I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"
Pilot: Jim J6, AKA “Airport Bum”damage or incidents (knock on wood). Silver/Gold/Diamond, all in pure gliders, got all the Diamonds south-of-the-Mason-Dixon-line and east-of-the-Mississippi (woohoo!). Flew that banner day in 1985 where a half dozen of us flew the first FAI 500k
Pure glider experience: A little over 1000 hours total in pure gliders, 700+ of this XC (badges, competition). Mostly in ASW-20, spread over 40+ years (some time off here and there for career reasons). About 25 or so off-airport landings, with no
Motorglider experience: Acquired an ASH-26E in 2016, since then a little over 500 hours in motorglider, almost all XC (expeditions/camps, competition). Around half a dozen “self-retrieves”, e.g. engine starts during an XC flight to end the soaringportion on course away from the home airport. No failures to start in-flight (yet).
Flying style: I think conservative, safety and fun first and foremost. Main focus is camp/expedition flying, small groups exploring remote soaring arenas primarily in the western USA, utilizing the freedom from towplanes offered by self-launchmotorized gliders. Also competition (but mostly for the socializing I must admit).
How has my soaring XC flight planning/conduct changed with motorgliding:free pass. EVERY time I get low, I follow the same “altitude funnel” approach I took in pure gliders, progressively homing in on my landable field as I attempt to scratch out of hole. My mindset is that if I don’t scratch out of the hole I am in, I
Basic philosophy: “Treat every successful in-flight engine start as a pleasant surprise.”
Therefore, there is hardly any difference in my in-flight behaviors as far as staying in gliding distance (with margin!) of high-confidence landable fields. The start-engine button is NOT there to get me out of a jam nor is it a guaranteed get-home-
As far as pre-flight planning, again for me hardly any difference motorgliding vs pure. There is always a basic plan for me to be trackable (including if I have to jump out, e.g. InReach in a SMAK Pack on my chute), and for someone to come get me if (actually, when) my get-home engine start fails and I land out. This is usually an understanding with my other self-launch buddies (I always fly XC with a buddy, at least someone flying out of the same airport and in the same general soaring arena, or
There are some detail differences:7.6 with my ASW-20. There have been a few instances where I “landed out” (get-home engine start) on weak competition days when my pure glider buddies dumped their water ballast and climbed out in the weak stuff that couldn’t keep me up. I accept
My motorglider is more challenging to dig out when low and in weak lift, wind, etc. because it is HEAVY (wing loading/climb performance) and BIG (not as maneuverable). Heavy because of the engine etc., e.g. my wing loading is about 9.2 lb per sq ft vs
But the biggest difference is increased conservatism in my off-field landing choices and my “hard deck” discipline. My big heavy self-launcher lands with significantly more energy than my pure glider, so my off-airport field choices are morelimited. I cannot land as short or as slow as I could in my pure glider ASW-20. So I stick with bigger fields. And regarding my “hard deck” for stopping soaring and committing to landing (or get-home engine start, treated as a pleasant surprise of
Another idea here: If things get hairy, and I am set up to land at an airport that I could self-launch out of, I will strongly consider just landing without even attempting an in-air start. Just land, meet the locals (almost always a pleasure), andthen self-launch to head home! I haven’t done this yet, but it is definitely in my mind if I end up in a stressful situation and want to skip a start attempt.
Another very important subtlety: Note that when flying the high country (example: the Rockies west of Denver and east of Grand Junction) the engine is little more than ballast, because when at peak and pass altitudes you are up where the under-powerclimb rates are pitiful or non-existent. You probably cannot motor home unless you are in the valleys that feed to your home airport. So you better have landable fields available. So, just like a pure glider…..
The final difference for me is simply the freedom to explore that the motorglider offers. I haven’t used this very much yet (except the ability to fly sites which don’t have towplanes, I use that a lot on my annual western soaring safaris). ButEric is my hero in this regard, he does it well. The idea is to use the motor if necessary to extend the soaring day and/or reach that very-interesting soaring area which would be otherwise inaccessible. No claim that this is “pure soaring”, but it
One final consideration: Once I have been pleasantly surprised by an engine start, I STILL fly it like a glider. I won’t leave the safety of being in a “funnel” to a landable field even when under power. My engine when running is a “tickingtime bomb” on its way to premature shutdown, as far as I am concerned.
I have sincerely tried to analyze motorglider operations in an attempt to enhance my safety and enjoyment. I hope these ideas can be useful to others. So there we go, open for polite and positive comments, especially if someone sees a non-conservativeor less-than-safe aspect to my approach. Lots to learn here I am sure.
Cheers,
Jim J6
On Sunday, May 1, 2022 at 11:48:42 AM UTC-5, J6 aka Airport Bum wrote:
I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"
Pilot: Jim J6, AKA “Airport Bum”damage or incidents (knock on wood). Silver/Gold/Diamond, all in pure gliders, got all the Diamonds south-of-the-Mason-Dixon-line and east-of-the-Mississippi (woohoo!). Flew that banner day in 1985 where a half dozen of us flew the first FAI 500k
Pure glider experience: A little over 1000 hours total in pure gliders, 700+ of this XC (badges, competition). Mostly in ASW-20, spread over 40+ years (some time off here and there for career reasons). About 25 or so off-airport landings, with no
Motorglider experience: Acquired an ASH-26E in 2016, since then a little over 500 hours in motorglider, almost all XC (expeditions/camps, competition). Around half a dozen “self-retrieves”, e.g. engine starts during an XC flight to end the soaringportion on course away from the home airport. No failures to start in-flight (yet).
Flying style: I think conservative, safety and fun first and foremost. Main focus is camp/expedition flying, small groups exploring remote soaring arenas primarily in the western USA, utilizing the freedom from towplanes offered by self-launchmotorized gliders. Also competition (but mostly for the socializing I must admit).
How has my soaring XC flight planning/conduct changed with motorgliding:free pass. EVERY time I get low, I follow the same “altitude funnel” approach I took in pure gliders, progressively homing in on my landable field as I attempt to scratch out of hole. My mindset is that if I don’t scratch out of the hole I am in, I
Basic philosophy: “Treat every successful in-flight engine start as a pleasant surprise.”
Therefore, there is hardly any difference in my in-flight behaviors as far as staying in gliding distance (with margin!) of high-confidence landable fields. The start-engine button is NOT there to get me out of a jam nor is it a guaranteed get-home-
As far as pre-flight planning, again for me hardly any difference motorgliding vs pure. There is always a basic plan for me to be trackable (including if I have to jump out, e.g. InReach in a SMAK Pack on my chute), and for someone to come get me if (actually, when) my get-home engine start fails and I land out. This is usually an understanding with my other self-launch buddies (I always fly XC with a buddy, at least someone flying out of the same airport and in the same general soaring arena, or
There are some detail differences:7.6 with my ASW-20. There have been a few instances where I “landed out” (get-home engine start) on weak competition days when my pure glider buddies dumped their water ballast and climbed out in the weak stuff that couldn’t keep me up. I accept
My motorglider is more challenging to dig out when low and in weak lift, wind, etc. because it is HEAVY (wing loading/climb performance) and BIG (not as maneuverable). Heavy because of the engine etc., e.g. my wing loading is about 9.2 lb per sq ft vs
But the biggest difference is increased conservatism in my off-field landing choices and my “hard deck” discipline. My big heavy self-launcher lands with significantly more energy than my pure glider, so my off-airport field choices are morelimited. I cannot land as short or as slow as I could in my pure glider ASW-20. So I stick with bigger fields. And regarding my “hard deck” for stopping soaring and committing to landing (or get-home engine start, treated as a pleasant surprise of
Another idea here: If things get hairy, and I am set up to land at an airport that I could self-launch out of, I will strongly consider just landing without even attempting an in-air start. Just land, meet the locals (almost always a pleasure), andthen self-launch to head home! I haven’t done this yet, but it is definitely in my mind if I end up in a stressful situation and want to skip a start attempt.
Another very important subtlety: Note that when flying the high country (example: the Rockies west of Denver and east of Grand Junction) the engine is little more than ballast, because when at peak and pass altitudes you are up where the under-powerclimb rates are pitiful or non-existent. You probably cannot motor home unless you are in the valleys that feed to your home airport. So you better have landable fields available. So, just like a pure glider…..
The final difference for me is simply the freedom to explore that the motorglider offers. I haven’t used this very much yet (except the ability to fly sites which don’t have towplanes, I use that a lot on my annual western soaring safaris). ButEric is my hero in this regard, he does it well. The idea is to use the motor if necessary to extend the soaring day and/or reach that very-interesting soaring area which would be otherwise inaccessible. No claim that this is “pure soaring”, but it
One final consideration: Once I have been pleasantly surprised by an engine start, I STILL fly it like a glider. I won’t leave the safety of being in a “funnel” to a landable field even when under power. My engine when running is a “tickingtime bomb” on its way to premature shutdown, as far as I am concerned.
I have sincerely tried to analyze motorglider operations in an attempt to enhance my safety and enjoyment. I hope these ideas can be useful to others. So there we go, open for polite and positive comments, especially if someone sees a non-conservativeor less-than-safe aspect to my approach. Lots to learn here I am sure.
Cheers,No offense "Bum", but I find reading Faulkners , "The Bear" much more interesting even with his void of punctuation. Old Bob, The Purist
Jim J6
On Sunday, May 1, 2022 at 11:48:42 AM UTC-5, J6 aka Airport Bum wrote:
I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"
I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"conduct have changed now that you are flying a motorglider vs a pure glider, and perhaps some polite non-judgemental discussion on our fellow motorglider pilot's posts.
So, in the interest of generating positive and educational discussion on this subject, I am opening this new conversation. I would like to make this a "judgement free zone", by which I mean let's just hear about how soaring XC flight planning and
It is relevant to understand the commenter's pure vs motorglider experience in regard to this question, I believe, so let's start each post with a little on that about yourself. The vast majority of the current motorglider pilot population has hadextensive pure glider experience before taking up the motorglider I think, so my expectation is that there will be lots of productive comparison insights and tips gained here. At least that is my hope.
So, motorglider pilots, please offer up your experience and ideas on this subject, I'll bet we'll all learn some useful things. Remember, "judgement free" please. If a post states something that you would like to challenge for any reason (less-than-safe, factually incorrect, etc.) please be polite and non-confrontational in your reply.
I'll go first, with the next post to this conversation. I will document my experience probably in more detail than required, just to kick things off with ideas on how you might describe your relevant experience levels. Don't feel compelled to write upas much detail, we primarily want your insights, ideas, and tips.
Cheers,
Jim J6
On Sunday, May 1, 2022 at 12:48:42 PM UTC-4, J6 aka Airport Bum wrote:conduct have changed now that you are flying a motorglider vs a pure glider, and perhaps some polite non-judgemental discussion on our fellow motorglider pilot's posts.
I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"
So, in the interest of generating positive and educational discussion on this subject, I am opening this new conversation. I would like to make this a "judgement free zone", by which I mean let's just hear about how soaring XC flight planning and
extensive pure glider experience before taking up the motorglider I think, so my expectation is that there will be lots of productive comparison insights and tips gained here. At least that is my hope.It is relevant to understand the commenter's pure vs motorglider experience in regard to this question, I believe, so let's start each post with a little on that about yourself. The vast majority of the current motorglider pilot population has had
safe, factually incorrect, etc.) please be polite and non-confrontational in your reply.So, motorglider pilots, please offer up your experience and ideas on this subject, I'll bet we'll all learn some useful things. Remember, "judgement free" please. If a post states something that you would like to challenge for any reason (less-than-
up as much detail, we primarily want your insights, ideas, and tips.I'll go first, with the next post to this conversation. I will document my experience probably in more detail than required, just to kick things off with ideas on how you might describe your relevant experience levels. Don't feel compelled to write
What Jim and Hank said! About 1200 hr in a ASW20, than a '27. About 15 non-airport landings.Then about 600 in 2 different DG8xx. The first DG800B caused a landout on my first self launched flight!Cheers,The only difference for me is that i can fly some days I otherwise could not fly because I don't need a tow. I tow or instruct on weekends and never fly my ships then, but I have the option to launch myself on a Wednesday and go soaring.
Jim J6
I do not fly any differently with or without the power system.
UH
But the biggest difference is increased conservatism in my off-field landing choices and my “hard deck” discipline. My big heavy self-launcher lands with significantly more energy than my pure glider, so my off-airport field choices are morelimited. I cannot land as short or as slow as I could in my pure glider ASW-20. So I stick with bigger fields.
On 5/1/2022 9:49 AM, J6 aka Airport Bum wrote:limited. I cannot land as short or as slow as I could in my pure glider ASW-20. So I stick with bigger fields.
But the biggest difference is increased conservatism in my off-field landing choices and my “hard deck” discipline. My big heavy self-launcher lands with significantly more energy than my pure glider, so my off-airport field choices are more
My experience and concern is identical to Jim's: My ASW20C was significantly easier to
land in a field. There is another issue: the weight of the motorglider makes it harder to
retrieve. The fuselage on my ASH26E weighs 500 lbs, far more than the fuselage on the
ASW20C, so getting it out of a farmer's field could be very difficult. As result, I
strongly favor doing a restart over an airport. This factor, along with the higher minimum
wing loading, means I don't "save" as many flights as I used to.
--
Eric Greenwell - USA
- "A Guide to Self-launching Sailplane Operation" https://sites.google.com/site/motorgliders/publications
I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"conduct have changed now that you are flying a motorglider vs a pure glider, and perhaps some polite non-judgemental discussion on our fellow motorglider pilot's posts.
So, in the interest of generating positive and educational discussion on this subject, I am opening this new conversation. I would like to make this a "judgement free zone", by which I mean let's just hear about how soaring XC flight planning and
It is relevant to understand the commenter's pure vs motorglider experience in regard to this question, I believe, so let's start each post with a little on that about yourself. The vast majority of the current motorglider pilot population has hadextensive pure glider experience before taking up the motorglider I think, so my expectation is that there will be lots of productive comparison insights and tips gained here. At least that is my hope.
So, motorglider pilots, please offer up your experience and ideas on this subject, I'll bet we'll all learn some useful things. Remember, "judgement free" please. If a post states something that you would like to challenge for any reason (less-than-safe, factually incorrect, etc.) please be polite and non-confrontational in your reply.
I'll go first, with the next post to this conversation. I will document my experience probably in more detail than required, just to kick things off with ideas on how you might describe your relevant experience levels. Don't feel compelled to writeup as much detail, we primarily want your insights, ideas, and tips.
Cheers,
Jim J6
On 5/1/2022 12:48 PM, J6 aka Airport Bum wrote:conduct have changed now that you are flying a motorglider vs a pure glider, and perhaps some polite non-judgemental discussion on our fellow motorglider pilot's posts.
I noted an interesting subject coming up in an otherwise non-productive post on this group, "How does soaring XC flight planning/conduct differ Motorglider vs Pure glider?"
So, in the interest of generating positive and educational discussion on this subject, I am opening this new conversation. I would like to make this a "judgement free zone", by which I mean let's just hear about how soaring XC flight planning and
extensive pure glider experience before taking up the motorglider I think, so my expectation is that there will be lots of productive comparison insights and tips gained here. At least that is my hope.It is relevant to understand the commenter's pure vs motorglider experience in regard to this question, I believe, so let's start each post with a little on that about yourself. The vast majority of the current motorglider pilot population has had
safe, factually incorrect, etc.) please be polite and non-confrontational in your reply.So, motorglider pilots, please offer up your experience and ideas on this subject, I'll bet we'll all learn some useful things. Remember, "judgement free" please. If a post states something that you would like to challenge for any reason (less-than-
up as much detail, we primarily want your insights, ideas, and tips.I'll go first, with the next post to this conversation. I will document my experience probably in more detail than required, just to kick things off with ideas on how you might describe your relevant experience levels. Don't feel compelled to write
Cheers,As Jim knows, decision height for attempting a motor start is a lot
Jim J6
higher than landing decision height for a pure glider. In last R5N
contest during weak stretches, twice I detoured to position where I
could turn to final at a larger airport and attempt an air-start (where
in a pure glider I would have stuck to the course line), and both times
I climbed out. A failed air-start would have been easy straight-ahead landing.
I will try to finish that article in the next week or two, at least put
out a public draft...
See ya, Dave "YO" (>2500 hours in motor-gliders, gas and electric).
Sysop: | Keyop |
---|---|
Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
Users: | 295 |
Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
Uptime: | 04:05:58 |
Calls: | 6,642 |
Calls today: | 2 |
Files: | 12,190 |
Messages: | 5,325,740 |