• Ukraine War and Video Games

    From Spalls Hurgenson@21:1/5 to All on Tue Nov 15 21:40:41 2022
    As a frequent gamer, watching videos from the war in Ukraine has an
    odd familiarity to it. So many of the industry's digital fantasies
    have involved heroic soldiers fighting battles with modern armaments
    against a hostile army, and seeing it happen in real life sometimes
    seems like I'm watching an ultra-realistic version of "ARMA" or "Call
    of Duty". The wars in Iraq and Syria - where the fighting was in the
    vast open deserts against a materially inferior foe - never felt quite
    the same. Not to dismiss the trials the soldiers faced in those wars,
    but their battles often felt disconnected from reality, more like
    Hollywood's ideas of SEAL team special operations. The Ukrainian
    conflict feels like a down-and-dirty war. It feels more honest, more
    real. More like we saw in our games.

    There's an odd sense of ambivalence watching these videos; I'm not
    sure if I should be fascinated or disgusted by what I'm seeing. Most
    of us, I expect (and hope), are lucky enough to never have been thrust
    into such a bloody carnage, so video-games are unsurprisingly our
    primary touchstone for what such a conflict might be like. It's
    unsurprising that's what we think of when we see it happening for
    real. What is disconcerting is that the same was true for many of the defenders, at least as of a year ago. Until the February 2022
    invasion, most of the people now fighting had never been closer to a
    battle than a 64-player deathmatch where their tactics rarely took
    into consideration the finality of death; a respawn was always just
    around the corner. I bet (I hope) those foolish notions got blown away
    quickly.

    Worse, whenever watching some of these videos, a somewhat shameful
    thought crosses through my head: "this would make a great game." Don't
    get me wrong; I don't want a game made of the Ukraine war; I don't
    think we need more glorification of real-world violence, or more
    propaganda, or any attempt to replace the sacrifice made by real
    heroes with fictional digital avatars. But the setting and the
    struggle - were they not real - would make perfect fodder for a game.
    Modern warfare in the mountains and forests of Ukraine, leading a
    ragtag band of fighters against an overwhelmingly large army to
    reclaim your homeland? Hollywood couldn't write a better story.

    Still, even if there never is a "Ukraine War" video game, I suspect
    the visuals we see on our TV and on YouTube will be influence games
    for decades to come, and again, I'm not sure if that's a good or bad
    thing. But the tactics and technology, the sights and sounds will
    become part of our video-games sooner or later, even if they don't
    directly mention the real-world conflict.

    Unexpectedly, perhaps unwittingly, it's being drawn into our shared
    culture and history. It's weird to see that happening in real-time.
    It's hard to decide how to feel about that. Should I be excited or
    disgusted?

    Maybe I should just stick to checkers.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)