• derek's decision

    From RichD@21:1/5 to All on Thu Aug 26 18:45:05 2021
    The Derek Chauvin case has been done to death, and
    he got 22 years. But no one asked, wherefore a trial?
    Every defendant has the option of a not guilty plea.

    Obviously, he rejected their offer. And the $64 question is,
    what did they offer? i.e. considering the facts of the case.

    Then, what was his counsel's counsel? Perhaps they
    told him he had slim chance, and he answered: I'm not
    going into the slammer voluntarily, I'll roll the dice.
    Or, did they encourage him, with the reasonable theory
    that it's hard to convict a cop, there's the common
    sympathy of "they have a tough job", and the defense
    only needs one such juror.

    All discussion of this topic is of course speculation.
    But that's one of the functions of these boards, so
    don't be shy -

    PS Is he going to spend the whole time in protective custody?

    --
    Rich

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Rick@21:1/5 to All on Fri Aug 27 08:20:58 2021
    "RichD" wrote in message news:baf901f7-a599-4b00-ade0-88708c6902d6n@googlegroups.com...

    The Derek Chauvin case has been done to death, and
    he got 22 years. But no one asked, wherefore a trial?
    Every defendant has the option of a not guilty plea.

    Obviously, he rejected their offer. And the $64 question is,
    what did they offer? i.e. considering the facts of the case.

    Then, what was his counsel's counsel? Perhaps they
    told him he had slim chance, and he answered: I'm not
    going into the slammer voluntarily, I'll roll the dice.
    Or, did they encourage him, with the reasonable theory
    that it's hard to convict a cop, there's the common
    sympathy of "they have a tough job", and the defense
    only needs one such juror.

    All discussion of this topic is of course speculation.
    But that's one of the functions of these boards, so
    don't be shy -

    PS Is he going to spend the whole time in protective custody?

    --
    Rich

    Please usually reject plea deals for one of two reasons:

    1) They believe or have been led to believe they have a reasonable chance
    at a better outcome if they go to trial

    2) They consider themselves innocent of the crimes they have been charged
    with and refuse to take any plea deal as a matter of principle

    In this case, until the defendant or his attorneys do some kind of tell-all interview, I don't think we have any real basis for speculation.


    --

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)