• Apple garbage collection with cloned startup disk

    From J Burns@21:1/5 to All on Thu Nov 11 15:25:17 2021
    In 2017 I began experiencing an annoying problem. When I put the
    computer to sleep, sometimes the display would come back on in six
    seconds, and the log wouldn't show that it had ever been asleep. It
    didn't seem to be connected with anything in Activity Monitor. Sometimes
    the second try would work, but I could go so far as to cycle it through
    a safe startup. On the second startup, if I clicked "sleep" instead of
    logging on, it might still refuse to sleep.

    A year later, the problem migrated to my new computer. It persists
    although my hardware and software are almost entirely different from 2017.

    Now I remember. The hard drive on my 2012 had become very slow, but a
    detailed report showed that it was in excellent shape. I suspected that defragmentation-on-the-fly wasn't working, and there no longer seemed to
    be defrag apps available. Prior to 2012, I used to defrag by cloning,
    which also provided redundancy. So I bought a USB SSD, cloned onto it
    with CCC, booted with it, and cloned back to my HD.

    It worked, but gradually the HD slowed down as if it were again becoming fragmented. I usually booted from the external SSD.

    For my first few months with my 2018 Mini, I cloned back and forth
    between the internal SSD and an external one because I liked redundancy.
    Now I have a theory. A cloned OS will somehow conflict with Apple's
    garbage collection, and this will persist even after a system upgrade.
    If I tell the computer to sleep during a scheduled garbage collection, I
    think garbage collection vetos sleep about 6 seconds after the screen
    goes black.

    It's annoying, and there may be worse effects. Should I reinstall the
    OS? Should I reinstall from Time Machine, or erase and get it from the internet? Do I need to write down my Apple password?

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From nospam@21:1/5 to All on Thu Nov 11 15:47:47 2021
    In article <smju7f$tpa$1@dont-email.me>, J Burns <burns@nospam.com>
    wrote:

    In 2017 I began experiencing an annoying problem. When I put the
    computer to sleep, sometimes the display would come back on in six
    seconds, and the log wouldn't show that it had ever been asleep. It
    didn't seem to be connected with anything in Activity Monitor. Sometimes
    the second try would work, but I could go so far as to cycle it through
    a safe startup. On the second startup, if I clicked "sleep" instead of logging on, it might still refuse to sleep.

    i had that happen once. a reboot fixed it.

    A year later, the problem migrated to my new computer. It persists
    although my hardware and software are almost entirely different from 2017.

    coincidence.

    Now I remember. The hard drive on my 2012 had become very slow, but a detailed report showed that it was in excellent shape. I suspected that defragmentation-on-the-fly wasn't working,

    it was, and not the cause.

    and there no longer seemed to
    be defrag apps available.

    that's because such apps are useless.

    Prior to 2012, I used to defrag by cloning,

    there is zero need to manually defrag except in very specific
    circumstances, which are very rare given the speed of modern hard
    drives.

    which also provided redundancy. So I bought a USB SSD, cloned onto it
    with CCC, booted with it, and cloned back to my HD.

    It worked, but gradually the HD slowed down as if it were again becoming fragmented. I usually booted from the external SSD.

    fragmentation hasn't been an issue in years and is definitely not the
    cause of random wakes.

    For my first few months with my 2018 Mini, I cloned back and forth
    between the internal SSD and an external one because I liked redundancy.

    backups are always a good idea.

    Now I have a theory. A cloned OS will somehow conflict with Apple's
    garbage collection, and this will persist even after a system upgrade.

    that theory is incorrect.

    If I tell the computer to sleep during a scheduled garbage collection, I think garbage collection vetos sleep about 6 seconds after the screen
    goes black.

    coincidence

    It's annoying, and there may be worse effects. Should I reinstall the
    OS? Should I reinstall from Time Machine, or erase and get it from the internet?

    only if you have a lot of free time and absolutely nothing better to do.

    Do I need to write down my Apple password?

    it should be in a password manager.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Your Name@21:1/5 to J Burns on Fri Nov 12 12:24:32 2021
    On 2021-11-11 20:25:17 +0000, J Burns said:

    In 2017 I began experiencing an annoying problem. When I put the
    computer to sleep, sometimes the display would come back on in six
    seconds, and the log wouldn't show that it had ever been asleep. It
    didn't seem to be connected with anything in Activity Monitor.
    Sometimes the second try would work, but I could go so far as to cycle
    it through a safe startup. On the second startup, if I clicked "sleep" instead of logging on, it might still refuse to sleep.

    A year later, the problem migrated to my new computer. It persists
    although my hardware and software are almost entirely different from
    2017.

    Now I remember. The hard drive on my 2012 had become very slow, but a detailed report showed that it was in excellent shape. I suspected that defragmentation-on-the-fly wasn't working, and there no longer seemed
    to be defrag apps available. Prior to 2012, I used to defrag by
    cloning, which also provided redundancy. So I bought a USB SSD, cloned
    onto it with CCC, booted with it, and cloned back to my HD.

    It worked, but gradually the HD slowed down as if it were again
    becoming fragmented. I usually booted from the external SSD.

    For my first few months with my 2018 Mini, I cloned back and forth
    between the internal SSD and an external one because I liked
    redundancy. Now I have a theory. A cloned OS will somehow conflict with Apple's garbage collection, and this will persist even after a system upgrade. If I tell the computer to sleep during a scheduled garbage collection, I think garbage collection vetos sleep about 6 seconds
    after the screen goes black.

    It's annoying, and there may be worse effects. Should I reinstall the
    OS? Should I reinstall from Time Machine, or erase and get it from the internet? Do I need to write down my Apple password?

    Two other possibilities ...

    Sometimes when I put my Mac to sleep, it will wake up almost instantly.
    The cause for is likely the mouse moving slightly (maybe as I let go or
    move the chair back under the desk) and reawakening it. It usually
    works properly the second attempt though.

    Another may be Spotlight indexing. Make sure the cloned drive is in the
    list to be excluded. Also exclude it from Time Machine (there's little
    point in also backing up a clone of the drive that's already backing up
    - other than perhaps double-redundancy).

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From nospam@21:1/5 to YourName@YourISP.com on Thu Nov 11 19:35:18 2021
    In article <smk8ng$t7u$1@gioia.aioe.org>, Your Name
    <YourName@YourISP.com> wrote:

    Sometimes when I put my Mac to sleep, it will wake up almost instantly.
    The cause for is likely the mouse moving slightly (maybe as I let go or
    move the chair back under the desk) and reawakening it. It usually
    works properly the second attempt though.

    only if it's a non-compliant mouse.

    Another may be Spotlight indexing. Make sure the cloned drive is in the
    list to be excluded. Also exclude it from Time Machine (there's little
    point in also backing up a clone of the drive that's already backing up
    - other than perhaps double-redundancy).

    definitely not.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From J Burns@21:1/5 to Your Name on Fri Nov 12 02:52:06 2021
    On 11/11/21 6:24 PM, Your Name wrote:
    On 2021-11-11 20:25:17 +0000, J Burns said:

    In 2017 I began experiencing an annoying problem. When I put the
    computer to sleep, sometimes the display would come back on in six
    seconds, and the log wouldn't show that it had ever been asleep. It
    didn't seem to be connected with anything in Activity Monitor.
    Sometimes the second try would work, but I could go so far as to cycle
    it through a safe startup. On the second startup, if I clicked "sleep"
    instead of logging on, it might still refuse to sleep.

    A year later, the problem migrated to my new computer. It persists
    although my hardware and software are almost entirely different from
    2017.

    Now I remember. The hard drive on my 2012 had become very slow, but a
    detailed report showed that it was in excellent shape. I suspected
    that defragmentation-on-the-fly wasn't working, and there no longer
    seemed to be defrag apps available. Prior to 2012, I used to defrag by
    cloning, which also provided redundancy. So I bought a USB SSD, cloned
    onto it with CCC, booted with it, and cloned back to my HD.

    It worked, but gradually the HD slowed down as if it were again
    becoming fragmented. I usually booted from the external SSD.

    For my first few months with my 2018 Mini, I cloned back and forth
    between the internal SSD and an external one because I liked
    redundancy. Now I have a theory. A cloned OS will somehow conflict
    with Apple's garbage collection, and this will persist even after a
    system upgrade. If I tell the computer to sleep during a scheduled
    garbage collection, I think garbage collection vetos sleep about 6
    seconds after the screen goes black.

    It's annoying, and there may be worse effects. Should I reinstall the
    OS? Should I reinstall from Time Machine, or erase and get it from the
    internet? Do I need to write down my Apple password?

    Two other possibilities ...

    Sometimes when I put my Mac to sleep, it will wake up almost instantly.
    The cause for is likely the mouse moving slightly (maybe as I let go or
    move the chair back under the desk) and reawakening it. It usually works properly the second attempt though.

    Another may be Spotlight indexing. Make sure the cloned drive is in the
    list to be excluded. Also exclude it from Time Machine (there's little
    point in also backing up a clone of the drive that's already backing up
    - other than perhaps double-redundancy).


    Thanks. Before 2017, if a Mac woke unexpectedly, it wouldn't necessarily
    be 6 seconds after I told it to sleep, and the log would say it had been
    waked, usually by a USB device, probably the mouse. In the current
    problem, the log never says it was waked, so I guess it wasn't asleep.

    Naturally, I need Spotlight to keep my startup drive indexed. I quit
    using clones as backups in 2019, so I also need Time Machine to keep my
    startup drive backed up. When I've had trouble, I've checked Activity
    Monitor and haven't found backupd or a stored to be active.

    There was a peculiarity under OS 11. When I had trouble, I would find
    that when I clicked S[eep, suggestd had jumped to "175% CPU." If I
    killed the process, clicking Sleep would wake it, so it was an effect,
    not the cause. It doesn't happen under OS 12, and it didn't happen under
    OS X.

    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical
    location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not
    what files it belongs to. TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the
    physical location of data. Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.

    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't
    be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD. In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD, and Apple won't enable
    TRIM. Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went
    to sleep during garbage collection?

    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting
    for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't
    interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS
    12, maybe I'd have TRIM.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From nospam@21:1/5 to All on Fri Nov 12 07:21:32 2021
    In article <sml6f8$r36$1@dont-email.me>, J Burns <burns@nospam.com>
    wrote:


    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical
    location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not
    what files it belongs to.

    that is normal and not an issue whatsoever.

    TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data.

    it does not.

    Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.

    nope, it's because some ssds have poor implementations of trim, which
    can potentially cause data loss. apple does not want to test every
    single ssd out there to be sure it works properly.

    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't
    be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD.

    that does not matter at all.

    In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD,

    no it doesn't.

    and Apple won't enable
    TRIM.

    trim is not needed on modern ssds, however, it can be enabled if the
    user really wants it.

    Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went
    to sleep during garbage collection?

    nope. that makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. it will resume
    when the computer wakes, just as everything else does.

    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting
    for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't
    interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS
    12, maybe I'd have TRIM.

    that theory has no basis in reality.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Snit@21:1/5 to nospam on Wed Nov 24 03:15:37 2021
    On Friday, November 12, 2021 at 5:21:37 AM UTC-7, nospam wrote:
    In article <sml6f8$r36$1...@dont-email.me>, J Burns <bu...@nospam.com>
    wrote:


    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not what files it belongs to.
    that is normal and not an issue whatsoever.
    TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data.
    it does not.
    Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.
    nope, it's because some ssds have poor implementations of trim, which
    can potentially cause data loss. apple does not want to test every
    single ssd out there to be sure it works properly.
    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't
    be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD.
    that does not matter at all.
    In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD,
    no it doesn't.
    and Apple won't enable
    TRIM.
    trim is not needed on modern ssds, however, it can be enabled if the
    user really wants it.
    Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went
    to sleep during garbage collection?
    nope. that makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. it will resume
    when the computer wakes, just as everything else does.
    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't
    interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS 12, maybe I'd have TRIM.
    that theory has no basis in reality.


    Keep in mind your accusation is based on you not understanding context.
    Your game:

    * Snit spoke of Dustin Cook having Carroll's flood bot code .
    * Dustin Cook does not have Carroll's flood bot code.

    Then you insist I lied. But you leave out the context.

    1) Snit spoke of Carroll's flood bot code, and what can be known without
    the code
    2) Dustin Cook responded by speaking of what he can know HAVING THE CODE.
    3) Snit spoke of Dustin Cook having Carroll's flood bot code.
    4) Dustin Cook does not have Carroll's flood bot code.

    You start at step three and then insist that if one starts there it LOOKS
    like you were unfairly accused.

    In short: you prove yourself a functionally illiterate fraud again.

    --
    This broke the Internet https://www.google.com/search?q=Dustin%20Cook%20functional%20illiterate%20fraud Steve 'Narcissistic Bigot' Carroll

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Steve Carroll@21:1/5 to nospam on Thu Nov 25 12:37:33 2021
    On Friday, November 12, 2021 at 5:21:37 AM UTC-7, nospam wrote:
    In article <sml6f8$r36$1...@dont-email.me>, J Burns <bu...@nospam.com>
    wrote:


    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not what files it belongs to.
    that is normal and not an issue whatsoever.
    TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data.
    it does not.
    Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.
    nope, it's because some ssds have poor implementations of trim, which
    can potentially cause data loss. apple does not want to test every
    single ssd out there to be sure it works properly.
    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't
    be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD.
    that does not matter at all.
    In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD,
    no it doesn't.
    and Apple won't enable
    TRIM.
    trim is not needed on modern ssds, however, it can be enabled if the
    user really wants it.
    Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went
    to sleep during garbage collection?
    nope. that makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. it will resume
    when the computer wakes, just as everything else does.
    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't
    interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS 12, maybe I'd have TRIM.
    that theory has no basis in reality.


    The guy is as loved as a drunken karaoke singer -- and with good reason.
    It was Snit sock HWSNBN who flooded RonB's site millions of times and
    denied it. This forum is a puss-filled cyst.

    Snit sock HWSNBN claims to be the programming master, let's see him
    put up a variant minus the shipping/handling routines.


    --
    This Trick Gets Women Hot For You https://www.walmart.com/browse/books/family-kids-books/cary-fagan/3920_582053_585918/YnJhbmQ6Q2FyeSBGYWdhbgieie
    <https://www.truepeoplesearch.com/results?name=4234911448&Diesel&Gremlin&Dustin_Cook>
    https://swisscows.com/web?query=%22narcissistic%20bigot%22
    Steve Carroll the Narcissistic Bigot

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Steve Carroll@21:1/5 to J Burns on Thu Nov 25 21:58:04 2021
    On Friday, November 12, 2021 at 12:52:12 AM UTC-7, J Burns wrote:
    On 11/11/21 6:24 PM, Your Name wrote:
    On 2021-11-11 20:25:17 +0000, J Burns said:

    In 2017 I began experiencing an annoying problem. When I put the
    computer to sleep, sometimes the display would come back on in six
    seconds, and the log wouldn't show that it had ever been asleep. It
    didn't seem to be connected with anything in Activity Monitor.
    Sometimes the second try would work, but I could go so far as to cycle
    it through a safe startup. On the second startup, if I clicked "sleep"
    instead of logging on, it might still refuse to sleep.

    A year later, the problem migrated to my new computer. It persists
    although my hardware and software are almost entirely different from
    2017.

    Now I remember. The hard drive on my 2012 had become very slow, but a
    detailed report showed that it was in excellent shape. I suspected
    that defragmentation-on-the-fly wasn't working, and there no longer
    seemed to be defrag apps available. Prior to 2012, I used to defrag by
    cloning, which also provided redundancy. So I bought a USB SSD, cloned
    onto it with CCC, booted with it, and cloned back to my HD.

    It worked, but gradually the HD slowed down as if it were again
    becoming fragmented. I usually booted from the external SSD.

    For my first few months with my 2018 Mini, I cloned back and forth
    between the internal SSD and an external one because I liked
    redundancy. Now I have a theory. A cloned OS will somehow conflict
    with Apple's garbage collection, and this will persist even after a
    system upgrade. If I tell the computer to sleep during a scheduled
    garbage collection, I think garbage collection vetos sleep about 6
    seconds after the screen goes black.

    It's annoying, and there may be worse effects. Should I reinstall the
    OS? Should I reinstall from Time Machine, or erase and get it from the
    internet? Do I need to write down my Apple password?

    Two other possibilities ...

    Sometimes when I put my Mac to sleep, it will wake up almost instantly.
    The cause for is likely the mouse moving slightly (maybe as I let go or move the chair back under the desk) and reawakening it. It usually works properly the second attempt though.

    Another may be Spotlight indexing. Make sure the cloned drive is in the list to be excluded. Also exclude it from Time Machine (there's little point in also backing up a clone of the drive that's already backing up
    - other than perhaps double-redundancy).


    Thanks. Before 2017, if a Mac woke unexpectedly, it wouldn't necessarily
    be 6 seconds after I told it to sleep, and the log would say it had been waked, usually by a USB device, probably the mouse. In the current
    problem, the log never says it was waked, so I guess it wasn't asleep.

    Naturally, I need Spotlight to keep my startup drive indexed. I quit
    using clones as backups in 2019, so I also need Time Machine to keep my startup drive backed up. When I've had trouble, I've checked Activity
    Monitor and haven't found backupd or a stored to be active.

    There was a peculiarity under OS 11. When I had trouble, I would find
    that when I clicked S[eep, suggestd had jumped to "175% CPU." If I
    killed the process, clicking Sleep would wake it, so it was an effect,
    not the cause. It doesn't happen under OS 12, and it didn't happen under
    OS X.

    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical
    location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not
    what files it belongs to. TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data. Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.

    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't
    be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD. In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD, and Apple won't enable
    TRIM. Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went
    to sleep during garbage collection?

    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting
    for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't
    interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS
    12, maybe I'd have TRIM.


    This is something you merely pretend to understand.

    Over and over, the surface request is Larry Washington wants to "talk
    tech", but Larry Washington spends most of his time whining about "trolling".

    Do you have a high school diploma?

    The entire farce is brimming of unbelievable inconsistencies and counts
    heavily on Larry Washington's 'home made CMS' nonsense. How many more
    chances does Larry Washington's stupid arse (a brick knows more than Larry Washington and is useful) need to prove their FromTheRafters sock accusation with evidence?

    Larry Washington claimed the headers were entirely consistent with many
    of the forgeries. Interesting, why is he having such a struggle backing
    his assertion up when asked to do so? In other words, if his statement
    was supportable, and not just a weak attempt to come to FromTheRafterss
    rescue? Larry Washington suffers from neurotic fantasies so, to him, everything,
    even people ignoring him, are "slander". Who DOESN'T know this?


    -
    Eight things to never feed your cat! http://techrights.org/2011/07/24/gnu-linux-macosx-by-michael-glasser- roy-schestowitz-and-goblin-on-techbytes/ https://www.bing.com/search?q=Steve+Petruzzellis+the+narcissistic+bigot https://swisscows.com/web?query=dustin%20cook%20%22functionally%20illiterate%20fraud%22
    Dustin Cook is a functionally illiterate fraud

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Steve Carroll@21:1/5 to Steve Carroll on Fri Nov 26 08:54:30 2021
    On Thursday, November 25, 2021 at 10:58:06 PM UTC-7, Steve Carroll wrote:
    On Friday, November 12, 2021 at 12:52:12 AM UTC-7, J Burns wrote:
    On 11/11/21 6:24 PM, Your Name wrote:
    On 2021-11-11 20:25:17 +0000, J Burns said:

    In 2017 I began experiencing an annoying problem. When I put the
    computer to sleep, sometimes the display would come back on in six
    seconds, and the log wouldn't show that it had ever been asleep. It
    didn't seem to be connected with anything in Activity Monitor.
    Sometimes the second try would work, but I could go so far as to cycle >> it through a safe startup. On the second startup, if I clicked "sleep" >> instead of logging on, it might still refuse to sleep.

    A year later, the problem migrated to my new computer. It persists
    although my hardware and software are almost entirely different from
    2017.

    Now I remember. The hard drive on my 2012 had become very slow, but a
    detailed report showed that it was in excellent shape. I suspected
    that defragmentation-on-the-fly wasn't working, and there no longer
    seemed to be defrag apps available. Prior to 2012, I used to defrag by >> cloning, which also provided redundancy. So I bought a USB SSD, cloned >> onto it with CCC, booted with it, and cloned back to my HD.

    It worked, but gradually the HD slowed down as if it were again
    becoming fragmented. I usually booted from the external SSD.

    For my first few months with my 2018 Mini, I cloned back and forth
    between the internal SSD and an external one because I liked
    redundancy. Now I have a theory. A cloned OS will somehow conflict
    with Apple's garbage collection, and this will persist even after a
    system upgrade. If I tell the computer to sleep during a scheduled
    garbage collection, I think garbage collection vetos sleep about 6
    seconds after the screen goes black.

    It's annoying, and there may be worse effects. Should I reinstall the
    OS? Should I reinstall from Time Machine, or erase and get it from the >> internet? Do I need to write down my Apple password?

    Two other possibilities ...

    Sometimes when I put my Mac to sleep, it will wake up almost instantly. The cause for is likely the mouse moving slightly (maybe as I let go or move the chair back under the desk) and reawakening it. It usually works properly the second attempt though.

    Another may be Spotlight indexing. Make sure the cloned drive is in the list to be excluded. Also exclude it from Time Machine (there's little point in also backing up a clone of the drive that's already backing up
    - other than perhaps double-redundancy).


    Thanks. Before 2017, if a Mac woke unexpectedly, it wouldn't necessarily
    be 6 seconds after I told it to sleep, and the log would say it had been waked, usually by a USB device, probably the mouse. In the current
    problem, the log never says it was waked, so I guess it wasn't asleep.

    Naturally, I need Spotlight to keep my startup drive indexed. I quit
    using clones as backups in 2019, so I also need Time Machine to keep my startup drive backed up. When I've had trouble, I've checked Activity Monitor and haven't found backupd or a stored to be active.

    There was a peculiarity under OS 11. When I had trouble, I would find
    that when I clicked S[eep, suggestd had jumped to "175% CPU." If I
    killed the process, clicking Sleep would wake it, so it was an effect,
    not the cause. It doesn't happen under OS 12, and it didn't happen under
    OS X.

    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not what files it belongs to. TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data. Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.

    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't
    be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD. In effect, cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD, and Apple won't enable TRIM. Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went
    to sleep during garbage collection?

    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't
    interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS 12, maybe I'd have TRIM.
    This is something you merely pretend to understand.

    Over and over, the surface request is Larry Washington wants to "talk
    tech", but Larry Washington spends most of his time whining about "trolling".

    Do you have a high school diploma?

    The entire farce is brimming of unbelievable inconsistencies and counts heavily on Larry Washington's 'home made CMS' nonsense. How many more
    chances does Larry Washington's stupid arse (a brick knows more than Larry Washington and is useful) need to prove their FromTheRafters sock accusation with evidence?

    Larry Washington claimed the headers were entirely consistent with many
    of the forgeries. Interesting, why is he having such a struggle backing
    his assertion up when asked to do so? In other words, if his statement
    was supportable, and not just a weak attempt to come to FromTheRafterss rescue? Larry Washington suffers from neurotic fantasies so, to him, everything,
    even people ignoring him, are "slander". Who DOESN'T know this?


    -
    Eight things to never feed your cat! http://techrights.org/2011/07/24/gnu-linux-macosx-by-michael-glasser- roy-schestowitz-and-goblin-on-techbytes/ https://www.bing.com/search?q=Steve+Petruzzellis+the+narcissistic+bigot https://swisscows.com/web?query=dustin%20cook%20%22functionally%20illiterate%20fraud%22
    Dustin Cook is a functionally illiterate fraud


    Theo must understand that Snit can go get Access, right, sicko? Add to that, anyone can filter his posts, which renders his kiddie crap impotent, just
    like Theo.

    I just configured an automation and won't be impacted by the flooding. Theo's crap has made a total ruin of COLA via GG, so I don't endeavor posting to
    your posts with my desktop anymore. One thing he has achieved with this crap
    is that the Theo plonk has been shown to clearly be the right thing. Too
    many individuals keep replying to Theo. In truth I do not denounce Snit for being pissed but I do not conceive why he posts here now that he gets what
    this place is. Snit is more interested in dialog as seen in an IRC venue
    and free forums will just lead to frustration.

    --
    Live on Kickstarter!!
    https://www.bing.com/search?q=%22narcissistic%20bigot%22 https://swisscows.com/web?query=%22narcissistic%20bigot%22 https://youtu.be/hYQ4Tg0r0g0
    Steve 'Narcissistic Bigot' Petruzzellis

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From STALKING_TARGET_52@21:1/5 to All on Fri Nov 26 09:26:07 2021
    On Thursday, November 25, 2021 at 1:37:35 PM UTC-7, STALKING_TARGET_52 wrote:
    On Friday, November 12, 2021 at 5:21:37 AM UTC-7, nospam wrote:
    In article <sml6f8$r36$1...@dont-email.me>, J Burns <bu...@nospam.com> wrote:


    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not what files it belongs to.
    that is normal and not an issue whatsoever.
    TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data.
    it does not.
    Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.
    nope, it's because some ssds have poor implementations of trim, which
    can potentially cause data loss. apple does not want to test every
    single ssd out there to be sure it works properly.
    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD.
    that does not matter at all.
    In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD,
    no it doesn't.
    and Apple won't enable
    TRIM.
    trim is not needed on modern ssds, however, it can be enabled if the
    user really wants it.
    Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went to sleep during garbage collection?
    nope. that makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. it will resume
    when the computer wakes, just as everything else does.
    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS 12, maybe I'd have TRIM.
    that theory has no basis in reality.
    The guy is as loved as a drunken karaoke singer -- and with good reason.
    It was Snit sock HWSNBN who flooded RonB's site millions of times and
    denied it. This forum is a puss-filled cyst.

    Snit sock HWSNBN claims to be the programming master, let's see him
    put up a variant minus the shipping/handling routines.


    --
    This Trick Gets Women Hot For You https://www.walmart.com/browse/books/family-kids-books/cary-fagan/3920_582053_585918/YnJhbmQ6Q2FyeSBGYWdhbgieie
    <https://www.truepeoplesearch.com/results?name=4234911448&Diesel&Gremlin&Dustin_Cook>
    https://swisscows.com/web?query=%22narcissistic%20bigot%22
    Steve Carroll the Narcissistic Bigot


    Diesel the functionally illiterate fraud. Gee, imagine -hh trying to pin
    his trash on me or others, no one has ever seen that before <shrug>. -
    hh is *still* focusing on *only* himself, as I predicted, when it comes
    to the business of hacking. And he completely sidesteps the proof that
    his "buddy" has not only confessed to engaging in this against Carroll
    but he's said he sees it to be no huge deal... immaterial. Do you believe
    the lies -hh is pushing?

    --
    Puppy Videos https://www.opensecrets.org/political-action-committees-pacs/C00166710/donors/2016
    https://ftp.cdc.gov/pub/health_Statistics/nchs/Software/mmds/2009/spell/mmds_spell.txt
    Narcissistic Bigot Steve Carroll

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Smit Michael Glaser@21:1/5 to Smit Michael Glaser on Sat Nov 27 01:44:28 2021
    On Thursday, November 25, 2021 at 1:37:35 PM UTC-7, Smit Michael Glaser wrote:
    On Friday, November 12, 2021 at 5:21:37 AM UTC-7, nospam wrote:
    In article <sml6f8$r36$1...@dont-email.me>, J Burns <bu...@nospam.com> wrote:


    An OS may know the logical location of files but not their physical location on an SSD. The SSD knows the physical location of data but not what files it belongs to.
    that is normal and not an issue whatsoever.
    TRIM allows an OS to tell an SSD what data has
    been deleted. It sounds as if in this case, the OS keeps track of the physical location of data.
    it does not.
    Perhaps Apple doesn't support TRIM for
    third-party SSDs because it may not know where an unfamiliar SSD puts data.
    nope, it's because some ssds have poor implementations of trim, which
    can potentially cause data loss. apple does not want to test every
    single ssd out there to be sure it works properly.
    When CCC copies an OS onto an SSD, it seems that the OS on the SSD can't be aware of the physical location of the files on the SSD.
    that does not matter at all.
    In effect,
    cloning turns an OEM SSD into a third-party SSD,
    no it doesn't.
    and Apple won't enable
    TRIM.
    trim is not needed on modern ssds, however, it can be enabled if the
    user really wants it.
    Without TRIM, I guess in the event of Sleep, it can't tell the SSD
    to cease garbage collection. Would it be a calamity if the computer went to sleep during garbage collection?
    nope. that makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. it will resume
    when the computer wakes, just as everything else does.
    My theory is that sometimes my Mac won't sleep because the OS is waiting for the SSD to finish garbage collection, a process the OS can't interrupt without TRIM. If I erased my SSD to make a fresh install of OS 12, maybe I'd have TRIM.
    that theory has no basis in reality.
    The guy is as loved as a drunken karaoke singer -- and with good reason.
    It was Snit sock HWSNBN who flooded RonB's site millions of times and
    denied it. This forum is a puss-filled cyst.

    Snit sock HWSNBN claims to be the programming master, let's see him
    put up a variant minus the shipping/handling routines.


    --
    This Trick Gets Women Hot For You https://www.walmart.com/browse/books/family-kids-books/cary-fagan/3920_582053_585918/YnJhbmQ6Q2FyeSBGYWdhbgieie
    <https://www.truepeoplesearch.com/results?name=4234911448&Diesel&Gremlin&Dustin_Cook>
    https://swisscows.com/web?query=%22narcissistic%20bigot%22
    Steve Carroll the Narcissistic Bigot


    If you have 'file.txt' open in a word processor such as Cooledit and
    chrisv wants to change its name to 'windows.pdf' via a preset script,
    David's method might be good, if only to see it attach to a VPN display.
    I just configured a filter and don't see the idiot. chrisv's crap has
    made an utter cesspool of cola via GG, so I don't even try reading David
    with my tablet anymore. Only thing he has achieved with this trolling
    is that the chrisv boycott will never be lifted.

    Like the other trolls in here, chrisv relies on mainstream media to
    build his positions on subjects. Hence, he only is aware of and accepts
    the endorsed news which also happens to be the ones which portray free
    thought in a falsely positive and heroic slant. What's the Earth coming
    to when a chrisv shill can not get any reaction... David can create a
    virtual machine. Rips what that Mac can do to shreds!

    Playing with AppleScript... still a rookie...

    -
    What Every Entrepreneur Must Know https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-glasser-86860011
    Steve Carroll the Narcissistic Bigot

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)