• Plastic bag bans may unintentionally dri

    From ScienceDaily@1:317/3 to All on Tue Mar 29 22:30:42 2022
    Plastic bag bans may unintentionally drive other bag sales

    Date:
    March 29, 2022
    Source:
    University of Georgia
    Summary:
    When cities or counties institute plastic bag bans or fees, the idea
    is to reduce the amount of plastic headed to the landfill. But a new
    analysis finds these policies, while created with good intentions,
    may cause more plastic bags to be purchased in the communities
    where they are in place.



    FULL STORY ==========================================================================
    When cities or counties institute plastic bag bans or fees, the idea is
    to reduce the amount of plastic headed to the landfill.


    ==========================================================================
    But a new analysis by a University of Georgia researcher finds these
    policies, while created with good intentions, may cause more plastic
    bags to be purchased in the communities where they are in place. The
    study was published earlier this year in the journalEnvironmental and
    Resource Economics.

    That's because while plastic grocery bags are viewed as a single-use item,
    they often find a second use as liners for small trash cans. When these shopping bags are taxed or taken away, people look for alternatives --
    which means they buy small plastic garbage bags.

    "We know there is a demand for using plastic bags, and we know, if these policies go into effect, some bags will disappear or will become more
    costly to get," said Yu-Kai Huang, a postdoctoral researcher at the UGA
    Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources. "So, we wanted to
    see the effectiveness of this policy in reducing bag usage overall."
    Previous studies have looked at the effect of bag bans on plastic
    consumption, but not the combined effects of fees or a bag ban. An environmental economist, Huang used a new way to calculate the effect
    of either policy while also accounting for variables such as residents'
    income levels and an area's population density, both of which influence
    the amount of trash generated in a community.

    Is banning plastic bags effective overall? Keeping in mind the second
    life that plastic grocery bags take on in many homes, Huang and professor Richard Woodward of Texas A&M University measured plastic trash bag
    sales in counties with bans or fees in place, and compared them to other counties without such policies. The selected counties were far enough
    away from each other to account for shoppers who might cross into a
    neighboring county to avoid the policy.



    ==========================================================================
    The study found California communities with bag policies saw sales of
    4-gallon trash bags increase by 55% to 75%, and sales of 8-gallon trash
    bags increase 87% to 110%. These results echo earlier studies that also
    showed increases in sales of smaller plastic trash bags.

    But while sales of small garbage bags jumped after policies were
    implemented, sales of larger 13-gallon trash bags -- the size often
    found in kitchen trash cans -- remained relatively unchanged. This
    further underscored the double life of plastic grocery bags, Huang said.

    "Carryout grocery bags were substituted for similar sizes of trash bags
    before implementing the regulations," he wrote in the paper. "After the regulations came into effect, consumers' plastic bag demand switched from regulated plastic bags to unregulated bags." The unintended increase in
    trash bag sales could also be measured by weight. By purchasing 4-gallon
    trash bags, plastic consumption increased by between 30 and 135 pounds per store per month. The sales of 8-gallon trash bags created an additional
    37 to 224 pounds of plastic per store per month.

    But, Huang noted, bag bans or fees could make a dent in plastic waste
    among high-volume stores. The study found that if a store generated
    at least 326 carryout plastic bags a day -- about 9,769 per month --
    the policy would end up sending less plastic to the landfill.

    It's important for policymakers to understand the unintended consequences
    of plastic bag bans or fees before implementing them, Huang said. And,
    if residents are reusing bags for trash cans, it can also affect the
    overall use.

    "There's no clear answer for this," he said. "Whether the provided free carryout grocery bags are reused is a key to determining the overall effectiveness of the related grocery bag policies."

    ========================================================================== Story Source: Materials provided by University_of_Georgia. Original
    written by Kristen Morales. Note: Content may be edited for style
    and length.


    ========================================================================== Journal Reference:
    1. Yu-Kai Huang, Richard T. Woodward. Spillover Effects of Grocery Bag
    Legislation: Evidence of Bag Bans and Bag Fees. Environmental
    and Resource Economics, 2022; 81 (4): 711 DOI:
    10.1007/s10640-022-00646-5 ==========================================================================

    Link to news story: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/03/220329142327.htm

    --- up 4 weeks, 1 day, 10 hours, 50 minutes
    * Origin: -=> Castle Rock BBS <=- Now Husky HPT Powered! (1:317/3)