• _Titane_; _On War_

    From septimus_millenicom@q.com@21:1/5 to All on Sun May 22 12:09:53 2022
    There are two very disturbing things about
    _Titane_ which seem to have gone under the radar;
    most reviewers (even the professional ones)
    tend to focus on the graphic, superficial stuff.
    First, the film goes along with the glorification
    of serial killers rampant in cinema since _Silence
    of the Lambs_ (and maybe even before that). The
    scene where Alexia kills off 3 people in rapid
    successful is scored to an exciting rock score,
    as if we should be pulling for her. Second, it
    seems to describe sexually aggressive bisexual
    (or trisexual, if you count the cars) women,
    especially pregnant ones, as criminally insane,
    hormonal, unstable, and murderous. When she
    binds her breasts, passes herself off as a
    man, and partakes of the all-male ritualistic
    society of firefighters, she helps save lives.
    So the male hierarchy is somehow nurturing!
    Lead actress Agathe Rousselle is said to be a
    feminist journalist, and director Julia
    Ducournau's previous film _Raw_ is, well, I
    don't know how one should describe it but it
    certainly doesn't have a traditional female
    protagonist. But if the director were a man, we
    might have had push-back against this narrative.

    It is not clear why Alexia's birth parents seem
    to be dismissed as unfit and disposable by the
    film, while Vincent Lindon's broken-down
    fire-fighter should be the revered father figure.
    (Just because he is the bigger movie star?) Maybe
    some day we will get interesting explanations
    from Rousselle and Durcournau. For now, I think
    the film confused but admire the performances
    and the camera work/lighting. Claire Denis'
    _High Life_ is just as graphic and explicit,
    but it is an infinitely better film,
    philosophically speaking.

    ----------------------------------------------

    Bertrand Bonello plays Alexia's biological
    father in _Titane_, and he seems as dis-
    interested an actor as he is as the director of
    _On War_. When you have charismatic actors like
    Mathieu Amalric, Elina Lowensohn, Lea Seydoux,
    Asia Argento, Clotilde Hesme, Guillaume
    Depardieu, Laurent Lucas, Aurora Clement, etc.,
    and still manage to make a tepid, dull film,
    there is something really wrong with you.
    Bertrand Bonello is another overrated French
    director who has been put on the pedestal in
    recent years for reasons that escape me. Here
    Amalric's character has a mid-life, existential
    crisis and goes to stay in a commune. He could
    have pulled a Byron and actually gone to fight
    ISIS. Or work with an NGO and help people in
    poor countries. But no, he just slums around,
    listens to Bob Dylan, and tries to impress us
    with his "gallic cool" I suppose. Perhaps the
    premise reminds me a bit of _My Dinner with
    Andre_, which seemed a great film to me in my
    youth; I wonder if I would still have patience
    with it today. For a film about real spiritual
    yearning and transformative experience, watch
    Melanie Laurent's _Plonger_ instead -- now
    *that* is a brave, poetic masterpiece.

    (The only Bonello film of any interest I've
    seen is _House of Tolerance_; Celine Salette,
    Hafsia Herzi, and their fellow actresses
    manage to beat the it-is-so-dull-it-must-be-art
    trap.)

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)