• Academic storytelling in the Internet

    From Manuel Rodriguez@21:1/5 to All on Sun Oct 21 10:12:28 2018
    While browsing through the World Wide Web, I've found a highly
    frequented website which i do not understand in detail. It is part
    of the Stackexchange network and is about topics from Academia https://academia.stackexchange.com/ For example about a phd career,
    doing publication in a journal or writing together in a group. One thing
    was remarkable. The topics are not discussed in an abstract form but in
    a personalized style.

    Let me give an example. Usually somebody would open a thread with the
    title “What is needed for a phd career?”, or an author would ask “how much does the APC charge cost in a journal?”. Not so in the forum. What
    they are using as a stylistic markup is an ego-centric storlytelling
    mode. That means, they are inventing a story about a virtual character
    in a 3d roleplaying game, who has experienced a certain situation and
    this is posted to the forum.

    So my question is: Did I have interpreted the stylistic tone correct and
    is there a certain reason to use individual language but avoid to discuss academic topics from a bird's view? What is the sense to explain all the
    topics in a puppet theatre but not discussion the formal conditions under
    which science take place?

    Perhaps I can tell what I've researched so far. I've found a paper about sensemaking in business careers. In the paper, the need for storytelling
    is explained with the following quote:

    “At a time when elite actors are increasingly ‘under fire’, when awareness of social inequalities is heightened, self-legitimacy is keenly sought.“
    Maclean, Mairi, Charles Harvey, and Robert Chia. "Sensemaking, storytelling
    and the legitimization of elite business careers." Human Relations 65.1
    (2012): 17-40.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)