• re3 Lawsuit dismissed

    From Spalls Hurgenson@21:1/5 to All on Sun Apr 9 13:17:25 2023
    Back before the release of the "Grand Theft Auto 3 Trilogy" remake,
    the best way to play the GTA3 and GTA:Vice City were with the "re3"
    and "reVC" mods, which updated the games to use wide-screen, and added
    a bunch of bug fixes, compatibility updates, and even some new
    functions. Essentially, they were an all-in-one mod that allowed you
    to play games written in 2000 on hardware developed in 2020; a
    love-letter from dedicated fans who didn't want to see their favorite
    games left in the ash-heap of old games left behind by the relentless progression of new hardware and operating systems.

    So of course Take-Two, the owners of the GTA franchise, decided to sue
    them.

    The reasons were the usual; "they're infringing on our copyright!",
    even though the mods themselves required players to own the original
    games (and, IIRC, the modders took pains not to include any Take-Two
    code or assets in their releases). The real reason, of course, was
    that Take-Two was just about to release their own (sub-par) upgrade to
    the games, and they didn't want the competition. So even though the
    legality of their claim was questionable, it was still easier (and
    more profitable) to get the mod temporarily delisted by suing the
    modders.

    But now that the official remaster has had its rush of new sales,
    there's no need for for the lawsuit, and all charges have been dropped
    (with prejudice, meaning Take-Two can't refile against the modders at
    a later date). Which only goes to show how meritless this case was in
    the first place. It's unfortunate that a counter-suit can't be filed
    against Take Two.

    Still, it's good news in the end, since now hopefully the re3/reVC
    mods can be reposted and people can play the game using those mods. In
    many ways, I preferred the mods to the official remasters, which felt
    truer to the original games than Take Two's efforts (which often went
    overboard with their chances). So "Yay!" for the good guys this time.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)