• CSM is the daddy - En Ami is the proof

    From dmunz@21:1/5 to Daniel Perez on Mon Jan 8 14:58:29 2018
    On Tuesday, May 23, 2000 at 2:00:00 AM UTC-5, Daniel Perez wrote:
    The proof that CSM is the father of Scully's baby is encoded within the subtext of dialogue and action in "En Ami". Throughout the entire
    episode, while CSM was psychologically manipulating Scully for getting
    the disk containing the cancer cure, he obviously had fatherhood on his
    mind.

    --------------
    Exhibit A
    CSM cures the little boy of cancer, leaves a Goochland, Virginia paper
    on Scullys doorstep, distracts Mulder from the case with the fake
    e-mails and manipulates Scully into seeing the little boy who was cured
    of cancer the exact same way she was; with a chip in the back of the
    neck. Why? For the purpose of awakening deep feelings of motherhood
    within Scully.

    --------------
    Exhibit B.
    In the office building, CSM tells Scully that she's a "woman of
    compassion" and says the following;

    "In the end, a man finally looks at the sum of his life, to see what
    he'll leave behind. Most of what I've worked to build is in ruins.
    And now that the darkness descends, I find I have no real legacy"

    What does Smoking Man mean by "no real legacy"? That he has no one to
    carry out his wishes for the project to continue. CSM shot his son
    Jeffery Spender in "One Son" and we learned that Mulder is also CSM's
    son in "Amor Fati", but there's no way that Mulder would carry on CSM's
    work. Therfore CSM was longing for another chance to continue, even
    beyond death, and that would mean another son.

    --------------
    Exhibit C
    In the following exchange between CSM and Scully after CSM throws out
    his cigarettes while riding the Sedan, we see more evidence;

    CSM: No sacrifice is truly altruistic. We give, expecting to recieve.

    Scully: What exactly is it you expect to recieve?

    CSM: Your trust. You question my sincerity. You think I'm heartless.
    Would it soften your opinion of me if I confessed that I've always had particular affection for you?

    A sharp glance by Scully at CSM.

    CSM: I assure you my intentions are honorable. I have affection for
    Mulder too. My affection for you is special. I held your life in my
    hands. Your cancer was terminal and I had the cure. Can you imagine
    what that's like? To have the power to extinguish a life in order to
    save it and let it flourish? Now to give you that power, so you can do
    the same.

    Throughout this entire exchange of manipulating Scullys trust he
    confessed that he had a "particular" and "special" affection for her. "Particular" is defined as "distinctinve, special, fastidious", meaning
    that CSM was paying very close attention to Scully's life, possibly
    stalking her through is information channels. He also threw in the
    line "I have affection for Mulder too" in order to keep her from
    panicking and leaving. CSM also said his intentions are "honorable". Everything known about CSM tells us he is never to be trusted and that
    he doesn't know the meaning of the word "honorable".

    --------------
    Exhibit D
    The next day, the exchange in the Sedan between CSM and Scully
    continues;

    CSM: You've been at the wheel too long. Would you like me to drive?

    Scully: I might, if you let me know where we're going

    CSM: Knowing that, would you feel comfortable? You'd trust me? How
    long did it take Mulder to win your trust?

    Scully: I've always trusted Mulder.

    CSM: You're not being honest with yourself. Think back. There was a
    time when you feared for your future, for your career, when you were
    first parterned with this man. I've told you, I've studied you for
    years. And if you would permit me, I'd like to make an observation.
    You're drawn to powerful men, but you fear their power. You keep your
    guard up, a wall around your heart. How else you explain a fearless
    devotion to a man obsessed, and yet, a life alone. You'd die for
    Mulder, but you won't allow yourself to love him.

    Scully: Wow. I'm learning a whole other side to you. You're not just
    a cold blooded killer, you're pop psychologist as well.

    CSM: I've been a destroyer all my life. Before I die, I'd like to
    prove I'm capable of something more.

    Obviously CSM was stalking Scully when he said; "I've told you, I've
    studied you for years". CSM's observation that "Scully is drawn to
    powerful men, but fears their power" and that "she keeps her guard up,
    a wall around her heart" was CSM's wish for a relationship between him
    and Scully. All of CSM's other women are now dead or missing;
    Cassandra Spender, Teena Mulder and Diana Fowley. Therefore he
    pursued Scully as a last chance to continue his legacy, not with a
    cancer cure given to Scully, but with a son(or daughter).

    --------------
    Exhibit E
    When CSM and Scully visit the 118 year old Margarie Butters he refers
    to Scully in his introduction as "my very good friend".

    --------------
    Exhibit F
    When CSM and Scully finally arrive at the house in Milford,
    Pennsylvania, Scully is asleep in the passenger seat. CSM puts on a
    pair of gloves, possibly to remove traces of fingerprints. CSM looks at
    the sleeping Scully and gently moves the bangs of hair out of her face
    with with his fingers; he looks as if he wants to kiss her.

    --------------
    Exhibit G
    Scully wakes up in bed, shocked to find herself in a pair of pajamas
    and her clothes hanging in a closet. CSM has had a past history of
    taking Scully to a far away place and removing her clothes. We saw it
    in Fight the Future when Scully was taken to Antartica, stripped naked
    and packed into a cocoon to become an alien digestive. Scully begins
    to panic at the possibility that something happened.

    The next scene shows CSM offering Scully a cup of morning coffee as she storms toward the door to leave.

    CSM: How do you take your coffee.

    Scully: Unadulterated, thank you.

    Scully takes the coffee from CSM and dumps it out the window.

    Scully: You drugged me!

    CSM: I did nothing of the sort.

    Scully: How did the hell did I get out of my clothes and into bed?

    CSM: I carried you. You've been up for over 30 hours. You were
    delerious. I only wanted to make you comfortable.

    Scully: Where are we?

    CSM: Milford, Pennsylvania

    Scully: Well that wasn't part of the deal. I don't know what you're up
    to.

    We know from the previous exibits leading up to the "Scully waking up
    in pajamas scene" that CSM obviously impregnated Scully. Assuming that
    CSM was too ill from his disease to "perform", it's very possible that
    CSM had Scully impregnated by invitro fertilization with CSM's seed and
    one of Scully's missing eggs. When Scully is offered the coffee, she
    says "Unadulterated, thank you". "Adulterated" is defined as "adding undesirable ingredients to". By saying "unadulterated" Scully is
    saying she wants her coffee "undefiled" or "uncontaminated" unlike what
    she assumes happened to her during the night. The next exhibit backs
    up the impregnation scenario.

    --------------
    Exhibit H
    While at dinner, CSM explains the cancer cure science to Scully and the expected contact. In the course of that converstation he tell's Scully
    that he's a "lonely man", becomes emotional and leaves the room.

    CSM: That which makes miracles, can also make great evil There are
    those who would use this power for their own purposes. To choose who
    will live and who will die. Theoretically, I can be cured. Everything
    I've told you but wanting to make right. I'm a lonely man, Dana.

    CSM becomes emotional, gets up from the table.

    CSM: Excuse me.

    It's very possible that CSM had some deep feelings of guilt for having
    Scully impregnated bubble up inside of him, a man who has manipulated everything to his advantage, even his past relationships with Cassandra Spender, Teena Mulder and Diana Fowley. A obvious sign of an
    emotional split personality, with a dominant personality that's evil
    and destroys everything while having a second and lesser personality of longing and wanting to be normal and loved like everyone else. The two contrasting personalies twist the very soul of CSM into a pretzel.

    It was mentioned in another Usenet post that "En Ami" was a Monster of
    the Week Episode with CSM as the "monster". In a way, that
    description is right if you look at this episode from the point of view
    of the story about Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, split personalities within
    one man constantly at war with each other. The episode was described
    by William B. Davis as being inspired by Shakespeare's Richard III.
    Looking into the CSM/Scully impregnation scenario reveals that "En Ami"
    is a combination of Richard III with Jekyll & Hyde.

    -------------
    Exhibit I
    When CSM is outside the restaraunt, he talks to his henchman about
    Cobra, the contact with the cancer cure.

    CSM: Cobra hasn't shown.

    Henchman: What do you want to do?

    CSM: Wait. What else can we do?

    Henchman: What trust you won, Scully won't stick around forever.

    CSM looks away with a troubled look.

    Henchman: What's wrong?

    CSM: Just do your damn job.

    Obviously when the Henchman brought up the subjects of "trust" and
    "Scully" in the same sentence, it troubled CSM deeply. When the
    Henchman asked what was wrong, CSM told him to "do his damn job" to
    hide his feelings of guilt for impregnating Scully.

    -------------
    Exhibit J
    When Scully is sent to meet Cobra, Cobra is assassinated by CSM's
    henchman after Scully gets the disk. Scully almost meets a similar
    fate, but is saved when CSM kills the henchman. He was protecting his "legacy" that's now inside of Scully.

    --------------
    Exhibit K
    When Mulder and Scully check out the now abandoned office building
    their dialogue gives us more clues when they enter CSM's empty office.

    Scully: He was here! These were his offices! What the hell is this?

    Mulder: He used you.

    Scully: Mulder, he laid it all out for me. I recorded it. I mailed
    you the tape. This old woman Margarie Butters. I met her, I saw her pictures, her birth certificate....

    Mulder: You saw what you needed to see in order to make you believe.

    Scully: What about this boy? This boy with cancer? You can't deny
    that. That's undeniable proof.

    Mulder: Even if we could convince his parents to let us march him out,
    how long before that chip in his neck mysteriously dissappears. This
    was a perfectly executed con, Scully. The only thing I can't figure
    out is why you're still alive.

    Bingo, Mulder hit it on the head with out realizing it by saying "The
    only thing I can't figure out is why you're still alive". Because
    Scully is carrying CSM's baby. It gets more interesting.

    Scully: Mulder, I looked into his eyes. I swear what he told me was
    true.

    Mulder: He did it all for himself, to get the science on that disk.
    His sincerity was a mask, Scully. The man's motives never changed.

    Scully: You think he used me to save himself, at the expense of the
    human race.

    Mulder: He knows what that science is worth, how powerful it is. He'd
    let nothing stand in his way.

    Scully: You may be right. But for a moment I saw something else in
    him. A longing for something more than power, maybe for something he
    could never have.

    After Scully's last piece of dialogue, CSM throws the disk with the
    cancer cure into a lake and lights up a Morley, knowing that he has
    doomed himself to die in a few months. The lines spoken by Scully, "I
    swear what he told me was true", "you think he used me to save himself"
    and "I saw something else in him, a longing for something more than
    power. Maybe for something he never had" were subconscious clues of
    Scullys impregnation by CSM without Scully ever being aware of it.

    Conclusion?

    The only reason Scully smiled at the end of "Requiem" when she said
    "she's pregnant" is that she assumes the baby is Mulders. "Requiem" is defined as "service for the dead". CSM was murdered by Krycek.
    "Service for the dead" symbolizes CSM's impregnation of Scully. We
    now know that the dead CSM is the father and will be reborn like a
    phoenix through Scully.

    Yours truly


    Daniel Perez

    Well done. Almost 18 years later and we now know.

    FWIW
    DLM

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From embradine@gmail.com@21:1/5 to All on Sat Jan 13 12:26:13 2018
    I've come back from the future to tell you you were right.

    Welcome next gen X-Philes.

    Bernardine

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From renancardosodossantos8563@gmail.com@21:1/5 to All on Mon Mar 16 12:00:29 2020
  • From Nayane Freitas@21:1/5 to All on Sat Jun 18 18:25:19 2022
    Em terça-feira, 23 de maio de 2000 às 04:00:00 UTC-3, Daniel Perez escreveu:
    The proof that CSM is the father of Scully's baby is encoded within the subtext of dialogue and action in "En Ami". Throughout the entire
    episode, while CSM was psychologically manipulating Scully for getting
    the disk containing the cancer cure, he obviously had fatherhood on his
    mind.
    --------------
    Exhibit A
    CSM cures the little boy of cancer, leaves a Goochland, Virginia paper
    on Scullys doorstep, distracts Mulder from the case with the fake
    e-mails and manipulates Scully into seeing the little boy who was cured
    of cancer the exact same way she was; with a chip in the back of the
    neck. Why? For the purpose of awakening deep feelings of motherhood
    within Scully.
    --------------
    Exhibit B.
    In the office building, CSM tells Scully that she's a "woman of
    compassion" and says the following;
    "In the end, a man finally looks at the sum of his life, to see what
    he'll leave behind. Most of what I've worked to build is in ruins.
    And now that the darkness descends, I find I have no real legacy"
    What does Smoking Man mean by "no real legacy"? That he has no one to
    carry out his wishes for the project to continue. CSM shot his son
    Jeffery Spender in "One Son" and we learned that Mulder is also CSM's
    son in "Amor Fati", but there's no way that Mulder would carry on CSM's
    work. Therfore CSM was longing for another chance to continue, even
    beyond death, and that would mean another son.
    --------------
    Exhibit C
    In the following exchange between CSM and Scully after CSM throws out
    his cigarettes while riding the Sedan, we see more evidence;
    CSM: No sacrifice is truly altruistic. We give, expecting to recieve.
    Scully: What exactly is it you expect to recieve?
    CSM: Your trust. You question my sincerity. You think I'm heartless.
    Would it soften your opinion of me if I confessed that I've always had particular affection for you?
    A sharp glance by Scully at CSM.
    CSM: I assure you my intentions are honorable. I have affection for
    Mulder too. My affection for you is special. I held your life in my
    hands. Your cancer was terminal and I had the cure. Can you imagine
    what that's like? To have the power to extinguish a life in order to
    save it and let it flourish? Now to give you that power, so you can do
    the same.
    Throughout this entire exchange of manipulating Scullys trust he
    confessed that he had a "particular" and "special" affection for her. "Particular" is defined as "distinctinve, special, fastidious", meaning
    that CSM was paying very close attention to Scully's life, possibly
    stalking her through is information channels. He also threw in the
    line "I have affection for Mulder too" in order to keep her from
    panicking and leaving. CSM also said his intentions are "honorable". Everything known about CSM tells us he is never to be trusted and that
    he doesn't know the meaning of the word "honorable".
    --------------
    Exhibit D
    The next day, the exchange in the Sedan between CSM and Scully
    continues;
    CSM: You've been at the wheel too long. Would you like me to drive?
    Scully: I might, if you let me know where we're going
    CSM: Knowing that, would you feel comfortable? You'd trust me? How
    long did it take Mulder to win your trust?
    Scully: I've always trusted Mulder.
    CSM: You're not being honest with yourself. Think back. There was a
    time when you feared for your future, for your career, when you were
    first parterned with this man. I've told you, I've studied you for
    years. And if you would permit me, I'd like to make an observation.
    You're drawn to powerful men, but you fear their power. You keep your
    guard up, a wall around your heart. How else you explain a fearless
    devotion to a man obsessed, and yet, a life alone. You'd die for
    Mulder, but you won't allow yourself to love him.
    Scully: Wow. I'm learning a whole other side to you. You're not just
    a cold blooded killer, you're pop psychologist as well.
    CSM: I've been a destroyer all my life. Before I die, I'd like to
    prove I'm capable of something more.
    Obviously CSM was stalking Scully when he said; "I've told you, I've
    studied you for years". CSM's observation that "Scully is drawn to
    powerful men, but fears their power" and that "she keeps her guard up,
    a wall around her heart" was CSM's wish for a relationship between him
    and Scully. All of CSM's other women are now dead or missing;
    Cassandra Spender, Teena Mulder and Diana Fowley. Therefore he
    pursued Scully as a last chance to continue his legacy, not with a
    cancer cure given to Scully, but with a son(or daughter).
    --------------
    Exhibit E
    When CSM and Scully visit the 118 year old Margarie Butters he refers
    to Scully in his introduction as "my very good friend".
    --------------
    Exhibit F
    When CSM and Scully finally arrive at the house in Milford,
    Pennsylvania, Scully is asleep in the passenger seat. CSM puts on a
    pair of gloves, possibly to remove traces of fingerprints. CSM looks at
    the sleeping Scully and gently moves the bangs of hair out of her face
    with with his fingers; he looks as if he wants to kiss her.
    --------------
    Exhibit G
    Scully wakes up in bed, shocked to find herself in a pair of pajamas
    and her clothes hanging in a closet. CSM has had a past history of
    taking Scully to a far away place and removing her clothes. We saw it
    in Fight the Future when Scully was taken to Antartica, stripped naked
    and packed into a cocoon to become an alien digestive. Scully begins
    to panic at the possibility that something happened.
    The next scene shows CSM offering Scully a cup of morning coffee as she storms toward the door to leave.
    CSM: How do you take your coffee.
    Scully: Unadulterated, thank you.
    Scully takes the coffee from CSM and dumps it out the window.
    Scully: You drugged me!
    CSM: I did nothing of the sort.
    Scully: How did the hell did I get out of my clothes and into bed?
    CSM: I carried you. You've been up for over 30 hours. You were
    delerious. I only wanted to make you comfortable.
    Scully: Where are we?
    CSM: Milford, Pennsylvania
    Scully: Well that wasn't part of the deal. I don't know what you're up
    to.
    We know from the previous exibits leading up to the "Scully waking up
    in pajamas scene" that CSM obviously impregnated Scully. Assuming that
    CSM was too ill from his disease to "perform", it's very possible that
    CSM had Scully impregnated by invitro fertilization with CSM's seed and
    one of Scully's missing eggs. When Scully is offered the coffee, she
    says "Unadulterated, thank you". "Adulterated" is defined as "adding undesirable ingredients to". By saying "unadulterated" Scully is
    saying she wants her coffee "undefiled" or "uncontaminated" unlike what
    she assumes happened to her during the night. The next exhibit backs
    up the impregnation scenario.
    --------------
    Exhibit H
    While at dinner, CSM explains the cancer cure science to Scully and the expected contact. In the course of that converstation he tell's Scully
    that he's a "lonely man", becomes emotional and leaves the room.
    CSM: That which makes miracles, can also make great evil There are
    those who would use this power for their own purposes. To choose who
    will live and who will die. Theoretically, I can be cured. Everything
    I've told you but wanting to make right. I'm a lonely man, Dana.
    CSM becomes emotional, gets up from the table.
    CSM: Excuse me.
    It's very possible that CSM had some deep feelings of guilt for having
    Scully impregnated bubble up inside of him, a man who has manipulated everything to his advantage, even his past relationships with Cassandra Spender, Teena Mulder and Diana Fowley. A obvious sign of an
    emotional split personality, with a dominant personality that's evil
    and destroys everything while having a second and lesser personality of longing and wanting to be normal and loved like everyone else. The two contrasting personalies twist the very soul of CSM into a pretzel.
    It was mentioned in another Usenet post that "En Ami" was a Monster of
    the Week Episode with CSM as the "monster". In a way, that
    description is right if you look at this episode from the point of view
    of the story about Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, split personalities within
    one man constantly at war with each other. The episode was described
    by William B. Davis as being inspired by Shakespeare's Richard III.
    Looking into the CSM/Scully impregnation scenario reveals that "En Ami"
    is a combination of Richard III with Jekyll & Hyde.
    -------------
    Exhibit I
    When CSM is outside the restaraunt, he talks to his henchman about
    Cobra, the contact with the cancer cure.
    CSM: Cobra hasn't shown.
    Henchman: What do you want to do?
    CSM: Wait. What else can we do?
    Henchman: What trust you won, Scully won't stick around forever.
    CSM looks away with a troubled look.
    Henchman: What's wrong?
    CSM: Just do your damn job.
    Obviously when the Henchman brought up the subjects of "trust" and
    "Scully" in the same sentence, it troubled CSM deeply. When the
    Henchman asked what was wrong, CSM told him to "do his damn job" to
    hide his feelings of guilt for impregnating Scully.
    -------------
    Exhibit J
    When Scully is sent to meet Cobra, Cobra is assassinated by CSM's
    henchman after Scully gets the disk. Scully almost meets a similar
    fate, but is saved when CSM kills the henchman. He was protecting his "legacy" that's now inside of Scully.
    --------------
    Exhibit K
    When Mulder and Scully check out the now abandoned office building
    their dialogue gives us more clues when they enter CSM's empty office. Scully: He was here! These were his offices! What the hell is this?
    Mulder: He used you.
    Scully: Mulder, he laid it all out for me. I recorded it. I mailed
    you the tape. This old woman Margarie Butters. I met her, I saw her
    pictures, her birth certificate....
    Mulder: You saw what you needed to see in order to make you believe.
    Scully: What about this boy? This boy with cancer? You can't deny
    that. That's undeniable proof.
    Mulder: Even if we could convince his parents to let us march him out,
    how long before that chip in his neck mysteriously dissappears. This
    was a perfectly executed con, Scully. The only thing I can't figure
    out is why you're still alive.
    Bingo, Mulder hit it on the head with out realizing it by saying "The
    only thing I can't figure out is why you're still alive". Because
    Scully is carrying CSM's baby. It gets more interesting.
    Scully: Mulder, I looked into his eyes. I swear what he told me was
    true.
    Mulder: He did it all for himself, to get the science on that disk.
    His sincerity was a mask, Scully. The man's motives never changed.
    Scully: You think he used me to save himself, at the expense of the
    human race.
    Mulder: He knows what that science is worth, how powerful it is. He'd
    let nothing stand in his way.
    Scully: You may be right. But for a moment I saw something else in
    him. A longing for something more than power, maybe for something he
    could never have.
    After Scully's last piece of dialogue, CSM throws the disk with the
    cancer cure into a lake and lights up a Morley, knowing that he has
    doomed himself to die in a few months. The lines spoken by Scully, "I
    swear what he told me was true", "you think he used me to save himself"
    and "I saw something else in him, a longing for something more than
    power. Maybe for something he never had" were subconscious clues of
    Scullys impregnation by CSM without Scully ever being aware of it. Conclusion?
    The only reason Scully smiled at the end of "Requiem" when she said
    "she's pregnant" is that she assumes the baby is Mulders. "Requiem" is defined as "service for the dead". CSM was murdered by Krycek.
    "Service for the dead" symbolizes CSM's impregnation of Scully. We
    now know that the dead CSM is the father and will be reborn like a
    phoenix through Scully.
    Yours truly

    Daniel Perez

    I had this same theory, but I never thought it would be right, damn.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)