call is never
    considered a Land, and Emeria, Shattered Skyclave is never considered a Sorcery (queue Crucible of Worlds shenanigans...).

    söndag 18 oktober 2020 kl. 03:02:25 UTC+2 skrev ne...@zzo38computer.org.invalid:
    Rule 305.9 says that an object that is both a land and another type cannot be cast, but it doesn't otherwise say that a land cannot be cast. Is this
    a mistake? It seems unintentional to me, that it should say that any object whose type is land cannot be cast, whether or not it has any other types.

    I found this when discussing on IRC about modal double-face cards, and how some specific rules regarding them work.

    --
    This signature intentionally left blank.
    (But if it has these words, then actually it isn't blank, isn't it?)

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)