• More reasons why XG and Gnubg are garbage

    From MK@21:1/5 to All on Mon Jan 9 11:39:54 2023
    I found it impossible to use these "learning
    tool" bots to play bot vs. bot, bot vs. human,
    human vs. human, using manual dice.

    In XG, even if you uncheck "auto roll" option, it
    displays the dice dialog for computer player/s
    automatically anyway. So, you can't do anything
    else until you roll. By that time it is too late to do
    anything else like looking at dice distribution, etc.
    before rolling the dice. If you close the dialog by
    clicking the "X", it reverts to internal dice and rolls
    the dice right away. After that you need to reset
    the dice to manual, go back to the position, click
    "play from position", select "different dice" option
    just to get back to square one and keep looping...

    What a cheap "gilded brown lily"...! :(

    In Gnubg, human vs. human seems to work okay.

    In bot vs. human, even if you uncheck "auto roll"
    option, it displays the dice dialog for computer
    player/s automatically anyway also. If you close
    the dice dialog without rolling, then you are totally
    screwed. After looking at temperature map, etc. if
    you click "game" then "play computer turn", it rolls
    00, displays "player cannot move" and waits for you
    to click to roll the dice for the other player. Then you
    need to go to back two steps to the previous roll for
    the human player, play it and when the dice dialog
    is displayed, roll or repeat the above... :(

    It's worse in bot vs bot. If you close the dice dialog
    without rolling, you have to click the "stop button"
    first (to interrupt whatever it's busy doing). Then if
    you click "game" then "play computer turn", it rolls
    00, displays "player cannot move" but in this case
    since the other player is also a bot, it displays the
    dice dialog automatically again. Then you need to
    go to back two steps to the previous roll for the first
    bot, click "game" then "play computer turn" to make
    it play that roll again. When when the dice dialog for
    the second bot player is displayed, roll or repeat the
    above... :(

    What a free "gilded brown lily"...! :(

    MK

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)