• _Two Days, One Night_; _How to be a Good Wife_

    From septimus_millenicom@q.com@21:1/5 to All on Wed Nov 15 17:25:43 2023
    _Two Days, One Night_ is microdemocracy in motion, anchored
    by Marion Cotillard's career-best performance. In a way it
    is a trial, like _Anatomy of a Fall_, except that the jury is
    made up of Sandra (Cotillard's) coworkers, who will vote on
    whether she is rehired into their small factory at the expense
    of a 1000 euro bonus.

    It has taken me a long time to catch this film, given my
    aversion to Cotillard's prevailing sleepwalking acting style.
    Here credit must go to co-directors (the Dardenne brothers)
    who elicit such conflicted, lived-in, and hyper-emotional
    work from the usually laid-back actress. The two are renown
    for coaxing naturalist performances out of non-professional
    or unknown actors, but their work with established stars
    should not be overlooked. Sandra, who has just recovered
    from depression, wears the same beat-up pink T-shirt all
    film long and is frazzled to the point of despair as she
    calls on 16 of her coworkers to support her reinstatement.
    Just like in real life, women and immigrants prove more
    willing to help than the males, who are more likely to get
    into fist-fights or yell at their wives. But there are a
    few kind-hearted male characters, especially Sandra's
    endlessly supportive husband. One option she surprisingly
    does not consider is to pay 1000 euros to each coworker;
    that must be just a few months' salary, but I guess that
    would be buying votes, jury-rigging? Regardless, it is
    another heartfelt, humanistic story from the Dardennes,
    leaving you angry at our neo-liberal capitalist world
    order but also hopeful for the human race. The camera
    work and set designs are brilliant in an understated way
    and provide resistance to despair. I haven't caught up
    their recent film _Tori and Lupika_; their work doesn't
    seem to travel any more. But I will watch that eventually.

    -------------------------------------------------------

    Martin Provost, who has directed the brilliant _Violette_
    and the more middling _Midwife_, must be a more serious
    auteur than I gave him credit for. Only true auteurs
    go off the deep end and make something as incoherent
    and embarrassing as _How to be a Good Wife_. Juliette
    Binoche's Paulette Van der Beck is the headmistress of
    a finishing school for future housewives; her sister-in-
    law Gilberte (Yolande Moreau) and the nun Marie-Therese
    (Noemie Lvovsky, unrecognizable) provide campy support
    for the female enslavement instructions to a bunch of
    poor teenagers. You can say the film is about Paulette's
    comeuppance and redemption, but it gets lost in so many
    directions along the way, including her affair with a
    banker. Early on it seems the teenage girls might be
    the focus; then all their stories seem to be snapped off
    in the middle. The film starts out as a not-funny farce
    and ends as a musical. I'm sure Joe Wright, also
    prone to going rogue, will sympathize. Maybe I'm being
    harsh here; I have never taken to Binoche (one of the
    greatest dramatic actresses alive) as a comedian (see
    also her pratfalls in _Slack Bay_, which come to think
    of it I prefer to this film). She doesn't seem to
    have the Melanie Laurent or Sandrine Kiberlain sense
    of comic timing. This kind of broad comedy might be
    better off for Isabelle Huppert, who hasn't bothered
    to "act" for a while now. But I'm willing to be
    proved wrong! It is also possible Provost has not
    provided the foil for her to play off of. Provost
    has a film about Pierre Bonnard and his wife coming
    next. The director does much better with films about
    artists, and I am glad Bonnard gets some much deserved
    cinematic exposure. I sure prefer his paintings to
    Picasso's or Cezanne's, the flavor of the day (or
    century), both of whom are done to death in movies.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)