• [OT] MAID for the mentally ill may be further delayed

    From Rhino@21:1/5 to All on Mon Jan 29 20:49:08 2024
    We had a significant controversy last year over the prospect of MAID
    (Medical Assistance in Dying) being rolled out for people whose only
    ailment was mental illness, as opposed to a terminal disease.
    Parliament agreed to delay by one year, until March 13, 2024, to allow
    more time for all the players to get ready.

    It now appears that this extension of MAID will be delayed by a year.
    However, the government needs to take action to extend the delay in the
    next few weeks, otherwise the expansion will go ahead on March 13. That
    would enable people with mental illnesses who might reasonably expect
    to live for many years to take their lives early.

    https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/as-deadline-looms-liberals-say-canada-not-ready-to-expand-assisted-dying-eligibility-1.6747073

    The Conservative Party wants this expansion of MAID to be abandoned
    entirely, not just delayed a further year. It remains to be seen if the Liberals will have the stomach to implement MAID for the mentally ill
    in March 2025, just months before an election, given how controversial
    the policy is and how low they are in the polls. With any other
    government, I would say the MAID expansion is effectively dead but
    Trudeau has shown a stubbornness that defies all reason about unpopular policies that he refuses to abandon so I'm not prepared to pronounce
    the MAID expansion dead.

    Of course the expansion could go ahead in March 2025 only to be rolled
    back after the next election, assuming the Conservatives win. (And I
    will be really REALLY upset if they don't!) But would the Conservatives
    roll the policy back after it has already been functioning for several
    months and presumably allowed dozens or hundreds of unhappy people to
    take their own lives? That will surely be labelled cruel by those who
    champion MAID for the mentally ill and no government likes to be called cruel....

    --
    Rhino

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From The Horny Goat@21:1/5 to no_offline_contact@example.com on Wed Jan 31 12:32:40 2024
    On Mon, 29 Jan 2024 20:49:08 -0500, Rhino
    <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:

    The Conservative Party wants this expansion of MAID to be abandoned
    entirely, not just delayed a further year. It remains to be seen if the >Liberals will have the stomach to implement MAID for the mentally ill
    in March 2025, just months before an election, given how controversial
    the policy is and how low they are in the polls. With any other
    government, I would say the MAID expansion is effectively dead but
    Trudeau has shown a stubbornness that defies all reason about unpopular >policies that he refuses to abandon so I'm not prepared to pronounce
    the MAID expansion dead.

    It was originally brought in solely for the terminally ill (e.g. don't
    bother us unless you're stage 4 cancer) but has bit by bit been
    extended. I am particularly unhappy with the severely mentally ill
    being included since that necessarily means people who cannot
    meaningfully consent.

    Guess they have to make room for another 1/2 million immigrants, 1/4
    million "students" and 100k refugees...

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)