• [Quora] What books should definitely not be movies?

    From D B Davis@21:1/5 to Moriarty on Wed Jul 31 15:30:12 2019
    Moriarty wrote:

    <snip>

    One of the better things about the low budget _Dune_ mini-series was Ian McNeice's Baron Harkonnen. He managed just the right mix of menace and manipulation that book-Baron did.

    Amen. McNeice's performance is "a delicious sight," so to speak. IMHO,
    this part of the treatment improves upon Herbert's original written
    word:

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------

    INT. DUKE LETO'S OFFICE - DAWN

    The Duke is propped up at his desk. A glazed look in his
    eyes. Clearly paralyzed but alert. He can SEE....

    BARON HARKONNEN across the room. With DeVries.
    And several other Harkonnen guards. And...

    DR. YUEH. Agitated.

    DR. YUEH
    ...my half of the bargain, Baron. I
    promised you the Duke, and there he is...

    BARON HARKONNEN
    And a delicious sight it is, Doctor.

    DR. YUEH
    ...now it's time for your half.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    And...believe it or not...I'm a man of my
    word.

    DR. YUEH
    Where is she!? You promised we'd be
    reunited. You said you'd free her if I
    did what you asked.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    Your wife is free, my good doctor.
    Completely free...

    And he floats across the room to a large draped object.
    Yanks the velvet curtains away to REVEAL...
    A glass SARCOPHAGUS. And a beautiful woman inside.
    Clearly dead!

    BARON HARKONNEN
    ...free of her mortal coil...free of her
    physical cage. I freed her.

    Yueh approaches the sarcophagus. Trembling. Unable to compute
    the deviousness of what's just been done to him.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    I promised you'd be reunited.

    Suddenly...DeVries steps in behind Yueh.
    Drives a dagger deep into his back.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    And I'm a man of my word, as now you can
    see.

    But as Yueh sinks, he manages to point a cursing finger at
    the Baron.

    DR. YUEH
    You...think...you've defeated...me.
    But he doesn't finish. He falls over...dead.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    Never trust a traitor. Not even one you
    create.
    (turning back to Leto)
    Well, my noble Duke, enjoying the show? I
    hope so. I've kept you alive so that you
    could witness every precious moment of
    your betrayal.

    DUKE LETO
    (barely audible)
    Paul...

    BARON HARKONNEN
    The boy? Dunno. Left him to the desert.
    He and that gorgeous woman of yours. Had
    to pry Piter off her. But we couldn't
    have noble blood on our hands now, could
    we? The Emperor was quite insistent about
    that.

    A small groan escapes Leto.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    Yes, your beloved Emperor. Just goes to
    show...never get more popular than the
    boss...unless you intend to sack him...

    The Baron jerks away in mock horror and embarrassment.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    Did I say that? How impolitic of me. I
    must be spending too much time with my
    idiot nephew, Rabban. Oh well, you won't
    tell, will you, dear man?

    DE VRIES
    Perhaps we should get on with it, then...

    BARON HARKONNEN
    Get on with it!? GET ON WITH IT!? This is
    KANLY, Piter! Vendetta! And I'm going to
    savor it! My family has hated the
    Atreides for generations. They've been
    the sand in our eye, the stink at our
    meals...these arrogant Atreides and their
    pompous honor...standing in our
    way...always standing in our way...

    He is floating around the room in a mad trance now.

    BARON HARKONNEN
    I want Leto to appreciate the beauty of
    what I've done to him. I want him to
    choke on the utter disgrace of his
    defeat...

    C.U. LETO. Straining to keep the Baron in focus.
    Straining to remember Yueh's last words to him.
    Straining to move his mouth!

    BARON HARKONNEN
    I want him to know that I, Baron Vladimir
    Harkonnen, am the instrument of his
    family's demise...the extinction of House
    Atreides...and the ascendance of House Harkonnen!!!

    http://duneinfo.com/Content/files/frank-herberts-dune-1.pdf

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------



    Thank you,

    --
    Don
    )\._.,--....,'``.
    /, _.. \ _\ (`._ ,.
    `._.-(,_..'--(,_..'`-.;.'
    My cat's telltale, tall tail tells tall tales.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)